Anti-TH Rushing

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badfish1979

Upgrading the town hall before every single upgrade is complete has its pros and cons just like maxing every single upgrade before upgrading the town hall has its pros and cons. This gives players the freedom to choose their own path in the game, which in my opinion is more fun - not more limitations and restrictions.

---

It is fun only if the players know what they're doing, suddenly most of them don't know.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Disenchanted11

Exactly sir. I don't understand people saying "No" immediately. While we can give our ideas to reduce TH Rushing in the community. Because I'm sick of seeing posts, laughing at a TH Rushers, because they are very smart.

---

If you meant your idea simply as a strongly worded caution/warning to people to try to persuade them not to rush, then the idea isn't completely terrible. I get the impression that English isn't your first language, so maybe there's a language barrier that's preventing you from getting your idea across. If that's the case, then I hope you can find the right words to express your idea. Until then, we're just going to keep calling it a bad idea. Because the way you originally wrote it, and then defended it? Pretty bad.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xitra

If you meant your idea simply as a strongly worded caution/warning to people to try to persuade them not to rush, then the idea isn't completely terrible. I get the impression that English isn't your first language, so maybe there's a language barrier that's preventing you from getting your idea across. If that's the case, then I hope you can find the right words to express your idea. Until then, we're just going to keep calling it a bad idea. Because the way you originally wrote it, and then defended it? Pretty bad.

---

If I got a bad first impression, then it's alright. I think this is the first time someone had suggested this idea, that's why so many people misinterpreted/overacted in it. It's fresh and young, yet can be something better. I'm used to deal with critics.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

A rule I think should be technically enforced, for the good of foolish young players, is that you cannot upgrade your TH higher than the lowest level elixir collector that you have.

Generally, players have elixir collectors a few levels higher than their TH. When they don't, these are the unhappy, kids.

There's nothing inherently wrong with wanting to rush to high level, but forcing a minimum elixir income means that the player can at least build the armies he is capable of building.

---

Having looked at some new members, I think this rule is most important at TH 2-4. Some kids have no idea about economics.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by George1971

Having looked at some new members, I think this rule is most important at TH 2-4. Some kids have no idea about economics.

---

Rushing at that low doesn't even hurt. It's not really until maybe TH8 that it starts becoming important. In fact, rushing to TH7 is probably a better choice than maxing TH6.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badfish1979

Rushing at that low doesn't even hurt. It's not really until maybe TH8 that it starts becoming important. In fact, rushing to TH7 is probably a better choice than maxing TH6.

---

Rushing your Town Hall ahead of your mines and collectors DOES hurt, even at TH4. A little because they run out of elixir to upgrade mines to raise gold to upgrade the TH. A lot because they run out of elixir to be able to build an army that can make a decent attack, or to maintain a respectable donation rate.

My point is that it is the elixir collectors that really matter. Mines and storage will be consequentially required. Little else really matters. The kids need to learn to not rush their TH ahead of their elixir collectors, and the earlier they learn this the better. It is so obvious that it would be suitable to technically require. "You can't upgrade your TH to a level higher than your lowest elixir collector"

The worst case I had, the kid with TH9, and three elixir collectors levels 1, 2 and 3, having spent Christmas present money on gems, was miserable until he upgraded his elixir collectors. He simply couldn't play the game due to not having elixir. With all elixir collectors built and upgraded, at least he could play, even with a pathetic base. Others were not so bad, but similar. (Admittedly, they are all 10 years old)

WHo said people need to play the game by your rules?

No. Everyone should have their rights to rush their base whether you like it or not. If they rush, they rush. You know, some people rush just to get that X-Bow or AQ but that doesn't mean you force them to max their stuff up.

TH rushing isn´t unfair!

I often raided rushed TH´s which were 1-2 TH´s above me. I can get more loot by rading them, while they can get less loot by raiding me.

Because of the loot system it´s pretty fair.

If somebody has a TH 10 with lv 2 troops(really seen that in game!) he only could get about 2-3% of a TH 5 ressources, while another TH 5 can get 20% of the ressources.

A less extreme example: A pretty rushed TH 10 is raiding me(good TH 8 at the moment), he can get 10% of my ressources, I make a revenge and can get 30% of his resources!

So there is no problem with TH-rushing.

I love all those rushers, because that means, more loot for me!;)