Clanmate Rating System

Keep this thread alive if you like the idea and add your badge ideas in the same format that I have below. Maybe SC will notice and make it happen!
Concept: Co-leaders and Leaders would have the ability to present awards to clan members to signify their contributions to the clan.

Example: Little Joey performed his 2 attacks in clan wars against a couple of difficult bases, but was able to 3 star both attacks. Co-Leader gives Little Joey a badge of MVP honor...

Badges:

1. War MVP - given to one player who did an outstanding job during a war as sampled above.
2. Loyalty - given to a player who has been with a clan for a long time
3. Donations - given to the player with the most donations for 1 season
4. Guru - for providing wisdom to other members
5. Most Improved - for a player that was low level and learned quickly to play the game

The list can go on, but it would be cool to create the system and it stick with the player to show other accomplishments that "Friend in Need" that is automated.

ADDED CONCEPT:
Members/Elders ability to rate the Cos, Leader, and clan overall.

Example: I join a clan for a week and see great team efforts, I can award the clan a badge for "Awesome Teamwork"

Clan Badges:

1. Teamwork - Awarded to great communication and coordination during war
2. Positive Chat - There are positive chat conversations in the clan
3. Cool Banner - The banner design has a meaning

Leader Badges:

1. Awesome Leader - Given to a leader who is fair with everyone
2. Coordinator - Coordinates war efforts and attacks well
3. Fun - A Co or Leader that has fun with his clan
4. Motivator - Motivates the clan to achieve its goals

These are the few I can think of. If you have more, post em below! :D:D:D

its a good idea but it will have no improvements or benefits to the player or to the game
or else i u think that i am wrong plz elaborate

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tico1177

Concept: Co-leaders and Leaders would have the ability to present awards to clan members to signify their contributions to the clan.

Example: Little Joey performed his 2 attacks in clan wars against a couple of difficult bases, but was able to 3 star both attacks. Co-Leader gives Little Joey a badge of MVP honor...

Badges:

1. War MVP - given to one player who did an outstanding job during a war as sampled above.
2. Loyalty - given to a player who has been with a clan for a long time
3. Donations - given to the player with the most donations for 1 season
4. Guru - for providing wisdom to other members
5. Most Improved - for a player that was low level and learned quickly to play the game
6. Deserter - For the player that gets into a war and deserts the clan.
7. Troublemaker - For the player that comes into a clan just to cause drama and trouble
8. Hopper - Designation for the players that hop into a clan to get donations and then leaves

The list can go on, but it would be cool to create the system and it stick with the player to show other accomplishments that "Friend in Need" that is automated. Furthermore it would encourage more fair play as players would want the positive ones over the negative ones.:cool::cool:

---

This could lead to a lot of trouble in clans, though. By glorifying some members and singling out others, it could create a lot of disparity. Not to mention what global will turn into. "join for free elder..... and every badge"

The idea of rewarding a clan mate for top donation is good. But as a leader or co-leader, you already have the ability to do this. Just mention the top donator in the clan description giving them credit.

bottoms off u explained it right :cool::cool:

I like it - except for the last 3. Also, change the name of the thread maybe, as it's a little misleading

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vishlutishlu

its a good idea but it will have no improvements or benefits to the player or to the game
or else i u think that i am wrong plz elaborate

---

In one sense you are correct that it is not a direct benefit, but it is an added element to motivate players to be in a clan and stay with a clan. Think about it this way... I you were in an army and lost a leg saving another, would you not get some award for your valiant actions? Yes soldiers get money the same we get Gold, elix, and DE, but to be noticed for your contributions is also nice too. The main benefit is to give leaders and cos a good chance to recognize their players. It would be a positive aspect of the game...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

I like it - except for the last 3. Also, change the name of the thread maybe, as it's a little misleading

---

Changed the title... Hope that makes more sense.

As for the last 3, well, that was not 100% serious, but more of a thought... I was thinking that if they did at least 1-5 and if you leave the clan, then you lose the badges it would be more incentive to stay with the clan and be loyal... However, I thought that was not cool either. As I said in a different reply, if you are in the military and you receive a HIGH achievement award like the Purple Heart or something, then you get to carry that honor for the rest of your life. So these badges should stick unless you delete and start over...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BottomsOff

This could lead to a lot of trouble in clans, though. By glorifying some members and singling out others, it could create a lot of disparity. Not to mention what global will turn into. "join for free elder..... and every badge"

The idea of rewarding a clan mate for top donation is good. But as a leader or co-leader, you already have the ability to do this. Just mention the top donator in the clan description giving them credit.

---

I like your idea of putting the top donator in the summary. Problem that happens is that it tends to be the same people over and over again.

As for what would go on with Global, that happens already with offer of elder or co-lead... Since the badges are not going to get us gems really, it is kind of pointless to advertise to give badges freely... As for the disparity part, well that is up to the cos and leader to be good at awards... Just like changing a TV channel showing something you are not interested in, you can change clans if you feel they are not being fair with badges. You can speak up to the cos and leader too... You have a voice... use it! Call them out on that type of behavior... you know what, now that you made that point, let's make it a 2-way street. Just as leaders can give badges, players should be able to rate the clan and the leaders too.

This is an awesome idea imo. I hope it comes in an update and shouldn't be very hard to put into the game as its a small update:)

Love this idea it could use some changes for badges and some could be added in.