penalize people who leave clan in the middle of war without attacking

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rhgreen82

Think you read into my comments a little to much. Codes for what they did is crazy as well as dumb.

---

Exactly. Hence my point.

You don't get to label folks as pariahs because they didn't want to stick around for the war. If you have a good environment, good folks will tend to stay. Why should folks be punished for leaving a clan that is a bad fit for them, as soon as they realize that they didn't want to be there? More crucially, why would you want to punish the rest of your clan by forcing someone who is a bad fit and doesn't want to be there to stick around...!?

If someone is not going to be an asset to your group, you are better off seeing him in your rearview mirror as soon as possible. The reason for his unsuitability is irrelevant. Just keep in mind that rejection is a 2-way street...it can come from the applicant as well as the institution.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chefkell

How do you know if they can be trusted? We can ask but what good would that do...they lie. You say sit them out a war, but we can't even start war with out them.

Mind you I'm not talking about people who are not in war. They can come and go as they please. I'm talking about people who join a clan, opt in for war, wait until they are in war and then leave without ever attacking. These are people who should be punished.

---

You would rather put someone new on a war map than those who opt out?

If you want to war, just put one of those who opt out... And ask them to hit lower.

Why put someone new, and get ♥♥♥♥♥♥ that they did not stay? If everything fail, just take a really low th to war.. Knowing that it won't use its attacks.

I don't know which is worse. A player leaving during war or a player not using both attacks. Either way, the rest of the team needs to step up and gain much stars as possible...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by adam73647

Make there war timer longer.

A week? Two weeks?

---

This is the best plan, for someone who has just griefed an entire clan of people. Perhaps the formula would be how many people in the clan multiplied by the amount of time left in the war.

What if you want to go visit a friend for 2 minutes, whilst in the middle of a war, but they're in a different clan.

This idea is stupid.

I'd say that it would be best if they were locked into the war until they used both attacks. Or once the war is over they are autopushed out.

While war hoppers can be annoying/disruptive, leaders (and cos) have the responsibility too to curb it. There are 2 common ways, used by many clans, to stop this.

1. Give a probation period. A new person has to be in the clan for a certain amount of days, normally 3 to 7 days, before he can war. During this time, co-leaders and the leader will access his attacking power (based on the replays he shares), donations, activeness, etc before he can war.
2. This method only works when your clan is large enough, and have a feeder clan/ smaller war clan. Have him to war in the feeder for a few wars, number depends on you, and the other co leaders in the clan will decide if he is worthy enough to be promoted to the main clan, for clan wars.

With these 2 methods, it will lessen the chance of war hoppers significantly. However, if your clan is strong in clan wars (ie war clan like mine), covering up for him will not be too much of a problem.

If people are not eligible for war, don't accept them .. it is possible to see if people have left/kicked out of a clan during preparation or during war.

Believe it or not .. a lot of players are kicked during prep, by members of "free elder/free co" clans ..

/Affront, Gliding Penguin

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Harrisman24

What if you want to go visit a friend for 2 minutes, whilst in the middle of a war, but they're in a different clan.

This idea is stupid.

---

This is my objection about this idea too. Last time I was also in the middle of the war and kind of visiting another family clan to watch a reference of a CW attack for few minutes. I absolutely wouldn't wanna get this blind penalty just because of this. Simply disagree.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 84brian

I'd say that it would be best if they were locked into the war until they used both attacks. Or once the war is over they are autopushed out.

---

Locked into war until they use both their attacks? Yea, that's going to work well.