Way More Advanced Ranking System

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GabeL

Also don't bump. It's been 1 day since your post and you are freaking out that no one responded. Take a couple deep breaths and just wait for people to comment.

---

idk about freaking out... lol

I was just saying ranks so there could be organization of the privileges, so people won't have to assign each individual privileges. and all the forums i found were about adding specific roles like general or something but I haven't found any where you come up with your own ranks, so people won't have to request for additional ranks of each privilege. Thanks for your feedback

I think there are some good ideas here. I especially like broadening the ability of multiple permission levels or recognizing exemplary performances.

I am not a fan of the concept of allowing outside players to donate clan castle troops though... it could result in very skewed power... say a war of all TH 6 and 7, but level 10 available to one clan, but not the other, donates all maxed troops. A lower level TH can waste their attack squad trying to take out maxed wiz or dragons.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by masalem

Come Up With Your Own Clan Ranks!!

You know how some people are asking for another rank for clans? Well what if the ranks can be made up? For example, you can promote people to elder or co leader still but how about you can give them a rank name? You click the person, you click a button that says "Assign Rank" and it gives you a list of privileges this player will have in the clan. What I mean by privileges is the ability to promote/demote people, send mail, etc. and there could be even more privileges a player can have. By the way, so there aren't complications, you can save up to 6 ranks and those will be the only ranks you can assign. The leader or anybody with the privilege can add/delete a rank. My ideas for privileges so far are:

• Send Mail
• Assign Rank
• Edit Clan Info
• Kick People (depends on the rank) and What People
• Add/Delete Rank
• Can't be kicked by anyone except the leader
• Get exactly what you want in your requests (ex: button in CC that allows you to specify what troops can be donated to you)
• Start War
• Donate to War Clan Castles
• Reserve Someone in War Just For Yourself or Multiple people (maybe)
• Deny the Reservation of Someone in War

If there are any others anyone would like to share I will add it to the list :thumbsup:

The leader will get every one of the privileges above. After you select the privileges for a rank, you can give the rank a name and a position from 1-6 (Position 1 could be the leader and Position 6 could be a rank called "peasant" or something :smirk: you can't use bad words like in global). Position 1 could kick everyone, Position 2 can kick everyone 3-6, Position 3 kick anyone 4-6, etc. To assign a rank, just click someone, click Assign Rank, and click one of the ranks you came up with. Some ideas I came up with are "War MVP" where someone who did really good in war gets a reward for it and they get an extra privilege, "Borderline" where someone is on the verge of being kicked, etc. If anyone would like to share a privilege they came up with I'll be happy to add it to the list. Remember that privileges could also be rewards :cool: Thanks for your time and I hope you like it! Tell me if there are any problems or confusing things :D

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by teladybug

I think there are some good ideas here. I especially like broadening the ability of multiple permission levels or recognizing exemplary performances.

I am not a fan of the concept of allowing outside players to donate clan castle troops though... it could result in very skewed power... say a war of all TH 6 and 7, but level 10 available to one clan, but not the other, donates all maxed troops. A lower level TH can waste their attack squad trying to take out maxed wiz or dragons.

---

That can happen as is with just one higher TH in the war, especially with the Lvl5 perk. Also, it's permitted for war attacks (a TH10 can sit out and donate max troops to all attackers) so why not defense?

It's a valid point. We run small rotations between full clan wars, and often this would actually be an advantage for us. However, especially with lower TH, using attack troops requires skill and low level cc openings minimize how much impact higher level troops have. Clans with level 5 perks do give them an edge, but my experience has been that it's their skills that have earned them level 5 points is their intrinsic advantage, not the troop level up.

We are still a few wars away from perks 5, and we are definitely looking forward to it, mostly to reduce the burden of a few members making most of the donations.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MirkwoodArcher

That can happen as is with just one higher TH in the war, especially with the Lvl5 perk. Also, it's permitted for war attacks (a TH10 can sit out and donate max troops to all attackers) so why not defense?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by teladybug

It's a valid point. We run small rotations between full clan wars, and often this would actually be an advantage for us. However, especially with lower TH, using attack troops requires skill and low level cc openings minimize how much impact higher level troops have. Clans with level 5 perks do give them an edge, but my experience has been that it's their skills that have earned them level 5 points is their intrinsic advantage, not the troop level up.

We are still a few wars away from perks 5, and we are definitely looking forward to it, mostly to reduce the burden of a few members making most of the donations.

---

Very true what you say about skills, but we also have a TH3 (a member's baby account) about to destroy a TH5 with just 2 Max loons😁

I like this idea, but only I`d reduce the amount of ranks. I think 4 is enough Personalizing the ranks names would be fine, tho.