Printable View
I have found that a lot of clans send in people to the clan they are going to war with to be able to scout out the villages and "clean up with hogs". To fix this just make it to where someone who has just joined a clan will not be able to see other clan members villages any different than someone out of the clan for about 1-2 days.
again, for the ?th time, just close your clan if you don't want spies.
Agreed simple but effectiveQuote:
Originally Posted by MrkSjr
- Use the Search Function. This has been requested many times already.
- Reject any join requests when Preparation Day starts.
- Alternative way: set your clan to Closed to prevent Spies.
LOL this "problem" was resolved the day they introduced Clan Wars.
A spy is a member of the enemy clan, often times a member who is not in the current war. They request to join your clan and pretend to be genuinely interested in your clan. Meanwhile, they snap pics of all your clan's war bases and post them online for all the enemy clan to see.
Lets set set aside the discussion of whether this should be permitted in war. As leader of my clan, I don't want to give new members full access to my war base. Give me the power to promote a member to elder, at which point they can have visit my base and see trap placement.
We really just want to protect from new members having the ability to spy. So let's have it so new members can't see the bomb placements. If I make you elder in the clan, u are a trusted member and I have no problems with you seeing my whole base. But if I let you in the clan 5 mins ago, why do you get to see my whole war base? Let's fix that!
Please add a feature that allows me to keep my war base private, or simply make it so you have to become a trusted member of the clan, an elder, in order to have full access to my war base
Perfect solution, right there!Quote:
Originally Posted by Valordjoe
uuumm..... close clan during war?Quote:
Originally Posted by Valordjoe
I have the solution ready!
Step 1: Click edit
Step 2: Set to close
http://i.imgur.com/PbYcsap.jpg
Step 3: Enjoy a spy free war
http://i.imgur.com/yjCU2Bh.jpg
BUT NO ONE CAN JOIN?!?!
You can invite people still. Woah; fixed the issue
Its part of the game and supposed to be. You don't want to discuss, you just want to whine and want a few other guys to whine with you. If you don't like getting outsmarted by the other guy then be smarter than he is.Quote:
Originally Posted by Valordjoe
So spare us this noise. IFR is supposed to be for new ideas to improve the game. Not whining from poor sports that can't win on their own and want help. All you are doing is taking up forum space that could be used by other guys trying to improve the game.
And if you don't want to take my word for it then take Supercell's.
Attachment 111816
We are always at war, so the suggestion to close the clan does not work as that would effectively close the clan to new members. We don't want to close the war to new members.Quote:
Originally Posted by MrkSjr
Why must we close the clan to players who are genuinely interested in joining the clan? If a spy convinces the clan to promote to elder, then the spy wins. Why give new, untrusted members immediate access to all clan information. Perhaps this is a bigger issue for clans at constant war. We war constantly, we get people trying to spy constantly, the question is simply why can't we talk a few minutes with new members and not give full view. Why all the hate? You sound like someone who enjoys spying and just don't want it to be difficult.
I will use my usual answer to this even though we have way to many threads on spying. This will be the shorter version because I don't feel like writing up my full argument.
Although your idea would practically eliminate spying, spying is not something that needs to be eliminated. It really hardly effects the outcome anyway. And you can switch the clan to invite only, and don't accept members who are on the opponents war map. You can even spy back on the other team if the spied on you and you manage to get in.
you can still invite even if your clan is closed. you can recruit after wars or during the war search.Quote:
Originally Posted by Valordjoe
Valordjoe, we are all giving our best solutions to avoid spying. And you just describe all of them as "hate?"Quote:
Originally Posted by Valordjoe
Understand and follow what all the other experienced people say, close your clan when Prep Day starts. Don't worry, you can still invite people to your clan.
OR set your clan to "Invite Only" and only accept those that you have talked to. Don't accept randoms once Prep Day has started. Only accept randoms when War ends. Accepting randoms to your clan during Prep Day/Battle Day will result in having your clan spied on.
If you'll still call these solutions I gave you as a hate comment, then go wait for SC to reply.
P.S.: We, the more experienced Clashers, do not like spying. That's why we're giving all our best solutions to keep every Clan safe from enemy Spies. If we liked (or even loved) spying, then we wouldn't have replied to this thread.