penalize people who leave clan in the middle of war without attacking

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by adam73647

Just throwing an idea out there.

We have never had the problem.

---

Absolutely! When I say 'you' I really mean anyone who manages a clan. :D

Lol people saying taking loot from them is too much...I say BAN them for a week. Lets see if anyone does it again then.

I know that in almost all cases, this might be a good thing, to promote activity. However, my strictly farming clan does 45v45 wars solely for XP, you aren't required to attack at all. So if we just want to take it easy and get XP, most of us would get severely punished. But most clans are war clans so I can see where you're coming from. I doubt they'd ever put a penalty in to be honest.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mrblah15

Absolutely! When I say 'you' I really mean anyone who manages a clan. :D

---

I just realized something as well.

The only person that didn't get attacks in was because we kicked that person. They didn't attack, likely because they didn't want to help after being kicked.

Adding more penalization could also negatively impact some poor sap who joins and gets booted.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by adam73647

I just realized something as well.

The only person that didn't get attacks in was because we kicked that person. They didn't attack, likely because they didn't want to help after being kicked.

Adding more penalization could also negatively impact some poor sap who joins and gets booted.

---

The idea is for people who leave. Not for people who get kicked....Of course the penalty shouldnt apply to them.

We have a small clan, maybe 15 to 20 members. If you are upgrading your heros then you don't have them for war so those people opt out. So we usually have barely enough to war and when we do war it's mostly 10 on 10 so when some screwball leaves w/o attacking it really hurts us. There just needs to be some ramifications if you skip out without attacking. Unfortunately, we have to include them if we want to war.

And I agree it should only be for someone who doesn't attack not someone who gets booted.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chefkell

I am so sick and tired of letting someone new war with us then before war even starts they leave the clan. COC needs to add a penalty for people who flee a war without using both attacks. 1,000,000 gold and 1,000,000 elixir and 10,000 dark that gets split between all the other clan members that are still in war. If it puts them in the negative then so be it.

---

This is the most dumbest thing I have read on the forums in a while. Its even dumber that people support this. ITS YOUR FAULT YOU LET NEW PEOPLE WAR. The fact you want people to lose over a million resources and 10k DE (hold on I need to laugh)..........is HILARIOUS. Supercell would never ever implement something so damn dumb. The fact that people are supporting this goes to show how oblivious many of you are to the problem. This is like the equivalent of letting new players join your clan and requesting right away. Like I said in the beggining, ITS YOUR FAULT. Get over it and dont let it happen again.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chefkell

We have a small clan, maybe 15 to 20 members. If you are upgrading your heros then you don't have them for war so those people opt out. So we usually have barely enough to war and when we do war it's mostly 10 on 10 so when some screwball leaves w/o attacking it really hurts us. There just needs to be some ramifications if you skip out without attacking. Unfortunately, we have to include them if we want to war.

---

I have a small clan of 16, most of the time only have 9 that want to war, so either we include someone and carry them, or we dont war, as for new members wanting to war, i make them wait for next one to see if they are still keen, we are not a war clan, we war for fun, win or lose we aren't bothered.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by adam73647

I just realized something as well.

The only person that didn't get attacks in was because we kicked that person. They didn't attack, likely because they didn't want to help after being kicked.

Adding more penalization could also negatively impact some poor sap who joins and gets booted.

---

You can't attack if your not a member of the clan