Printable View
I do not know if anyone ever thought about it that I will write, the more I think it would be a good idea to clan LIDER could give a punishment for members who leave without their attacks in the war.
There is a lot that goes on clan, on the preparation of the war they leave without return.
I think we should end these things should have this tool for each clan LIDER to use, giving a warning to the member and stay in goes to war at least two weeks.
Has anyone ever thought that way?
I don't think SC needs to implement a feature to do this ... clan leaders can do what they feel is right.
In our clan, if you miss a war attack you are suspended for the next war. Do it again within 2 months, and you're kicked.
problem is that there are members who come out to prepare the war and goes to other clans do the same thingQuote:
Originally Posted by Uthrac
1. Don't let them back in if they leave.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazeshini
2. Many clans have implemented a "wait time" before letting new members participate in war. (i.e. You need to wait a week and make at least X donations before we add you to war.)
This can be solved with good leader management of the clan, not something SuperCell should mandate.
A person doesn't want to war with you, there's nothing you can do about it.
If you punish him for leaving, he'll just stay and punish YOU and your clan mates with vulgarity, in every attempt possible so you kick them and they get what they wanted without punishment.
If you force people to stay, to do something they don't want to do, it will backfire on you worse then if you would have just let them leave.
If I were forced to stay in a clan I didn't want to war with, I would change my base to an easy 3 star and hit the two highest bases that have already got at least one star and just one star them again. That way, if you lose, I win. If you win, I still win with plenty of loot without contributing anything whatsoever to the victory.
Oh and plenty of Wall Breaker for every War Castle. Not everyone will be able to dump them in time!
I say punishment would be a member to leave, not participate in the war for a while. 2D to 5D or maybe one week.
Any punishment for leaving is a bad idea, if you stop being mad long enough to think this through you think it through you don't want this either. To avoid the punishment they would simply troll your clan until you kick them and all the trouble they will make (an angry trapped animal clawing its cage can get pretty bad) will be worse for you and your clan than if they had simply left.
The least damaging thing they could do would be to simply drop a barb on 2 bases so that the game shows that they did their attacks and does not punish them. You actually hope they choose that solution because all the rest of them are worse.
Nobody should be forced to attack in wars, but if you turn your war light green then yes if you leave the clan without attacking there should be some penalty.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kazeshini
Yeah, then that member would just attack, drop no troops, then end attack.Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss
genius idea...
P.S. don't necro old threads.
:facepalm:Stop posting on old threads. It is against the forum rules. I don't care if you think you can, you aren't allowed to. It doesn't matter if you addressed the question asked, you aren't allowed to revive old threadsQuote:
Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss
Why can I still comment on these threads if it against the rules? I don't understandQuote:
Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome
Yes, you are physically able to reply, but you aren't supposed to. The only reason why they don't close threads is because the original poster might need to edit the post, or so a Mod or staff can comment on it.Quote:
Originally Posted by GoldRushBoss
What do they class as an old thread? A week is hardly old?Quote:
Originally Posted by ColonelAwesome