How to build online defending into clash and completely make you rethink attacking

Hello all long time gamer short time clasher first time poster. love the stabiabilty clash puts into their attacking/defending setup, but all all I can think is why can't we fight players while they are online, so I came up with what I feel to be a ballenced way of doing this.

•Online and offline players will be blended in search favoring offline.
•As soon as you see an online player an icon pops up on both players screens, yours saying "online", defending player saying "being scouted"
•defender get the chance to clear pumps and decide if they have what it takes to defend.
•defender cannot use spells
•Attacker gets bonus based on the stars they get and town hall lvl, my thoughts would be at th10 a 3 star online attack should give 200k rss bonus, making attacking players with 80k resources a fun thing to do and possibly pay off good
•this makes attacking an online player a huge risk as they could destroy you easy if there camp is full, or easy kill if they have no troops, or ( my personal fav) gem troops in to defend with ;)
•As soon as Attacker places first troop the defenders screen pops up with the troop bar just as in an attack, he then gets to place what troops he wants where during the fight

So op all valks would eliminate any ground attacks 10-12 drags well.

Well adjust as needed it's not a complaint, wouldn't you like to actively fight online players?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by shadowmeep88

So op all valks would eliminate any ground attacks 10-12 drags well.

---

If fact let's put it out there, im simply opening a fourm on online attack, if you have nothing beneficial to bring to the convo then why even post?

Really think about it your raiding and ooh I'll attack this online guy clicks attack 10 drags appear noooo.

Its a bad idea :/
The game is going to be soooooooooooooo hard

Ughhh come on people, no it would not make they game any harder as I already started its completely your choice to attack an online player and when doing so you take the gamble, it's a win win win, gem troops in you don't have and supercell wins, got no troops ready or not defending rate troops Attacker gets sweet rss bonus, get lucky and have a full set of troops and have a nice fun fight, and still maybe lose ;)

I don't hate it, I think it'd be quite the programming feasco. I can just imagine being in a war (as we normally are) and get the cue that someone is attacking me, taking t whole war army against them. It would be make attacking much more difficult for attackers and potentially more expensive for defenders so maybe an adjustment to attack rewards or defensive victories

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MightyAxStream

•Attacker gets bonus based on the stars they get and town hall lvl, my thoughts would be at th10 a 3 star online attack should give 200k rss bonus, making attacking players with 80k resources a fun thing to do and possibly pay off good
•this makes attacking an online player a huge risk as they could destroy you easy if there camp is full, or easy kill if they have no troops, or ( my personal fav) gem troops in to defend with ;)
•As soon as Attacker places first troop the defenders screen pops up with the troop bar just as in an attack, he then gets to place what troops he wants where during the fight

---

I disagree with these points...
i think attacking online players who have no shield is kinda cool except these ideas are sort of over powered, if someone can use their entire army to defend their base nobody would attack an online players so the added feature would be useless

except for the active defence idea, I like your idea a lot

but the active defence is so OP I would never attack an on line player unless the gem cost was just as OP (100 gems or more for 10 camp space of troops)

attacking online players is going to have to be implemented with the new matchmaking algorithm or revenge will go from the improbable virtual stalking that it is now to actually impossible.

i can't go offline for 5 minutes without shields befor I'm attacked and shields go up again.

if warren is around I'd like to hear how his revenge is working since the update

My thought is this, there are at any given second a half mill online players, how many of these ppl have full army camps of good defending troops? Your load of giants healers gobs barbs all that have no use if I hit with loons and drags, which I would do if I could walk out with 300k+ rss for a decent hit

I don't think it should be known if their online or not. Just sway it so like 1/20 are online and, surprise, you are screwed. People need to attack to get loot and if they know they won't attack so

So some say too much loot some say not enough, and yes my play was a blend ratio of 1:10 when searching, again it's a gamble, you train big troops and either win big or walk home empty handed

In reality though there is no way someone could win an attack against someone online unless they had air and the defender had all ground. I mean 100 troops vs 220 troops when the 100 have cannons mortors wiz towers traps. This would be a SIGNIFICANT change in the entire game. I think there might be something but definitely needs to be fleshed out

I agree what I am suggesting is a massive undertaking, instead of mailing supercell I decided to post here and see what feedback came in then work with supercell after decent response. When speaking with some other players, all of which quit another major moble game I said this, the one thing that game had over clash and the one thing clash is missing is the one on one connection, be that priviate message aka whisper aka activity chatting with one person while chatting in clan chat, or mailing just one person not whole clan, or my fav one on one battles, being faced with someone real time and your skills tested, and only one victor walk out. Wars do this on a clan lvl every few days, but that's group on group. We can do better then that.

So after reading supercells "Read Before Posting" thread (which I did not read before posting ♥♥♥♥ ) I see what I came up with in an hour is on par with at least 5 diff popular ideas, most of which need the base guildlines I've stated to work, but none mention them. So please feel free to post any of your thoughts on this topic and we will form a conduit to supercell to bring a new very cool addition to clash :)