Extend the duration of each war attack to 4 mins

Dear Supercell,

Why are there only 3 minutes to complete a war attack?

You keep adding more defensive buildings and upgrades but don't give us more time in which to destroy them!

This arbitrary 3 minute cut off seems to punish the more skilful players: how is it fair that a 52% attack with the offensive army completely destroyed can score 2 stars; whereas a 96% attack, with all the defences destroyed and an army still rampaging round the base, can get the same (or even less)?

The 3 minute guillotine acts as a artificial leveller, meaning that players with spam or ill-conceived attacks can compete against those with well considered plans (particularly if the less skilful team has a TH10 advantage).

In our clan, we are getting 3-4 of these 90+% raids, in which our armies are still alive, in every war. And it is getting frustrating.

Why not extend the time allowed to 4 minutes?

If you want to reward the players who can still wipe out the base within 3 minutes you could give them a 4th star. That would enable you to fairly reward and distinguish between the average, skilful and expert attackers.

Yours with dwindling patience,

Pugilisk

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pugilisk

Dear Supercell,

Why are there only 3 minutes to complete a war attack?

You keep adding more defensive buildings and upgrades but don't give us more time in which to destroy them!

This arbitrary 3 minute cut off seems to punish the more skilful players: how is it fair that a 52% attack with the offensive army completely destroyed can score 2 stars; whereas a 96% attack, with all the defences destroyed and an army still rampaging round the base, can get the same (or even less)?

The 3 minute guillotine acts as a artificial leveller, meaning that players with spam or ill-conceived attacks can compete against those with well considered plans (particularly if the less skilful team has a TH10 advantage).

In our clan, we are getting 3-4 of these 90+% raids, in which our armies are still alive, in every war. And it is getting frustrating.

Why not extend the time allowed to 4 minutes?

If you want to reward the players who can still wipe out the base within 3 minutes you could give them a 4th star. That would enable you to fairly reward and distinguish between the average, skilful and expert attackers.

Yours with dwindling patience,

Pugilisk

---

Simple.... 50% damage give 1 star, destroy TH and you get one star.
When you destroy 99% and you did not get TH, you can only get 1 star.
50% + 49% = 99%. If someone has a warbase that has max protection on his TH and you did not get it, the other player did best to defend his base.
Instead of feeling sorry that you dont get the extra star, you should give your opponent a (virtual) hand because he knows how to defend.
More time isnt needed either because a quick deployment of troops can destroy everything within 3 minutes.
If your attack goes as planned

You win some, you lose some.
And when you lose, dont start whining for change but accept that your opponent was better.
Oh btw Im a fast player, I deploy my troops very fast but that is because I already spend the time to study the base and make a plan BEFORE I push the attack button.
When you push the attack button and start planning while clock is ticking its your own fault if you dont get the stars that you want