Feature: A log of who donated you which troops....

Hi! I love playing clash of clans :heart:
I request that a log should be added about the donations where the user can see which member donated him/her which troops.
It is necessary because there are some members who constantly donate wrong troops and most of the time get away with that.
Adding this feature will help clashers to identify wrong donators.
If this is not possible then kindly add a feature like if someone wants donations he/she can choose from the types of troops he wants. So that when someone tries to donate, only those troops are enabled which the requester requested.
Thank you and happy clashing :heart::o

That was the reason why supercell added the feature of kicking out clan castle troops. Its not perfect, but it gets the job done.

I know about that feature but what if there are only 5 mints left in the war and you request for some high level troops and someone deliberately donates you low level troops but you couldn't notice his/her name and you lose the battle.
Now what will you do with this kind of situation? How will you identify that member and kick him?

You don't let the weak in. Thats the main reason why clans have Troop lv requirements like lv 6 = arch lv 5 wiz. or Lv 50+ to join. I do know what you mean, but if you cant get 2 attacks in before the last 5 hours of war. Thats on you. And during that 19 hours you have time to shift through the clan castle troops getting the best of the best.

I dont think so that kicking all low level players is a solution.
And adding this logging feature (limited logs) is not a very difficult thing. I too am a game developer so adding this limited logging feature will help a lot and is not very difficult to achieve.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Khubaib

I dont think so that kicking all low level players is a solution.
And adding this logging feature (limited logs) is not a very difficult thing. I too am a game developer so adding this limited logging feature will help a lot and is not very difficult to achieve.

---

why not?
And also, wouldn't it cause lag when it gets really long? remember, you get 5 troops at a time

I know that is why i said "limited logging". For example log for last 20 donations can be maintained without causing much lag.

There should be a log in your inbox next to attacks and defenses that shows what you were donated at what time you requested. Not much and its good I reckon

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

There should be a log in your inbox next to attacks and defenses that shows what you were donated at what time you requested. Not much and its good I reckon

---

Finally! Someone agrees with me :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Khubaib

Finally! Someone agrees with me :)

---

It's a great idea and it's plain and simple! :) I hope it gets added.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Khubaib

Hi! I love playing clash of clans :heart:
I request that a log should be added about the donations where the user can see which member donated him/her which troops.
It is necessary because there are some members who constantly donate wrong troops and most of the time get away with that.
Adding this feature will help clashers to identify wrong donators.
If this is not possible then kindly add a feature like if someone wants donations he/she can choose from the types of troops he wants. So that when someone tries to donate, only those troops are enabled which the requester requested.
Thank you and happy clashing :heart::o

---

It's a cracking idea but once you have indentified the culpret, then what?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

It's a cracking idea but once you have indentified the culpret, then what?

---

you tell them off or kick them from the clan c;

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

you tell them off or kick them from the clan c;

---

Does this promote a friendly game?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

Does this promote a friendly game?

---

Does donating the wrong troops promote a friendly game?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

Does donating the wrong troops promote a friendly game?

---

I don't mind what troops I get,

again in your words it won't kill you if you get donated wrong troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

I don't mind what troops I get,

again in your words it won't kill you if you get donated wrong troops.

---

I never said that? I said you giving people troops and them then leaving won't kill you. Quote correctly, don't put words in my mouth like an arrogant fool.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

I never said that? I said you giving people troops and them then leaving won't kill you. Quote correctly, don't put words in my mouth like an arrogant fool.

---

Please again don't be offensive with your replys

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

Please again don't be offensive with your replys

---

It's hard when you're just so so stupid you know.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

It's hard when you're just so so stupid you know.

---

With your very intelligent replys, I can see where your coming from.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

I don't mind what troops I get,

again in your words it won't kill you if you get donated wrong troops.

---

GoldRushBoss just tell me whats the disadvantage of adding this feature?
If you dont mind getting any troops then simply dont check your log to see who is donating you what?
But if someone cares that if he/she is about to go offline and he/she wants strong troops in his/her CC to save his resources and he/she puts a request for, say, lvl4+ archers or wizards and he goes offline. Next time he opens his game and see that he/she has been raided and his/her precious resources are lost because someone donated him goblins for example.
Then what?
Do you think donating wrong troops is being friendly as in this case?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

With your very intelligent replys, I can see where your coming from.

---

You're in no position to judge mate.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

You're in no position to judge mate.

