Gift gems to clan members

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Slaskio

Incorrect. Trading means there is an exchange of already in game resources (gems in this case). This gifting idea is saying to let a person buy gems from their account and letting it show up on a friend/clan mates account. Much better than the alternative since SC gets the full amount of the purchase where someone thats gets a 20$ card might spend it on a different game entirely.

I like this as it does open up clan run competitions more (most donated, most new recruits, best war stars at the end of he month, ect.)

---

Tyhere can be the give me gems or I kick you. Donate x number of gems per season, donate gems to be elder. Stuff. That would be bad to have that door open.

But none of those arguments matter because in the end it would be a violation of SCs agreement with Apple and Google to circumvent their stores. (The fee structure and taxation laws for a purchaser buying for themselves and buying for someone else are different)

So the gift card suggestion was the right answer. I am not sure the problem here, I think a few guys are so fixated on seeing things only one way they can't see an alternative that gets them the same end result.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DARWINIANS

Still, they're related. Well, nearly. Like I said, do what the others have already said. Do you even read the final lines?!

---

Don't question my reading comprehension when you yourself are not setting a good example:facepalm:

they are two seperate things, while milk and cheese are related they are still seperate things. I even gave you a reason why this works better than the alternative method

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Tyhere can be the give me gems or I kick you. Donate x number of gems per season, donate gems to be elder. Stuff. That would be bad to have that door open.

But none of those arguments matter because in the end it would be a violation of SCs agreement with Apple and Google to circumvent their stores. (The fee structure and taxation laws for a purchaser buying for themselves and buying for someone else are different)

So the gift card suggestion was the right answer. I am not sure the problem here, I think a few guys are so fixated on seeing things only one way they can't see an alternative that gets them the same end result.

---

Ok them how bout drop bieng able to donate gems and make it just resourses

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Slaskio

Don't question my reading comprehension when you yourself are not setting a good example:facepalm:

they are two seperate things, while milk and cheese are related they are still seperate things. I even gave you a reason why this works better than the alternative method

---

not that I want to get fixated or anything, but I disagree, trade is any form of giving/gifting whether you expect to receive anything in return or not.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Slaskio

Don't question my reading comprehension when you yourself are not setting a good example:facepalm:

they are two seperate things, while milk and cheese are related they are still seperate things. I even gave you a reason why this works better than the alternative method

---

Like I don't know English. -_- They're related but not the same. Where do you think I live in? The moon?! Jeez...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ironagedave

not that I want to get fixated or anything, but I disagree, trade is any form of giving/gifting whether you expect to receive anything in return or not.

---

You just gave the definition of gifting lol. Trade definition is "an exchange of something for something else" still different but yes similar i guess. Although 1 gets something in return while the other doesn't

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pblanton1

Ok them how bout drop bieng able to donate gems and make it just resourses

---

Donating resources is ruled out because it would be abused. Let this awful idea die.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yanks8981

Donating resources is ruled out because it would be abused. Let this awful idea die.

---

This is gifting buying someone resourses with GEMS which would encourage more in app purchases wich would make supercell more Money

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pblanton1

This is gifting buying someone resourses with GEMS which would encourage more in app purchases wich would make supercell more Money

---

And this will help with rewarding outstanding donaters or war performers

Ok ok ok people enough fighting. I'm gonna clear this up for ya. Trading and giving are definitely different. But that doesn't mean this is allowed because the rules say that donating resources is ruled out, not just trading them.
But it seems supercell would make an exception for this because of all the extra money they could make.