Gift gems to clan members

Ummm... If a player has 2 devices, with device 1 holding their main CoC account and device 2 having no account linked, it can be easily abused.

Download the game on device 2. Start a new game, and run the tutorial without linking any GC or Google account.

Build the CC, join device 1's clan. One might even spend 10-20 gems to get it ASAP.

Donate the 250 gems from the tutorial.

Leave the clan, and delete the game from the device.

Re-download, and start from step 1. Since there is no GC or Google account linked to CoC on this device, the player can start over from the tutorial.

Easy infinite gems. There's also the problems mentioned by others previously of "donate x gems for elder" or "donate x gems a season or you get kicked."

Clearly you guys don't see the difference in giving gems/resources and buying. I understand Clash of Clans were made for 13+ but forums should be for people who can comprehend each other's ideas. What this brilliant man has proposed was a system of buying gems straight from your wallet but for a fellow member. Now this may cause tension between clan members who are complete strangers, threatening a member to donate or they'll be kicked but for the clans with family friends or even clans that have been around a long time and actually grew and bonded together this feature would be pretty neat. Going out and getting a Gift Card sending the code to an email would be tons of work, hence laziness whereas one can go and gift the gems in a matter of seconds. Now I know the creators of Clash are in another country but I'm pretty sure I'm talking their language when I say "easy money" This feature isn't needed immediately considering there are other things that is more significant but maybe one for the future. Sorry to be abrupt but instead of arguing about completely different ideas focus on the task or "thread" at hand or don't comment at all 💯

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pblanton1

Ok when u tap visit a players profile that is in your clan there is a new tab that says gift resourses by tapping on this u can buy them a resourse package then theresourses will be added to there profile and they will recive a message saying that u gifted them a resourse package example Preston has sent u a gift of 1000k dark elixer these rates should be the same if u bought them for yourself

---

This is an ok idea, but it opens players to bribes.

EG, if you don't give me 20 gems I'm leaving your clan.

your losing a war by 1star and the only player to attack says give me 50 gems otherwise I'm not attacking.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TrapezoidSteve

Ummm... If a player has 2 devices, with device 1 holding their main CoC account and device 2 having no account linked, it can be easily abused.

Download the game on device 2. Start a new game, and run the tutorial without linking any GC or Google account.

Build the CC, join device 1's clan. One might even spend 10-20 gems to get it ASAP.

Donate the 250 gems from the tutorial.

Leave the clan, and delete the game from the device.

Re-download, and start from step 1. Since there is no GC or Google account linked to CoC on this device, the player can start over from the tutorial.

Easy infinite gems. There's also the problems mentioned by others previously of "donate x gems for elder" or "donate x gems a season or you get kicked."

---

Oh ya......... I forgot about this as my reason why you shouldn't be able to donate resources, but if you could donate gems it would be even worse. This person has a great point.

Being able to gift gems would set up a market for them where one could take advantage of exchange and tax rates to engage in arbitrage.

Additionally it would make it much easier for criminals to setup shops and sell gems at a discount rate using stolen cards or whatever.

These are the same reasons why iTunes gift cards are also country specific.

I just wanna say, Everyone here supporting this idea is a 8 y/o. Just look at the grammar on these posts. :\

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TrapezoidSteve

Ummm... If a player has 2 devices, with device 1 holding their main CoC account and device 2 having no account linked, it can be easily abused.

Download the game on device 2. Start a new game, and run the tutorial without linking any GC or Google account.

Build the CC, join device 1's clan. One might even spend 10-20 gems to get it ASAP.

Donate the 250 gems from the tutorial.

Leave the clan, and delete the game from the device.

Re-download, and start from step 1. Since there is no GC or Google account linked to CoC on this device, the player can start over from the tutorial.

Easy infinite gems. There's also the problems mentioned by others previously of "donate x gems for elder" or "donate x gems a season or you get kicked."

---

Make the cheapest gem package cost 300 gems and only person in clan that knows that u donated is person u donated to

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Billlans

I just wanna say, Everyone here supporting this idea is a 8 y/o. Just look at the grammar on these posts. :\

---

*an 8 year old :)