Idea 1 Is way to overpowering defensively. Idea 2 is stupid in regards to joining req & leave clans. If you're joining Req & leave clans and asking for a specific troop that they're not donating you won't get anything. Then you get kicked and have to req again 15 minutes later, hence it has done nothing.
That said, I don't think 2 is bad, but just the way you use it sounds stupid.

