New clan wars

Printable View

April 27th, 2015
Kwiitsoput

New clan wars

I know this is going to sound completely idiotic and childish but I was pondering on how it could be possible to help in a attack against a enemy per say sending a maximum of five troops below a certain level. So people spectating can help when ever a clan mate attacks. Say a low level needs some elixir so he tries and attack but boo boo he can't get through the walls! So a friend just so happens to drop a wall breaker and helps him in! Thank you if you read sorry if you feel insulted just a random thought. Have a good rest of the day.
April 27th, 2015
Victor1234567890

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kwiitsoput

I know this is going to sound completely idiotic and childish but I was pondering on how it could be possible to help in a attack against a enemy per say sending a maximum of five troops below a certain level. So people spectating can help when ever a clan mate attacks. Say a low level needs some elixir so he tries and attack but boo boo he can't get through the walls! So a friend just so happens to drop a wall breaker and helps him in! Thank you if you read sorry if you feel insulted just a random thought. Have a good rest of the day.

Then he doesn't need wb and then watchers drop like 50 wb.
April 27th, 2015
Kwiitsoput

Quote:

Originally Posted by Victor1234567890

Then he doesn't need wb and then watchers drop like 50 wb.

Pic you see near the middle of the article I say how they will only be able to drop a maximum of 1-5 troops depending on their level and strength.
April 27th, 2015
awesomness2016

From a programming standpoint, this would be ridiculously difficult to achieve.

From a gameplay standpoint, a well-planned attack can 3 star most bases on your level, pretty much until you get to TH10, so increasing the amount of troops a player gets on offense would probably make things too easy. But in any case, you need to be more specific with how many people can help any given battle, and exactly how much help can be given...so a total of 5 spots maximum? (I don't think you can vary it based on level).
April 28th, 2015
Kwiitsoput

Quote:

Originally Posted by awesomness2016

From a programming standpoint, this would be ridiculously difficult to achieve.

From a gameplay standpoint, a well-planned attack can 3 star most bases on your level, pretty much until you get to TH10, so increasing the amount of troops a player gets on offense would probably make things too easy. But in any case, you need to be more specific with how many people can help any given battle, and exactly how much help can be given...so a total of 5 spots maximum? (I don't think you can vary it based on level).

I understand your point and as I stated it was just a random little thought. I have taken many programming classes so I know what you are talking about and how much of a pain it is to add or fix a already delicate and over simulated action. I meant how a barbarian takes up one slot in the camps and how the Giants take five. It would be like that but you know more... Delicate. As for the level I guess I can't think of how that can work at the moment but if I do think of something I'll post it. Finally for the number of people not many usually watch battles anyway so, so what if only one person watches and lends a hand. Again just a thought. Thanks for reading no hard feelings have a good day.
April 28th, 2015
codmeister1

This is a good idea. I think that the 5 troop limit is a good idea, maybe only 10-15 slots? that way you cant give them 5 dragons which is totally op. Maybe you could make the troops cost 2x the normal elixir to discourage it unless it was absolutely necessary. A few tweaks and this could be a great system.
April 28th, 2015
Behelith

... Clan Castle?
April 28th, 2015
yanks8981

If only there was a way for a clanmate to assist by giving you anywhere from 10-35 housing spaces for troops to assist you in attacks.....hmmmm... oh there is, its called your clan castle...
April 28th, 2015
yanks8981

Quote:

Originally Posted by Behelith

... Clan Castle?

You beat me to it! :)
April 28th, 2015
Uthrac

Quote:

Originally Posted by yanks8981

You beat me to it! :)

+1

This is exactly what the Clan Castle does.
April 28th, 2015
ShaneHed13

He's asking that spectators can deploy their own troops during battle.

Doubt it'll happen. My wife plays and when we are on the same internet 3 feet apart, my "live" replay is about 4-5 seconds behind her actual attack.

Don't see that working with troops coming in that late.
April 28th, 2015
yanks8981

Quote:

Originally Posted by ShaneHed13

He's asking that spectators can deploy their own troops during battle.

