Printable View
The Caravan would be a good idea. You unlock it at townhall 8 and its 750'000 Elixir. The Caravan is not a troop. It's a thing you place down sort of like the Archer queen And Barbarian King. The Caravan collects 1 gem every 3 days at level 1. It collects 1 gem every 1.5 days at level 2. But the Caravan has a special elixir sheild so people can't steal your gems.
Do you think it's a good idea?
This is why I hate this section.
Gem mines/collectors are ruled out.Quote:
Originally Posted by PotatoOverLord
Aaaaaww, you love it. you know you do.Quote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
No I really do not. People have become very ignorant here and t seems as if me, you, and Warren spend more time saying this is ruled out or saying how it's a bad idea. When the good ideas come along; no one cares. It ethier all about masterminds ideas (haven't been added and likely won't be added anytime soon.) and Heros. There's 0 effort by the mods to update the ruled out ideas even though we contact them. And it's rather irritating (no offense mods.) how can we be a constructive section if our guidelines are outdated? We're using stone tools here while the guy is over there with a sledge hammer, drill, and laser tech. /end rant.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Then you have people who will say any idea just because they're etheir young (or cheap) to where they would like gems.
Ni offense op; I get you're new. But it took 5 seconds to come up with more gem ideas.
... Y u h8 :p...Quote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
Ill list ressons.Quote:
Originally Posted by PotatoOverLord
- Your thread isn't origional
- No major detail
- Free Gem ideas are suggested over and over
- This is a on the list of use the water in my book.
- We're given free gems from gem Boxes that no one can steal much like your idea.
- We already receive a surplus of gems.
- Gens aren't even expensive and there's ways to get free gems. (Search any clash YouTuber and you'll find it.)
- You didn't read the ruled out ideas.
- You didn't read ruled out ideas.
- You read 8,9 twice.
Sigh. I can't argue. I am starting to tire of it because al I do is get shot for being the messenger.Quote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
FreshSpwn52: We should get 100 free gems for each time we donate spells.
Me: Donating spells is ruled out.
FreshSpawn52: Why are you so negative. I am just trying to improve the game and guys like you are ruining it for all of us. Gosh you are a troll. Why would you be such a troll. Such a negative troll, yeah that's what you are.
Me: <no response is given, to tired and discouraged>
FreshSpawn52 the next day: buuuuump!
FredshSpaw52 another day later: hey guys like my idea
FredshSpaw52 another day later:No comments? Come on guys.
Me: please stop self bumping. you are spamming off other peoples good ideas.
FreshSpawn52: If you have nothing constructive to say then stay off my thread,. I only want positive feedback. I don't want your negativity.
FreshSpawn52 the next day: buuuuump!
You also forgot the guy who gets butt hurt about being told he's got a bad idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
AngryUser68: Donate resources
Me: Your idea is ruled out and would be abused.
AngryUser68: Reported for drug related name (yes this happened 2 weeks ago.)
------Ganja's crew jumps in thread and defends him and how it's a bad idea.------
Thread gets bumped.
starts all over.
After crazy reports; it's deleted after a mod has been messaged. (1 week later.)
Post like that make me not even want to get on here. We post good ideas. But they get tossed down by threads like this. Where is the point?
Didn't forget. I cant go through all the types we get without writing a book.Quote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
Exactly why Dahami left after saying he hated it too. There's a surplus of bad ideas. And there's those rare good ones that people don't care to post on and yet get tossed back because people would rather discuss ruled out ideas. Do we need a new sections for ruled out ideas or what?Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Start a poll in the IFR subforum. :smirk:Quote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
Don't forget me!!! This is my so called "main" hangout area on the forums so I deal with this ♥♥♥♥ everyday and I honestly agree, people are so ignorent. We say "Read the sticky. Use the search function" and people don't. Honestly SC, its waaay past time to implement a quiz to check if others read the stickyQuote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
I have since removed it from my signature, but it had a perfect quote from another user...
If Supercell wants to give away free gems, I doubt they'll need our ideas on how to do it...
Gem collectors have been ruled out. Please read the ruled out section BEFORE posting: http://bit.do/ruledout
Aside from being ruled out, there are a lot of things wrong with this idea.
- Gem collections will ruin the game economy and SC can't really earn money from gem collectors
- Elixir to guard the caravan? Elixir is probably the most expendable resource in the game, not much an issue trying to get it. It's too easy
- Please try to understand the theme COC is taking on. The theme of medieval with a nice fantasy twist. A caravan doesn't fit in the theme.