Printable View
I think the clan war should end if both clans have used all their attacks the war should end or if one clan has 1 attack left and the other clan has 0 attacks left and the scores 22-20 the other clan with one attack left the leader should be able to end the war and decide if they want to end the war early.
Or they could add a surrender button
That would be good to.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronaldorz
Not a bad idea, but to clarify, would you be able to surrender the war if the other clan has attacks left?
The war period has to still run to 48 hours because they can't start paying xp and bonus at faster rates. So I do not think surrendering or otherwise declaring the war over accomplishes much.
Perhaps if you are giving up art of bonus and xp points to compensate for the faster payouts. But speaking for myself I would rather wait and get paid in full.
That would be an issue. People have proposed this before, and I responded that the ONLY way to do it is just like in a real war...the enemy has to ACCEPT your surrender.Quote:
Originally Posted by Reddigulous
It is one thing if every single attack has been used on both sides (in which case I see no reason why the war would not automatically end), but say you've decided that you're so far behind that you can't win, but the other clan still has attacks left...if the situation were reversed, would you accept a surrender, or would you and the other players in your clan still want to attack, because (maybe) you have more XP to earn, and you know you're going to win and want to use both your attacks so you get that sweet win bonus?
Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Might be a slight issue for bonuses, but with a 24 hour prep day, and needing the enemy clan to accept the surrender (explained above), how much faster would you actually get to war.
As far as xp, again it wouldn't be that much faster, but it might help out smaller clans a bit since they're more likely to be able to finish wars early, and right now clan perks gives a decided advantage to larger clans, who can lose wars and still level up faster than a clan with 15 less players that is warring at the same rate and winning.
Another wrinkle to consider. If I leave my clan while it is in war am I war eligible whenever the 48 hour window is closed or just whenever that particular war is over? Depending on how that is currently tracked it could be a massive headache for Supercell to implement.
Clans would actually start hurrying through wars to get bonuses at a faster rate. And the current problem with clans making deals would shoot way up too. So yea a lot.Quote:
Originally Posted by awesomness2016
SC has been on chatting with us about it before and that was where they explained about the balance they have to keep in the economy and how changing any of the ways (not just war bonuses) has effects they then need to balance other ways. So if they let the bonuses go out faster they would have to either make them smaller or slow down one or more of the other ways loot flows into the game.
And then there is also the rate at which they want xp points to go out. That wont upset the game economy or not directly, but still I am sure they have a balance in there somewhere whre this would be an issue.
COC is actually very complex. It is its own little self contained world with everything balanced against each other so that if chugs along at just the right rate.
I think it's kinda rare that both clans use all attacks. So I think there should just be a surrender button.