Introduce clan war user performance statistics

Hi,
I think it would be very valuable for clan leaders to see users' stats in clan wars. For each user, I would love to have the following information visible in their profile:
- Number of wars played
- Average number of attacks per war
- Average number of new stars per war
- Average number of total stars per attack (including existing stars)
- Average number of defenses per war
- Average number of stars per attack made by enemies attacking this user in war

I think that, based on this, users can more effectively improve their weak areas and leaders can better understand who to accept, who to kick, who to include in a war, etc...

Thanks for considering!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Addieco

Hi,
I think it would be very valuable for clan leaders to see users' stats in clan wars. For each user, I would love to have the following information visible in their profile:
- Number of wars played
- Average number of attacks per war..................:facepalm:............... that should always be 2..........if its not, your not getting in our clan.
- Average number of new stars per war
- Average number of total stars per attack (including existing stars)
- Average number of defenses per war
- Average number of stars per attack made by enemies attacking this user in war

I think that, based on this, users can more effectively improve their weak areas and leaders can better understand who to accept, who to kick, who to include in a war, etc...

Thanks for considering!

---

comments in bold

the rest of the ideas are really cool. I wish I knew my own stats.

SuperCell will not provide "negative data" on any player. So, unlikely this would be implemented, as it is data that would be used to negatively impact the play experience for some players. If you want that data, and the extra work, you can certainly track it yourself.

Also, this data is exploitable ... as almost all data is ...

- Average number of attacks per war (should always be 2, but doesn't differentiate between real attacks, snipes, or drop-n-quit)
- Average number of new stars per war (I have 6, because I'm #5 and always attack the bottom two targets during the first minutes of every war. My wife has 4, because she is #6 and always 2-star attacks the #1 and #2 opponents. Who do you want, my 6 or her 4?)
- Average number of total stars per attack (including existing stars) - see above
- Average number of defenses per war - What counts as a defense? Also, see next point ...
- Average number of stars per attack made by enemies attacking this user in war ... in my old clan, I was TH8 and #1. Attacks only got 0 or 1 star. I switched to an advanced clan and now am #29. I get 3-starred all the time by TH9's.

Point being ... all of the stats you listed are so circumstantial, they do not give any meaningful data.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Uthrac

SuperCell will not provide "negative data" on any player. So, unlikely this would be implemented.....

---

Uthrac nailed it. None of those stats really mean anything because how many stars you get is largely correlated to how hard the bases you're attacking are, and how well your base defends is largely correlated to the relative strength of the players attacking you. And there's no way to know any of that from the stats listed here.

What you'd really need to give this any sort of meaning is some sort of player strength rating, which would take into account not just the # of stars you're getting, but also the defensive strength of those bases relative to the strength of your offense. And not just how well your base holds up, but how well it holds up relative to the strength of who is attacking you. Then you'd actually be able to distinguish between a TH8 that is 3 starring TH7s, and one with the same troops that is actually 3 starring bases on their level.

Getting the balance right on such a stat would be pretty complicated though..sometimes we send a TH9 or even 8 to 1 star one of their top TH10s because it can be the best strategy for us to maximize our clan's total star count. Other times our bottom players will scout or loot because the makeup of our clan is such that we sometimes get matchups where our bottom couple players basically have no shot at 3 starring anything no matter how good they are at attacking, and we aren't going to win if we don't send someone down to 3 star those bases. Or maybe we're ahead enough that the players left can 1 star up high to maximize their bonus. I don't think it would be fair to penalize players for any of these things, but if you had a stat like this, you'd have to worry about this sort of stuff.

PS Uthrac, I like that strategy...sending some low players high so high players can go low.

Good idea👍