New Clan War Idea?

For clan wars fans out there wouldn't it be cool to have a more challenging & competitive clan war? You know how we have to 3 stars in order to consider it a win. In this clan war which I'm calling it "Heroic Clan War" which is a different mode of clan war where you need at least 1 star a base to consider a win. However, in order to get the 1 star you must at least take down the Town Hall to call it a "victory". Meaning that they are no such thing as 50% or 100%! Once you take that Town Hall down, you got yourself a victory!

Since this is a "Heroic Clan War" they are also limits on what players can use. A clan who is attending "Heroic Clan War" cannot use spell,heroes, and dark troops but only can use elixir troops. This makes it more challenging because if they are no limitation then it would be obvious easy to 1 star a base.

So overall, how do you feel about this idea?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Malladus

For clan wars fans out there wouldn't it be cool to have a more challenging & competitive clan war? You know how we have to 3 stars in order to consider it a win. In this clan war which I'm calling it "Heroic Clan War" which is a different mode of clan war where you need at least 1 star a base to consider a win. However, in order to get the 1 star you must at least take down the Town Hall to call it a "victory". Meaning that they are no such thing as 50% or 100%! Once you take that Town Hall down, you got yourself a victory!

Since this is a "Heroic Clan War" they are also limits on what players can use. A clan who is attending "Heroic Clan War" cannot use spell,heroes, and dark troops but only can use elixir troops. This makes it more challenging because if they are no limitation then it would be obvious easy to 1 star a base.

So overall, how do you feel about this idea?

---

Honestly, I think this will just make things complicated since you will change the scoring system in clan wars. Plus, the scoring system in Clan Wars is similar to normal attacks in multiplayers and in the campaign map. 1 star for destroying the TH. 1 star for destroying 50% of enemy buildings. And 1 more star for destroying 100% of the enemy base. In addition to that, is the "Heroic Clan War" an option that both clans will talk about or is that simply an addition to normal wars? Because the preparation and the attack days are 48 hours all in all. So, if this mode will be added to the clan war, it definitely will change. Right?

Probably clarify more on points of your idea. But all in all, good point.