War Related: Spectators/New people should be unable to see traps/teslas

This suggestion mainly comes from the idea of spies sent to other clans. There are so many threads created reporting other clans for attacking knowing where the traps are that I think something should be done against this.

My suggestion relates to the Spectator rank (if you can call it like that) from the Wars. The spectator rank or title appears when a player is not participating in his own clan's war but is only looking. This can either happen if the player is new to the clan or if the player has opted out of war.

The idea #1: The spectators from the war should be UNABLE to see the traps/teslas of their own clan mates.
Reason: To stop the spying in other clans.

Advantages: People will be unable to spy in other clans and as a result less fake reports will be made on the opposing clans.
Disadvantages: Their own clan mates which are not new to the clan will be unable to see the traps/teslas of their clan mates BUT they can ask one who is participating to show them.

---

The idea #2: The players marked under the title New should be UNABLE to see the traps/teslas of their own clan mates.
Reason: The same, to stop the spying in other clans.

Advantages: People will be unable to spy in other clans and as a result less fake reports will be made on the opposing clans.
Disadvantages: Very few! Usually the players that are new but didn't join the clan to spy DON'T need to check their clan mates bases.


Why I think this idea can be implemented quite easily: Because the spectators are already prohibited from donating troops to the clan war map, so if SuperCell could implement this prohibition I think they can also include one for traps/teslas.

I like Idea 2 more then Idea 1. Sounds good! Should be a big help! But I should note that it might be easier to simply close the clan.. :smirk:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cheeserman

I like Idea 2 more then Idea 1. Sounds good! Should be a big help! But I should note that it might be easier to simply close the clan.. :smirk:

---

I also tend to go for the #2 but it's best to give people to choose from something. If the next replies will focus only on the second idea, I will simply remove the first and keep the second one as main. :smirk:

Either one will work. but it's better to NOT accept these spies in the first place. I suggest to provide the last clan the player was a member of. this can be included in the player profile. this way we can just reject the request to join if we see the last clan was the current enemy clan. it would also be nice to have the last 3 clans the player was a member of so that we'll know if the player is a hopper or not.

Either idea is great.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cheeserman

I like Idea 2 more then Idea 1. Sounds good! Should be a big help! But I should note that it might be easier to simply close the clan.. :smirk:

---

I thought you shouldn't bump dead threads...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by c3yaz

Either one will work. but it's better to NOT accept these spies in the first place. I suggest to provide the last clan the player was a member of. this can be included in the player profile. this way we can just reject the request to join if we see the last clan was the current enemy clan. it would also be nice to have the last 3 clans the player was a member of so that we'll know if the player is a hopper or not.

---

While I don't object to this idea, I don't see it solving the problem as people intent on spying will or already have secondary accounts unaffiliated with the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tisguyz

I thought you shouldn't bump dead threads...

---

And also shouldn't post ideas without searching first. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

I like ur ideas devil but I think the people who have been in the clan( the not new people) can see the new people's traps. If that makes sense lol.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zekeswe

Either idea is great.

---

Well thanks! I hope they will take at least one into consideration. :smirk:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by c3yaz

Either one will work. but it's better to NOT accept these spies in the first place. I suggest to provide the last clan the player was a member of. this can be included in the player profile. this way we can just reject the request to join if we see the last clan was the current enemy clan. it would also be nice to have the last 3 clans the player was a member of so that we'll know if the player is a hopper or not.

---

Well, the new member could just switch 3 clans fast before going into yours. This system you suggest would also require the addition of a "time in" counter to specify the amount of time spent inside. I know that it could easily be avoided by not accepting them, but not accepting anybody since the war started is a huge downfall since you risk to miss good people that actually want to join your clan. My clan is a full one, 50/50, so this suggestion doesn't come from any issues I would be facing, but from the topics I saw being posted and the complaints I saw. The second idea from the two would't hurt anybody so at least for that one I would say "why not".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PvtLeeOwned

While I don't object to this idea, I don't see it solving the problem as people intent on spying will or already have secondary accounts unaffiliated with the clan.

---

Well, the two ideas will block any new member from seeing the traps. The spies cannot send a member to your clan before the war started because they cannot know the next opponent, so from the moment of the war start, the spies will be unable to see anything useful to make their fight easier.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thecoolkyle

I like ur ideas devil but I think the people who have been in the clan( the not new people) can see the new people's traps. If that makes sense lol.

---

Nope I don't really get what you mean XD