The Unfairness of Equal Xp Set by a Number of Players

Supercell made a huge mistake. The reason most mmo games don't last beyond player level 100 is because it takes too long for new players to catch up. It takes years to max a clan now.. Supercell is killing one of the biggest areas of the game, clan building. It was already hard for newer players to build clans but in a few months it will be nearly impossible.

If you kill the influx of new clans you also kill war. Simple math allows us the prediction that in a few months matches will be very hard to find... and supercell realizes it now.. What do you think they will do to fix this?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HeliSmith

Supercell made a huge mistake. The reason most mmo games don't last beyond player level 100 is because it takes too long for new players to catch up. It takes years to max a clan now.. Supercell is killing one of the biggest areas of the game, clan building. It was already hard for newer players to build clans but in a few months it will be nearly impossible.

If you kill the influx of new clans you also kill war. Simple math allows us the prediction that in a few months matches will be very hard to find... and supercell realizes it now.. What do you think they will do to fix this?

---

In truth.. no low level was meant to make their own successful clan. Those times are gone, now you need to go with the flow. Low levels were meant to hop around clans until they found a place they can call home. Most clans started from the very beginning of the game as low level players, for example: Adult Aces, and stuck together all this time but now low levels just hop around until they meet a clan requirement they want to join and stay there. Good, low levels are high demand now so your argument is not correct to its extension. Low levels are valuable more than ever, that is if they know how to attack or drop their troops in the correct place. For now, low levels are rocking it.

Clan perk's only purpose is to eliminate small inactive clans. Ever since the update, success rate of people creating a independent clan on their own has drastically decreased. This forces players that can't create their own clan to join stronger clans, thus giving us a much better war matchup. I do agree fully with the fact that TH7 in top 5 gives same amount as xp as TH10 is bad.

The point "it costs a lot for th10s to war". There's a reason there's war loot!
They could host tournaments that reward clan xp. Preferably there would be different classes (higher classes would get more clan xp). Also, they should change the war search mechanic to include the highest ths troop levels (very important now when you may opt out).
Balance is a big issue, you can't make high th clans get op xp, otherwise lower level players in low level clans quit, but still you'll have to SLIGHTLY buff how much xp high th clans get, otherwise they'll complain.
Bottomline: Clans full of higher ths should get a slight edge.

I fully support what the OP is saying here. "Hoppers" a Clan level 5 has a full 50 member clan. Of this clan there are 4 members that are far superior to the rest of the clan. These members ranks are Lvl 91, 93, 119, and 131 respectively with 2 of them having maxed troops as a nearly maxed TH10.

Of the 46 other members in this clan none are over lvl 60 with 28 of them being below lvl 20... yes LEVEL 20!!! Now lets explain the logic here as the OP already did very clearly. This will probably always do a 45v45 war with their top members sitting out (The Leaders by the way). They will be matched up against another clan with a bunch of lvl 20-30 opponents.

Now here is the kicker and if someone can ask this fairly then I am convinced that this is fair way to play, so here it is. Is it fair for a Lvl 6 new player facing another lvl 6 players and have max balloons in their cc? Does it take any skill or hard work to click on the little CC icon when you start a battle? The obvious answer is a definite NO! Once this clan reaches lvl 10, which they did not earn, the leaders will kick all of the lower lvl and start recruiting for a power clan. This is a cheap way to play the game and there should be something done! The best solution I can come up with it to have the matchmaking algorithm include all members of a clan so that Maxed players can't just sit and hide will donating troops to TH2's and 3's in war.

PLEASE someone explain to me how this is even remotely fair or just!?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TrainedNoob

A TH10 cares about those perks because in all top warring clans we have quite a few TH9s. These perks help the TH9s give us the maxed troops we usually give out making it fair for the TH10s with maxed troops. In other words we don't need those TH9s to be TH10 to match our troops standard that we give. And you said why TH10s need more war loot? Because we war and it is extra loot we get... Did you think before commenting? A TH10 can't get high level donations, we can't go above the maxed troop line, but like I said we do want to be given the same level we passionate give out. Why more CC Storage? Because the bases we attack sometimes gives us 600k each... Two attacks in our mirror base rank and we made 1.2+ million. Sometimes our Gold Storage is full or near full and we don't have the space to put all the gold in so we stack it. This space for more CC storage helps us a lot. You clearly didn't read in detail the brief summary I wrote but probably read through the lines and ignorantly comment with no basis. The point of the whole summary was that a TH7 can obtain the same and equal clan war xp as a TH10 or TH9. On the other hand, these clan perks can open possibilities for TH8s in top high level play War Clans.. in my main clan we don't allow TH8s because their troop level is limited and their contribution to donations and clan war donations is extremely limited. With the Lv.10 perk, things may change but if low level player clans get there faster then the TH10 Top War Clans... something is extremely unbalanced. Next time when you comment try to have a solid argument and not just 2 sentences to make your point.

---

You make really long phrases ...

In your main clan you don't accept TH8 because they have only level 5 troops? Serious?

Talk about a selfish consideration about a player value.

Now I understand more why your are against low levels getting as much XP as you. You lost my vote there.

All our TH9s are looking forward to level 5 so they can fill the war CC also because for the last 100 wars, that task was for the TH10s alone except for the witches which TH9 could fill. It might take us a bit longer than clans full of TH4-TH7. But we'll get there as a team.

The quality of an argument is not determined by the number of words you know. Or as you pointed out with low level clans, having too many words in a sentence doesn't make the sentence more valuable.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by blackcollector

You make really long phrases ...

In your main clan you don't accept TH8 because they have only level 5 troops? Serious?

Talk about a selfish consideration about a player value.

Now I understand more why your are against low levels getting as much XP as you. You lost my vote there.

All our TH9s are looking forward to level 5 so they can fill the war CC also because for the last 100 wars, that task was for the TH10s alone except for the witches which TH9 could fill. It might take us a bit longer than clans full of TH4-TH7. But we'll get there as a team.

The quality of an argument is not determined by the number of words you know. Or as you pointed out with low level clans, having too many words in a sentence doesn't make the sentence more valuable.

---

You do realize this has nothing to do with the overall concept of this post? Maybe you shouldn't try to knitpick at the little things that wasn't part of the original arguement and actually think about the well put together arguement the OP is making here.

Level 5 Clans are "ruling" the CoC world? Seriously? They got there the same way any other clan can, by winning wars or just losing enough of them.

You're also conflating league rankings with individual player exp level with clan exp level with town hall levels.

Can someone explain to me what perks are even worth this discussion?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by somethingtofill

Level 5 Clans are "ruling" the CoC world? Seriously? They got there the same way any other clan can, by winning wars or just losing enough of them.

You're also conflating league rankings with individual player exp level with clan exp level with town hall levels.

---

Another ignorant response. Read all of the posts before being so Naive!