Doubt it'll happen. My wife plays and when we are on the same internet 3 feet apart, my "live" replay is about 4-5 seconds behind her actual attack.

Don't see that working with troops coming in that late.

Even if it did work, I don't see that its worth while. Not only is it possible that too many people are watching the feed so maybe the person he/she needs troops from is not able to join, why should 1 village have to defend an attack by 2 people? You already get clan castle troops that allow you to bring better troops than you can produce into a war, why should you not have to plan for something like breaking through a wall and let someone else do it for you? If you need wallbreakers, bring them with you. If you forgot and didn't realize it until you had started your attack, better luck next time.
April 28th, 2015
dave4586

would ruin the individual achievement of executing a good attack. try again.
April 28th, 2015
Behelith

Quote:

Originally Posted by ShaneHed13

He's asking that spectators can deploy their own troops during battle.

Doubt it'll happen. My wife plays and when we are on the same internet 3 feet apart, my "live" replay is about 4-5 seconds behind her actual attack.

Don't see that working with troops coming in that late.

If features would be humans they would be twins.
April 29th, 2015
Kwiitsoput

Quote:

Originally Posted by Uthrac

+1

This is exactly what the Clan Castle does.

I understand this and what I meant is in its own way yes like the clan castle but more manual. as for the people who feel insulted again sorry just a little thought I had. Have a good rest of the day.
April 29th, 2015
Kwiitsoput

Quote:

Originally Posted by yanks8981

Even if it did work, I don't see that its worth while. Not only is it possible that too many people are watching the feed so maybe the person he/she needs troops from is not able to join, why should 1 village have to defend an attack by 2 people? You already get clan castle troops that allow you to bring better troops than you can produce into a war, why should you not have to plan for something like breaking through a wall and let someone else do it for you? If you need wallbreakers, bring them with you. If you forgot and didn't realize it until you had started your attack, better luck next time.

What at happens if your new and everyone keeps attacking you and your completely screwed? Hm riddle me that? So then a spectator can drop something to help. LIKE I SAID only 1-5troops depending on what it is so you can drop either five barbarians archers or goblins one giant or anything else with below five housing. Have a good day.
April 29th, 2015
Chaoslorder

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kwiitsoput

I know this is going to sound completely idiotic and childish but I was pondering on how it could be possible to help in a attack against a enemy per say sending a maximum of five troops below a certain level. So people spectating can help when ever a clan mate attacks. Say a low level needs some elixir so he tries and attack but boo boo he can't get through the walls! So a friend just so happens to drop a wall breaker and helps him in! Thank you if you read sorry if you feel insulted just a random thought. Have a good rest of the day.

Does that mean that a th10 could drop a withch to help a th4 on an attck?
April 29th, 2015
yanks8981

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kwiitsoput

What at happens if your new and everyone keeps attacking you and your completely screwed? Hm riddle me that? So then a spectator can drop something to help. LIKE I SAID only 1-5troops depending on what it is so you can drop either five barbarians archers or goblins one giant or anything else with below five housing. Have a good day.

Everyone was new at some point. I am assuming, based upon your title, that you mean only clan wars, right? Otherwise, its completely impossible. For clan wars, I would hope you are in a clan that would help you build a base that would be the best possible setup for your rank and give you advice on what to upgrade and such. Regardless, in most clan wars, unless you are in a clan with all TH10s and 9s, all of the 8s and below are going to get 3 starred. Usually the battle is holding them to 2 so others have to waste attacks to clean it up. Yes, I have been in wars where not everything 8 and below is 3 starred, but more time than not, that's what happens. So if you are new (I will assume you are a th8 or less, because I wouldn't consider someone 9 or 10 as new unless you are a complete TH rusher, in which I'd boot you from my clan before I'd drop troops for you), theres a great chance that regardless of who could help you, you're going to be 3 starred. On offense, you shouldn't be attacking bases so much stronger than yours that you cant 3 star them without needing assistance currently not available in the game. If you cant, either drop bases to attack, or upgrade your troops.
April 29th, 2015
Uthrac

If you ever "Watch Live" a war battle, there's a 3-second server delay.

This makes it very difficult for a second player to "drop troops to help in real time."