Printable View
I was thinking about how cool it would be to be able to attack your self, to test your defenses. You won't gain any loot or loose any troops. This can be done mainly to see where your base lacks in and what to improve on. And also just for fun, you could test defenses of people in your clan. You won't need to train troops, it would show you what troops you have and how many you can use near the bottom. :thumbsup:
Thank you for your time
Its a often requested idea and a good one. But, this shall be devastating for warsQuote:
Originally Posted by Jacknightstar
say... You have a target of your own th level, you could simply copy the design and think for the best place for traps. Then you could attack it for no cost as many times you want till you find a perfect comp for the particular base
also, spies could tell one where exactly the traps are. Overall, a no, though I like the idea, but it needs more thought.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Paari2000
I suppose that may be one down, but there can be a limit, as the example you mentioned, the game should detect if you are copying someones base and not allow you to finish. IDK, but this was just a little fn concept, hope it gets in the game.
How would this "detection of a copied base" happen? Won't happen until you fix all the loopholes.
To clear one loop hole, that may clear more, this cannot be used during war, whether youre a spectator or not, because spectators ca tell people in war how to do it. Just another thought. Please let me know if there may be anything else ou may see wrong with this idea
I think it's a good idea, but as for the "detection feature" stated above.. there are just too many loopholes.
Essentially, unprogrammable (New word :confused:)
While I'm sure there is plenty of demand for such a feature, I think the negative side of the feature is far too great for Supercell to want to act upon it.
What is a negative side to it? Do you people know how long it takes to copy a base? I spend about 20 minutes. A time limit (1 every 2 days) or not being able to use it during wars could fix just about every problem listed. Thanks for making this, I planned on doing it today.
Don't forget revenge attacks.
The very essence of Clash of Clans is calculated risk.Quote:
Originally Posted by mrkw
How many troops should one use before assaulting (knowing that all troops will perish afterwards regardless)?
Do I have the correct army to take down this base? Is my strategy accurate?
If there was an added feature that allowed you to simulate an attack on someone, it takes out that "risk factor".
It wouldn't be fair/fun anymore, regardless of time restrictions on using the feature.
How is this simulating an attack on someone? This is your base we are talking about.
To make it more realistic, refund 1/2 of the cost of all troops used. (essentially, you still have to pay up).
Are you kidding?Quote:
Originally Posted by mrkw
You do know that you can alter your own base to match a rival's base?
Thus, effectively simulating an attack on a rival.
Do you see the issue in that? It would be abused heavily.