Leader can edit war bases

Sometimes, in wars, some players do not have the time to make their own war base, or cannot be bothered to. This leads to an obvious three stars. Also, as a leader, i find that its hard to question a new clanmates war base, because you cant see it. So, my requests are:
1. Leaders can change bases of other members in war, but they have a restriction on how many bases they are allowed to change
2. All members are allowed to see each others war base by visiting them (just like for village visits).

I do not see any issue for my first suggestion. If the leader was not real smart and made his/her member's bases bad, he/she would lower the chance of their clan winning.
Also, if they were making bad changes, the members would leave, which would be bad luck for them.

I would find it so convienient if i could see my member's war bases before i allow them to go into war because i would know who is a good war player and who isnt.


If you do not agree on my first request, you should find that there are no issues about my second request.

Thanks,
Simon

I agree with your second point, about being able to see the war base when you visit while in the clan war section.

but the first point isn't good... It's not fair that a leader has control over someone else's base. As a leader you would have to confront the person who has that rubbish base and if he doesn't listen then just kick him out. And also, if a group of friends made a clan, the leader could prank them by making their bases really bad and screwing it up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ImperfectLion

I agree with your second point, about being able to see the war base when you visit while in the clan war section.

but the first point isn't good... It's not fair that a leader has control over someone else's base. As a leader you would have to confront the person who has that rubbish base and if he doesn't listen then just kick him out. And also, if a group of friends made a clan, the leader could prank them by making their bases really bad and screwing it up.

---

Also true. What if the leader's edit only changed a players war base until he leaves? What if there was a way that a player can confirm the changes that the leader has done to his base?

Leader editing other people’s war base ? Bad idea. You will end up with people leaving mid war.

This all presumes the Leader knows how to defend a war base. Even if they are th8 and have a good defense record, that doesn’t mean a person with th8 knows how to build a th10 war base.

Once again, if you recruit new players, sit them out for a few wars, let them see what you expect, involve them in the clan chat during CW. If you stress the right things, they get the message. Show them what to do and they learn. Do it for them once and you will always need to do it,. Again and again.

Long term member ? You have to live with. We all have at some time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

Leader editing other people’s war base ? Bad idea. You will end up with people leaving mid war.

This all presumes the Leader knows how to defend a war base. Even if they are th8 and have a good defense record, that doesn’t mean a person with th8 knows how to build a th10 war base.

Once again, if you recruit new players, sit them out for a few wars, let them see what you expect, involve them in the clan chat during CW. If you stress the right things, they get the message. Show them what to do and they learn. Do it for them once and you will always need to do it,. Again and again.

Long term member ? You have to live with. We all have at some time.

---

No problem with my second request, right?
I understand that my first request would be a little...hmm...strange i guess, and moderately unfair.
Although maybe there could be a way that the member can accept the edit to his war base

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SimonTheEpic

No problem with my second request, right?
I understand that my first request would be a little...hmm...strange i guess, and moderately unfair.
Although maybe there could be a way that the member can accept the edit to his war base

---

I am indifferent to your second “idea”. It’s certainly be raised many times.
In my clan we use the available village/war base slots to show each other new designs and share advice. Personally I think the only advantage to seeing another person’s war base, is to discuss it with them then and there. Mostly just to brag. I don’t see the need it during normal game play.

E una bella idea ed utile

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

I am indifferent to your second “idea”. It’s certainly be raised many times.
In my clan we use the available village/war base slots to show each other new designs and share advice. Personally I think the only advantage to seeing another person’s war base, is to discuss it with them then and there. Mostly just to brag. I don’t see the need it during normal game play.

---

Well i need it to see who should be in wars or not.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SimonTheEpic

Well i need it to see who should be in wars or not.

---

And you can see it..3 village slots, 3 war base slots..Players can copy any war base to any village then set it sctive. Hey presto it’s viewable during non war time. That wasn’t to hard was it ?
Then tell you clan..no view, no war. Works for many of us. Try it.

It’s a shame you have started to pollute the forum with repeat threads on repeat subjects. You are doing no-one any favours this way, including yourself. It isn’t like you didn’t know just looks like you don’t read other’s posts thoroughly, you don’t search or check a forum, you fon’t accept any advice or some combination of the three.

Right upon reading the title, a lot of possible situations for this came into my mind...

Example,
What if your clan starts a war and your leader is sort of "Stupid" (this is an example, i never meant to offend any leaders)? The leader can then edit everyone's war bases into something stupid that the enemy can easily 3-star it?

Actually, there aren't any "stupid" leaders, as everyone does their best to benefit his/her clan. But the example is just a situation... Don't be offended. Sorry for any offense, though. :D

1st point :thumbsdown:
2nd point :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup: :thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

Leader editing other people’s war base ? Bad idea. You will end up with people leaving mid war.

---

because that never happens right?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ectar

because that never happens right?

---

Fair point. That should read “You will end up with people will leaving mid war ..... if you mess with their base.”

Leaders editing other’s war bases was the topic being discussed but I guess some people have poorer inference skills than others so it needs to be dumbed-down.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OzAudi

Fair point. That should read “You will end up with people will leaving mid war ..... if you mess with their base.”

Leaders editing other’s war bases was the topic being discussed but I guess some people have poorer inference skills than others so it needs to be dumbed-down.

---

XD Do you think i care about spamming threads?

as a clan leader of a low level clan with many noobs, i think its a good idea for me to build their war base for them because its sort of hard to explain to them what they should change. I think their should be an option for this for example the player will have a button on their profile that asks if they should allow their clan leader to edit their war base. i dont see why this is a big deal, its not like the leader is editing your village, you could always take away the option for this so its good idea

This is too exploitable - however, sometimes I would agree with this idea (our top guys forgot to set x-bows to air units too)

This is a terrible idea.

If you don't like their war base that much then you shouldn't keep them in your clan. If they can't be bothered to work at the game then why do you want them?

What's next? Letting leaders attack for other players in war? Do you want to collect their loot for them too? Who's playing their village? You or them?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SimonTheEpic

XD Do you think i care about spamming threads?

---

You have a serious problem. You seem unable to follow threads.
I responded to you. Ectar commented on my post. I responded to Ectar.

Not everything concerns you. I was responding to Ectar and was not addressing you at all. So whether you care or not .....stop spamming you own threads.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Reddigulous

This is a terrible idea.

If you don't like their war base that much then you shouldn't keep them in your clan. If they can't be bothered to work at the game then why do you want them?

What's next? Letting leaders attack for other players in war? Do you want to collect their loot for them too? Who's playing their village? You or them?

---

I guess youre right, but is there a problem with my second idea?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SimonTheEpic

I guess youre right, but is there a problem with my second idea?

---

The second idea is good as far as I can see. The first idea is terrible.