New Clan War idea... Civil war!

​A civil war would be played within the one clan. Two captains are selected and they choose the teams from within the members of their own clan. This civil war could last half of the time that a normal war would. So lets say that you have a 10 member clan, the two captains select 4 other members each... this leaves a civil war of 5 a side.

The way that supercell can make this would be to add another button beside the clan war button for the civil war. When you go in there it looks just like a normal war screen and you can't see your opponent's traps or clan castle troops. Seeing that this is a war between one clan do not add any extra xp for the clan or war win bonus. Civil war is just a practice war to enable the clan members to gain experience in attacking and also to test out new bases. Also inside the Civil war button you could add a chat screen for each team so members can discuss war tactics without the opponent team being able to read this.

I think this would be a great idea as it would allow members of the same clan to compete with each other. It would not be OP because no loot bonus or clan experience points will be added to the clan and a civil war only lasts half of the time of a regular war... All you gain from this is experience which is priceless. Let me know what you think about this because i would most certainly like to see this in the next update!!

I like the idea and you could see who isn't good attackers.

Sounds like a clever way to test bases. There is a link in my signature about the vast exploits this opens up. As much as I would like to attack my friends I don't see it working out.

my clan have been wanting this for months now, we have tried to match up like other clans have done but we have failed to do so, it would be a lot of fun to go against your friends just for bragging rights

It's good idea with potential I like it

Also - who selects the captains?
Along with that - can members of the other team donate to the other team via the normal clan chat

As for the captains, the leader would choose two people, him and a co or whatever. Now hear me out, I like this idea, but what is this but just organized attacking. It doesn't really have enough game impacting flavor for supercell to add, but with a few tweaks it could be better.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Allinone27

Also - who selects the captains?
Along with that - can members of the other team donate to the other team via the normal clan chat

---

Captains are selected by if co-leader or leader start civil war they are 1 captain. Anyone else that clicks be a captain is the other and they select troops.

This could be really bad if it doesn't have any restrictions for instance....if a clan that all has 2nd lower accounts the primary ones can just win over the smaller ones or vise versa. It depends on the loot system of there even is one for a "Civil War"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GabeL

This could be really bad if it doesn't have any restrictions for instance....if a clan that all has 2nd lower accounts the primary ones can just win over the smaller ones or vise versa. It depends on the loot system of there even is one for a "Civil War"

---

There will be no loot awarded for winning or loosing the civil war so it is up to the common sense of the clan players to create fair and challenging teams. As I was saying civil war is for practice and experience purposes only so what would be the point to make a civil war with say for example 5 TH10's vs 5 TH6's. However the small details would be left for Supercell to figure out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CPH3

As for the captains, the leader would choose two people, him and a co or whatever. Now hear me out, I like this idea, but what is this but just organized attacking. It doesn't really have enough game impacting flavor for supercell to add, but with a few tweaks it could be better.

---

I believe that this would allow to test out war bases as well as allow your clan mates to gain experience in attacking. I have provided an idea and i believe that supercell can figure out the small details. I still think that it will help normal clan wars as well add a bit of entertainment to a clan.

Overall really like this idea, though I think adding in some sort of loot would be good since otherwise said practice could get pricey. As a th9 I generally spend (not counting donations) 500k elixir and 4-6k DE per war, having no chance of gaining any of that back would make it far less appealing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iceageg

Sounds like a clever way to test bases. There is a link in my signature about the vast exploits this opens up. As much as I would like to attack my friends I don't see it working out.

---

iceageg, really like your idea here, the base testing idea is fabulous, checked out your full thread. Well thought out!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheWishmaster

Overall really like this idea, though I think adding in some sort of loot would be good since otherwise said practice could get pricey. As a th9 I generally spend (not counting donations) 500k elixir and 4-6k DE per war, having no chance of gaining any of that back would make it far less appealing.

---

Well then how about this. Lets make it that there is a special place inside the civil war button to train your troops. Inside there you can train the troops for free but only use them for the civil war and nothing else. This way you wont spend elixir on troops and there will not have to be a loot bonus. I think this would make it fair.

sounds fun

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CPH3

As for the captains, the leader would choose two people, him and a co or whatever. Now hear me out, I like this idea, but what is this but just organized attacking. It doesn't really have enough game impacting flavor for supercell to add, but with a few tweaks it could be better.

---

If you going to say would work but needs tweaks, givIng a few ideas of what you mean may help to further the thread