War spies

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Phyrian

It's not part of the game, it's people exploiting a loophole.

My clan constantly wars, and also happens to want to recruit. People quit, people don't work out, there are many reasons why recruiting is necessary. If we limited recruiting to times when spies would not be an issue then we would recruit approximately never.

The fact that anyone in your clan can view everyone's war bases is unnecessary, and is the only reason spying works. It would be simple to fix, and would negatively impact only those who practice or rely on spying. I can therefore only conclude that those of you opposed to this idea do so, and I would have no choice but to assume that you do because you can't win in a fair fight.

---

the game's loophole is also part of the game dude, if you want to play the game, you must accept it both good and bad parts of the game.

if you want to search for games that suits your taste, then COC is not the game for you since you can's stand the loophole

Can we just drop the subject? People are obviously entrenched in there own ideas and rationalizations. You have one see it as a no-issue, and another see it as metagaming and exploiting the rules. Both sides are not going to convince the other by repeating the same thing back at each other. If it didn't work the first dozen times, why would a dozen more times have a chance to work?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

Is there anything else they should do to make the game fit your clans style? I'm thinking, if you convince them to rewrite the game for you they probably will only do it once.... So make sure your list is complete...

some other ideas you may want to add

1. Stop opponents from watching replays of failed attacks, so they can't learn where your traps are...

2. Stop opponents from attacking weaker members of your clan.... No more TH-10's taking advantage of your TH-8s

3. Don't allow other clan to use more attacks than you do.... Sometimes your players might miss an attack, it's unfair they get extra attacks.

4. Non waring members shouldn't be allowed to donate for war attacks, so any troops donated as part of an army disapear from CC if used in a war ATTACK instead of a regular ATTACK. It's unfair when your opponent has maxed cc tropps when they are TH-7....

im sure you can find other great ideas that will benefit your clans way of playing from others here... Don't waste the rewrite on just one thing...

---

This is funny. Why don't you go join a real clan? You are obviously very inexperienced in wars. We do all of the above.

No!!

Not a good idea!

Why!!!!!


becasue if this happens..then this will remove the whole point of spying,,,

lozlzlzozlzolz

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

Is there anything else they should do to make the game fit your clans style? I'm thinking, if you convince them to rewrite the game for you they probably will only do it once.... So make sure your list is complete...

some other ideas you may want to add

1. Stop opponents from watching replays of failed attacks, so they can't learn where your traps are...

2. Stop opponents from attacking weaker members of your clan.... No more TH-10's taking advantage of your TH-8s

3. Don't allow other clan to use more attacks than you do.... Sometimes your players might miss an attack, it's unfair they get extra attacks.

4. Non waring members shouldn't be allowed to donate for war attacks, so any troops donated as part of an army disapear from CC if used in a war ATTACK instead of a regular ATTACK. It's unfair when your opponent has maxed cc tropps when they are TH-7....

im sure you can find other great ideas that will benefit your clans way of playing from others here... Don't waste the rewrite on just one thing...

---

lOLZLZL

IT Sounds like you woke at the wrong side of the bed

but you know what = I agree with everything you said

ultimately spying is just a part of the game and I think SC intentionally placed that risk as a part of it.

so no need to complain,

Ohh and one more thing. sometimes we apoint a high level player who intentionally trophy pushed just to spy

WE DONT ENLIST HIM IN THE WAR

and we make him leave before the war begins and will send him our opponent's tag so that he can pretend that he just saw the clan somewhere in the "search clan" list.

so never accept request unless you are 100% sure that he's your buddy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

When raiding, 100% damage does not equal 100% dead village.
When looted, only a small fraction of the loot is taken, not all of it.
When the Town Hall is destroyed, the game (boxing referee) gives a shield to prevent attacks, when realistically such a punch in the nose would mean nothing, and raids would continue.

So yes, like boxing. You have gloves, you have rules, and you have timeouts.

---

Can we just drop the subject? People are obviously entrenched in there own ideas and rationalizations. You have one see it as a no-issue, and another see it as metagaming and exploiting the rules. Both sides are not going to convince the other by repeating the same thing back at each other. If it didn't work the first dozen times, why would a dozen more times have a chance to work?

---

Actually in boxing there is spying too because he send scouts out like in all pro sports to see how good the opponent is. They also watch videos of the opponent.

Another point is war does not mean 100% annihation. One side surrenders and then there is peace and they sign a treaty not to attack each other (like a shield). You also say there are timeouts but you can not call time in the middle of a raid. And we all know there are no gloves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mrkw

This is funny. Why don't you go join a real clan? You are obviously very inexperienced in wars. We do all of the above.

---

He's being sarcastic duh

[Distracting drama text removed.]
[Note: THNSUM's backfired joke post removed as well.]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

Is there anything else they should do to make the game fit your clans style? I'm thinking, if you convince them to rewrite the game for you they probably will only do it once.... So make sure your list is complete...

some other ideas you may want to add

1. Stop opponents from watching replays of failed attacks, so they can't learn where your traps are...

2. Stop opponents from attacking weaker members of your clan.... No more TH-10's taking advantage of your TH-8s

3. Don't allow other clan to use more attacks than you do.... Sometimes your players might miss an attack, it's unfair they get extra attacks.

4. Non waring members shouldn't be allowed to donate for war attacks, so any troops donated as part of an army disapear from CC if used in a war ATTACK instead of a regular ATTACK. It's unfair when your opponent has maxed cc tropps when they are TH-7....

im sure you can find other great ideas that will benefit your clans way of playing from others here... Don't waste the rewrite on just one thing...

---

I totally agree. Best post if ever seen btw!

I Think the replays are ok, that higher players should be able to donate inside there clan for war, and that players should be allowed to attack who they please. It is war the other clans lack of strategy (Letting th10 attack th8) will only hurt the enemy clan. Th7 getting maxed troops, it's the clan. Is it any different from a th7 having maxed troops for a regular multiplayer attack? No.