Enemy team is locked in. It's midnight for them when your last guy clicks go and the war begins. The enemy team would have far less time to attack.Quote:
Originally Posted by Natesd222
Printable View
Enemy team is locked in. It's midnight for them when your last guy clicks go and the war begins. The enemy team would have far less time to attack.Quote:
Originally Posted by Natesd222
Could still be manipulated unfairly.......
Ex: Clan is always ready right at the start (quick donations etc.) They all click ready in the first few hours. Enemy clan is also ready, but sees nationality of the clan and intentionally waits until they all are asleep (as kowalski pointed out) to be ready. This gives them an unfair advantage if they are in a different time zone.
Both clans have to click READY just to start the war immediately. What about if the enemy clan wants to effectively use up the 24-hour preparation day and doesn't want to start the war? Now that READY button has to wait, then it becomes useless.
If a clan starts a war, they should assume the 24 hr prep day, but if they all want the war to start, by clicking Ready to Start..possibly the other clan has clicked ready too, and the war can begin. It's another aspect of strategy I guess..and also convenience in the majoeity of cases.
If everyone in yout clan clicks ready..that doesn't mean war starts...evryone in each clan must click ready...if they both started a war at say 7pm their time...they obviously wont all click ready at 4am in the morning...don't understand why not 1 of you agrees with me. Mentioned it to my clan and everyone loved the idea. Confused because there's no downside.
Natesd222, the Preparation Phase of the Clan Wars has a purpose. Not all clans are always ready. Some have to prepare the troops they're going to use (especially Dragons that take 30 minutes to train one). Another "some" has to finish/rush their upgrades (usually Defensive buildings). The last "some" has to rush their Lab upgrades to be ready for war.
Like I've said, not everybody is ready for Wars. If you're ready, your opponent may not be, though YOU think that they are ready.
You are undermining the depth that some people are willing to go to to be famous in this game. Someone would make a clan of 10 accounts and match with his buddy's clan of his 10 accounts. They would get a win per day, and climb the leaderboard 2X as fast as clans that don't do this.
SC have made a war last 2 days for a reason. That reason being you would have lvl 10 war clans overnight. Hence they will not implement this as it will ruin the legitimacy of cws. End of story:thumbsdown:
Hi Natesd222, first of all, it's not my logic. That's COC's. I just copy it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Natesd222
Second, as JackAtk (#16) said, this is the fairest way for everyone, especially for one who have to work every day from 0900 to 1700.
Also, you'd definitely have people troll by not clicking ready when everyone else is, people would complain and get upset with each other. Clan members who go offline for 12 hours to, idk, have a life, would become villains. It would never work. You would have a fast start about as often as you'd be able to use revenge.
Right now now you can start a clan war search at a time of day that maximizes participation in the first and last hour of the war. Why change that?
There are also clans who war and intentionally lose, but request the opposing clan leave their top 2 guys THs outside so they can loot it. Losing clans members attack 1 and 2 for loot with almost no troop expense, get the loot for their loss, and start a new war. They can do this over and over and over again, where with the current setup, they can do it 3.5 times per week.
You said you are open to listening to reasons against your request. Prove it by letting this bad idea die.