---

Well seems like I did.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

Well seems like I did.

---

You misinterpreted my reply, I said you are in no position to, not that you cannot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DreamyoOOaS

You misinterpreted my reply, I said you are in no position to, not that you cannot.

---

Which position do I need to be in?

Dont take it to the personal level guys. Kindly keep the comments to the game and the thread topic...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

Which position do I need to be in?

---

Where you're actually intelligent, you cannot be stupid and be calling others stupid hence why you are not in the position to judge. ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Khubaib

GoldRushBoss just tell me whats the disadvantage of adding this feature?
If you dont mind getting any troops then simply dont check your log to see who is donating you what?
But if someone cares that if he/she is about to go offline and he/she wants strong troops in his/her CC to save his resources and he/she puts a request for, say, lvl4+ archers or wizards and he goes offline. Next time he opens his game and see that he/she has been raided and his/her precious resources are lost because someone donated him goblins for example.
Then what?
Do you think donating wrong troops is being friendly as in this case?

---

Exactly. It may not be useful to you, but it is to MANY others. I would personally love the idea to be added, as there are always the people who donate things like Giants, barbarians, and other bad troops. I currently have someone in my clan donating Giants - this would let me determine who it is. Also, those haters, well they don't really ever say why they hate it. I've had a few in the past - just ignore them.

+1 from me

Also, I will do you a favor and report the guys who made this an argument thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

Exactly. It may not be useful to you, but it is to MANY others. I would personally love the idea to be added, as there are always the people who donate things like Giants, barbarians, and other bad troops. I currently have someone in my clan donating Giants - this would let me determine who it is. Also, those haters, well they don't really ever say why they hate it. I've had a few in the past - just ignore them.

+1 from me

---

Thank you thank you and thank you! Nobody likes receiving the wrong troops that they ask for, and they can tell the person not to do it so next time they know not to give them the troops they didn't want.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Khubaib

GoldRushBoss just tell me whats the disadvantage of adding this feature?
If you dont mind getting any troops then simply dont check your log to see who is donating you what?
But if someone cares that if he/she is about to go offline and he/she wants strong troops in his/her CC to save his resources and he/she puts a request for, say, lvl4+ archers or wizards and he goes offline. Next time he opens his game and see that he/she has been raided and his/her precious resources are lost because someone donated him goblins for example.
Then what?
Do you think donating wrong troops is being friendly as in this case?

---

I stated this was a cracking idea, and read my reply it states that it may not promote friendly gaming.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

I stated this was a cracking idea, and read my reply it states that it may not promote friendly gaming.

---

And donating bad - REALLY bad troops doesn't? I wanna see this world you live in...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

And donating bad - REALLY bad troops doesn't? I wanna see this world you live in...

---

What you mean by bad troops?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss

What you mean by bad troops?

---

Giants, Goblins lvl 2, barbarians lvl 2

*Nobody in my clan has these low lvls, but other clans do. It may be a high lvl friend helping out his pal on starting out a clan that gets these troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

Giants, Goblins lvl 2, barbarians lvl 2

*Nobody in my clan has these low lvls, but other clans do. It may be a high lvl friend helping out his pal on starting out a clan that gets these troops

---

Thank you for explains this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

Giants, Goblins lvl 2, barbarians lvl 2

*Nobody in my clan has these low lvls, but other clans do. It may be a high lvl friend helping out his pal on starting out a clan that gets these troops

---

I agree, getting these troops isn't fair. And when you can't eliminate the person causing the trouble it makes it worse.

Thank you guys for supporting my idea. Now, how can we tell supercell to take notice ho this? Will they take notice of this thread or we will have to do something else?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Khubaib

Hi! I love playing clash of clans :heart:
I request that a log should be added about the donations where the user can see which member donated him/her which troops.
It is necessary because there are some members who constantly donate wrong troops and most of the time get away with that.
Adding this feature will help clashers to identify wrong donators.
If this is not possible then kindly add a feature like if someone wants donations he/she can choose from the types of troops he wants. So that when someone tries to donate, only those troops are enabled which the requester requested.
Thank you and happy clashing :heart::o

---

Quite frankly, Adding this would be not necessary. How about, instead of having a problem with what u get, you just work with it. Not everyone can send a level 4 dragon or whatever your asking for. Just get over it, and work with what you get. If you refuse to do that, discard than try again.