Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

I can give you credit for your dedication to hopper hating. You have regularly suggested this idea, been told why its a bad idea, and then instead of learning anything you are back a week or so later trying again to push the same thing. (and frankly every time after your first is really just spamming)

I think you are so mad at them you are incapable of thinking of anything other than a way to hurt them.

But if your idea was put into play, what would happen is the same thing that you were told all the other times you suggested it. To avoid the loss the hoppers would damage your clan more than if they simply left before you are finally forced to kick them.

Oh, and not that you care for all the times you have been told this but it would also kill request clans.

It has also been suggested to you that you should adopt the ways to avoid getting hurt by them in the first place but I see you still reject that. You prefer getting hurt by them over and over and just being so mad after you can't think anything but having your mad on.

---

Excuse me, I never posted on this topic before...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ShameerMasroor

Excuse me, I never posted on this topic before...

---

Post #3

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ey-leave%21%21

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ShameerMasroor

My clans best rule against hoppers is, when a guy joins and requests, we kick them thinking they are hoppers or we give them 1 goblins. 2nd thing you can do is tell them to donate 20 troops before requesting and if they don't. Simply Kick them!

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

Post #3

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ey-leave%21%21

---

Told ya! Never created such a post! First of this kind post... And who the heck says I am posting regularly...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ShameerMasroor

Told ya! Never created such a post! First of this kind post... And who the heck says I am posting regularly...

---

Aliens ?? Nope, don’t think so.

Just stop now before you truly embarrass yourself.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

Post #3

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ey-leave%21%21

---

A interesting idea. Making a clan setting for donating clans vs. not is a cool feature to hinder hoppers. I can dig it.

I personally don't mind donating to them though because it makes my donations look more impressive and I become a higher level.. which in the end makes me look better. I'll donate to all yall mooches!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ShameerMasroor

Seeded from someone else and added a good thing in it. Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave is a great idea to prevent hoppers. But doesn't that mean that Req 'n' Go clans will be useless, well there's a alternative to that. Clans can set whether a person leaves can keep the donated troops or not. Co-Leader's and the leader can set this. This means, Req 'n' Go clans will boom and normal clans can stay hopper proof. And what happens if your clan is "Lose Troops" and you donated to a guy and he leaves? He doesn't get the troops and your donated troops come back to you!

Tell me if you need more explaination...:cool:

---

so instead of requesting troops an leaving.....
he will request troops and use them, then request troops and use them, then request troops and use them, until he is kicked
so this idea helps how?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

Aliens ?? Nope, don’t think so.

Just stop now before you truly embarrass yourself.

---

LOL, I am not embarrassing my self its the opposite way for you...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Snivell

so instead of requesting troops an leaving.....
he will request troops and use them, then request troops and use them, then request troops and use them, until he is kicked
so this idea helps how?

---

No it doesn't help... To do this, it requires a stupid leader...

I like the idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yanks8981

I don't see what the problem is with clan hoppers. If someone joins and requests and you donate a handful of archers and he leaves, youre out a couple thousand elixir, which is absolutely nothing. If someone from your clan has a conversation with the new person when they enter, youll have a pretty good idea right away if that person is trying to find a new clan or just jumping around. There are bigger issues SC should deal with before trying to manage clans for leaders.

---

Hoppers should stay in a clan. Many clans accept people who request more than they donate if that's the reason because they leave because they are too grasping to give some archers.