War spies

For players not active in the current war you guys really need to disable trap, tesla, and CC visibility.

Getting spammed by invites from random people and having to reject them all is beyond annoying.

And no, disabling applications is not an option as we have friends in other clans who swap back and forth often to be social.

I totally agree.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

Is there anything else they should do to make the game fit your clans style? I'm thinking, if you convince them to rewrite the game for you they probably will only do it once.... So make sure your list is complete...

---

I'm sorry, I thought this was the Ideas & Features Requests forums. Go troll someone who can't read forum titles you sad little cat man.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

it just amazes me how many people hate spies but don't mind the replays. Think about it, to stop spying you can close your clan or the least make it invite only. Then no spy can get in. Now let's look replays, after someone attacks you, everyone on the opposing clan can watch it, and help the next attacker plan their attack. You can't stop this, you can't make any changes that will prevent your next attacker from seeing your traps, and clan castle troops. Yet no one seems bothered by this, just crazed at the idea that ONE person on the other team can see their traps. Makes me shake my head everytime...

It goes to my entire post, people get so caught up in themselves and their way of playing they can't see beyond it. Let's just change the game to adjust to the one thing I don't like, forget the bigger picture, it's all about me..... And I hate it when the other clans top player is a TH-8 but they have maxed TH-10 troops in Thier clan castle..... I realize this doesn't bother most players but I added it to make my point, as you can see from your response, you are able to spot a bad idea and dont mind pointing it out in the rudest way possible, while simultaneously being angered by someone disagreeing with your bad idea...

---

Angered? no. Pointing out the guy who is obviously trolling by sarcastically implying that people should NOT be posting Ideas and feature requests in the Ideas and Feature Requests subforums: yes.

As to your post...
We have people from multiple sister clans that pop in from time to time to chat. Closing the clan to invite only = no more being social since a lot of clans war constantly. We are very good at not letting strangers in during wars (unless we are absolutely killing them), but it is the most annoying thing ever to have conversations spammed by non-stop invite requests from spy accounts.

I assume you mean watching the war log replays from previous wars... If someone wants to sift through a few hours worth of video replays hoping to get trap locations... then they frankly deserve to get the intel. If you are talking about current war replays, I see absolutely no issue with that. They blew an attack to get the CC and trap/tesla location, so that allows the second attack to be more of a strategic hit. That adds depth to the game, making the first hit a general strategy based on base layout, while the second attack is countering a base your clan didnt clear the first time.

As for your concern about only one person seeing the bases... in this day and age of facebook groups, instagram, imgur, etc... sharing screenshots from your phone of all bases, with full trap locations, and even CC intel can be done, and shared in less than 3 minutes.

As for the TH troop level imbalances, look at your clan perks. Clan perks completely counter bringing in TH10 ringers for the troops. At level 10, TH7 or TH8 troops = TH10 troops when donated.

As to your comment about the number of attacks, if you dont use all your attacks, that is on your team to deal with. My clan uses every attack, every time. We war all the time, so it is just routine to use both attacks every other day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wrxeter

For players not active in the current war you guys really need to disable trap, tesla, and CC visibility.

Getting spammed by invites from random people and having to reject them all is beyond annoying.

And no, disabling applications is not an option as we have friends in other clans who swap back and forth often to be social.

---

Of course the existing tools are sufficient. At one stage we had 5 clans. That never stopped us from controlling who entered our closed clan and who didn’t.

Keep your clans closed and communicate out of game. Friends in other clans aren’t really friends unless they were friends first.
Set your clan to Invite once you actually agree a known friend wants to enter, and use a simple message to verify entry. Then set it to closed as soon as possible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wrxeter

And no, disabling applications is not an option as we have friends in other clans who swap back and forth often to be social.

---

No, keep the clan open only for when they return. All your posts on this thread are useless. This will be disadvantageous to so many clans, as opt in/opt out means people miss wars, but still help and give feedback.

Communicate through line or kik and open the clan when they return. Simple.

Just join this clan and your problems will be solved

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ighlight=Spies

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

it just amazes me how many people hate spies but don't mind the replays. Think about it, to stop spying you can close your clan or the least make it invite only. Then no spy can get in. Now let's look replays, after someone attacks you, everyone on the opposing clan can watch it, and help the next attacker plan their attack. You can't stop this, you can't make any changes that will prevent your next attacker from seeing your traps, and clan castle troops. Yet no one seems bothered by this, just crazed at the idea that ONE person on the other team can see their traps. Makes me shake my head everytime...

It goes to my entire post, people get so caught up in themselves and their way of playing they can't see beyond it. Let's just change the game to adjust to the one thing I don't like, forget the bigger picture, it's all about me..... And I hate it when the other clans top player is a TH-8 but they have maxed TH-10 troops in Thier clan castle..... I realize this doesn't bother most players but I added it to make my point, as you can see from your response, you are able to spot a bad idea and dont mind pointing it out in the rudest way possible, while simultaneously being angered by someone disagreeing with your bad idea...

---

Your logic is completely flawed. Yes, replays can be watched. But that costs the enemy clan one attack per base. Looking at a 10v10 war, for example, it costs the enemy a minimum of 10 attacks to expose all traps, teslas, etc. One spy can do the same thing free of charge. Also, if I attack a base with all hogs I will not expose and air bombs, seeking air mines, etc.

So your main argument against this suggestion is illogical at best.

You can set 4200 trophy.
Set your clan to Closed, that's how to prevent spies. you can change it when some of your friends wanna join tho.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by THNSUM

Is there anything else they should do to make the game fit your clans style? I'm thinking, if you convince them to rewrite the game for you they probably will only do it once.... So make sure your list is complete...

some other ideas you may want to add

1. Stop opponents from watching replays of failed attacks, so they can't learn where your traps are...

2. Stop opponents from attacking weaker members of your clan.... No more TH-10's taking advantage of your TH-8s

3. Don't allow other clan to use more attacks than you do.... Sometimes your players might miss an attack, it's unfair they get extra attacks.

4. Non waring members shouldn't be allowed to donate for war attacks, so any troops donated as part of an army disapear from CC if used in a war ATTACK instead of a regular ATTACK. It's unfair when your opponent has maxed cc tropps when they are TH-7....

im sure you can find other great ideas that will benefit your clans way of playing from others here... Don't waste the rewrite on just one thing...

---

1. Everybody does it and so it's not like you can't do the same thing to the enemy.
2. If their th10's are attacking your th8's then they're wasting their attacks so why bother stopping that?
3. This is the worst idea in your list. The whole point of clan wars is to see who's the better clan. If your players mess up then oh well, that's your problem, the enemy clan shouldn't have to pay for your clan's mistakes. Everybody has 2 attacks, tell your clan to use their attacks WISELY.
4. This is also a bad idea. They're just using everything to their advantage. If they're a th7 (maybe th8) or lower, they're most likely to be 3 starred anyway, unless the player sucks, if both clans have a lot of high level players (th9+) in the war