Who donated those troops?

No one is going to confess to donating those goblins on the war map or donating those barbarians when it was wizards that were requested.

We know that you can see who donated troops only if you are online and quick to see the pop up messages that disappear in seconds. That isn't enough. We need to have a way of knowing who continues to donate unwanted troops or just doesn't care about strategy. Its the difference between finding out if the clan member just isn't aware or is just being a jerk. Also, it's not just to find the troublemakers, it would be nice to keep track of who donated good troops on the war map, during war, and regular farming. Clans could keep track and take turns donating expensive troops and such.

If there is already a way to do this then I apologize, but I have yet to find it.

This is just a few of the benefits that this idea could bring to the game. What other benefits are there? What do you think?

then use the existing feature where you can remove existing war cc troops from your war cc. they added it to counter these kind of problems.

But dont we want to know who donated the troops in the first place? Yes, we can remove what was donated, but it is helpful to know who donated. Especially if it keeps happening. We dont want to micromanage clan members but it is an ongoing issue in a lot of clans. What else can we do to counter this problem?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by garrettbn75

But dont we want to know who donated the troops in the first place? Yes, we can remove what was donated, but it is helpful to know who donated. Especially if it keeps happening. We dont want to micromanage clan members but it is an ongoing issue in a lot of clans. What else can we do to counter this problem?

---

well do note that it is currently being considered by supercell
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines

Quote:

---

* History button on clan app - see stats: Last x clans, time in, donations given/received, kicked/left, etc

---

Just hope it'll be implemented soon.

You'd be surprised how many kids (b/c it's always children who do it) admit to donating those troops, if you ask the question in the right way. "Hey, saw we had some members putting some goblins in the war bases. Interesting approach, who thought of that?" or something along those lines. They jump at the chance to take credit when they think they're being praised, then... CHOP.

I like this non-lethal approach. I will use this tactic in the future!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tachoyaki

then use the existing feature where you can remove existing war cc troops from your war cc. they added it to counter these kind of problems.

---

Thats fine but the problem is that if the owner of that CC is not around before war starts then we're stuck. Your answer would be fine if a leader could also remove unwanted troops to clean it out so the proper troops can be donated. But when someone keeps donating barbs or wbs or low level troops - eventually you need to know so you can deal with the root cause of the problem and not keep treating the symptoms.

Why not? This would help us leaders to monitor and identify trollers and hardheads within our ranks and penalize the offenders. Aside from being annoying, donating unnecessary troops especially for clan war is not just a waste of resources and time but can affect the overall clan war experience.

These troublemakers need some whiplash for them to not do it again (and again and again and again...).

I think that they should have either a second donation stat line for donating to clan war troops or they should have it count towards your overall donations. Everyone in my clan hates that they don't get any credit for the war clan castles but do it anyways because we want to win but then If we lose it feels like a huge waste cuz you get nothing for it... Just my thought on the subject

I agree this would be nice to have