New idea for using heroes in War

Printable View

April 14th, 2015
40jumpstreet

New idea for using heroes in War

First of all im a th 9 maxed out except walls and heroes I have a lvl 20 king and a lvl 19 queen I keep em both upgrading all the time the thing is most clans won't allow me to be in war since I don't have both my heroes.
Supercell say it's not possible for us to have heroes in war while upgrading due to some coding issue(which we all know is not true) so my idea here is supercell should start a subscription for like 5 dollars a month to allow people to use their heroes in war this wAy they keep earning money and we get to use em while upgrading without dishing out lots of money.
April 14th, 2015
bstick7

Quote:

Originally Posted by 40jumpstreet

First of all im a th 9 maxed out except walls and heroes I have a lvl 20 king and a lvl 19 queen I keep em both upgrading all the time the thing is most clans won't allow me to be in war since I don't have both my heroes.
Supercell say it's not possible for us to have heroes in war while upgrading due to some coding issue(which we all know is not true) so my idea here is supercell should start a subscription for like 5 dollars a month to allow people to use their heroes in war this wAy they keep earning money and we get to use em while upgrading without dishing out lots of money.

or they could just allow it. they say coding issue, but personally i dont believe it is hard at all. it's almost like how if you upgrade a building it doesn't upgrade in war, and that was already like that when clan wars first came out.
April 14th, 2015
Livevil

I don't understand these threads. You guys want to eat your cake and have it too.
April 14th, 2015
OzAudi

Quote:

Originally Posted by 40jumpstreet

First of all im a th 9 maxed out except walls and heroes I have a lvl 20 king and a lvl 19 queen I keep em both upgrading all the time the thing is most clans won't allow me to be in war since I don't have both my heroes.
Supercell say it's not possible for us to have heroes in war while upgrading due to some coding issue(which we all know is not true) so my idea here is supercell should start a subscription for like 5 dollars a month to allow people to use their heroes in war this wAy they keep earning money and we get to use em while upgrading without dishing out lots of money.

If you are willng to pay an additional premium monthly, just buy gems and manage their use yourself. Far more flexible.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bstick7

or they could just allow it. they say coding issue, but personally i dont believe it is hard at all. it's almost like how if you upgrade a building it doesn't upgrade in war, and that was already like that when clan wars first came out.

Bad analogy. Your heroes are available in defense..just like defense buildings...as part of your war base...but at the level.they are at start of battle day. The difference is offense comes from your village, which is a different entity to your war base.

I’m pretty sure the implementation iis far more involved than many assume. Coding might be relatively simple, - we don’t really know - but incorporating that code into the entire system is another issue and much more difficult.
April 14th, 2015
OzAudi

Quote:

Originally Posted by Livevil

I don't understand these threads. You guys want to eat your cake and have it too.

^^^^^
This.
April 14th, 2015
Bighundy

5$ a month??? LOL

You know how much they make off of people gemming heroes for war?

hahaha thanks for the laugh
April 14th, 2015
Tchoa

Quote:

Originally Posted by 40jumpstreet

First of all im a th 9 maxed out except walls and heroes I have a lvl 20 king and a lvl 19 queen I keep em both upgrading all the time the thing is most clans won't allow me to be in war since I don't have both my heroes.
Supercell say it's not possible for us to have heroes in war while upgrading due to some coding issue(which we all know is not true) so my idea here is supercell should start a subscription for like 5 dollars a month to allow people to use their heroes in war this wAy they keep earning money and we get to use em while upgrading without dishing out lots of money.

They never said it was impossible.
They just say it was not possible to have them available for war,
but still upgrading for multiplayer game....

Remember that defense come from a "screenshot" of your base.
Attack come from classical game.
April 14th, 2015
AJabbar

Remember the hero level at the start time of the war.. Make that level hero appear in your attack troops when you're attacking in Clan Wars regardless if it got upgraded during the war or still upgrading!

var KingLevel = 17;
var QueenLevel = 20;

ClanWarAttack()
{
DeploymentTroops(Golems, Pekkas, Wizards, BK[KingLevel], AQ[QueenLevel],...,......,.......);
InitializeAttackScreen(VillageID);
}

How hard that must be??
April 14th, 2015
Godzilla86

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tchoa

They never said it was impossible.
They just say it was not possible to have them available for war,
but still upgrading for multiplayer game....

They can make upgrading defenses work in war so it's perfectly possible to do the same for heroes.

They just don't wanna butcher their cash cow :)
Their choice really and I can understand it because they are a company after all and they have to earn their living, but I really wish they stopped lying about stuff.
April 14th, 2015
Bake1986

A monthly subscription now? These ideas just get crazier o_O
April 14th, 2015
antimatter

Quote:

Originally Posted by 40jumpstreet

First of all im a th 9 maxed out except walls and heroes I have a lvl 20 king and a lvl 19 queen I keep em both upgrading all the time the thing is most clans won't allow me to be in war since I don't have both my heroes.
Supercell say it's not possible for us to have heroes in war while upgrading due to some coding issue(which we all know is not true) so my idea here is supercell should start a subscription for like 5 dollars a month to allow people to use their heroes in war this wAy they keep earning money and we get to use em while upgrading without dishing out lots of money.

thats extremley unfair for the poor people playing , no?

but those milllionares get a max th 10 in minutes and we have to farm it..

i like the idea. if their not gonna make it free then we will pay for having heroes in war.

but having that will lessen their income from people gemming the 7 days which will dish them more money, no?

lol in scs case, this will never happen.but love the idea
April 14th, 2015
OzAudi

Quote:

Originally Posted by AJabbar

Remember the hero level at the start time of the war.. Make that level hero appear in your attack troops when you're attacking in Clan Wars regardless if it got upgraded during the war or still upgrading!

var KingLevel = 17;
var QueenLevel = 20;

ClanWarAttack()
{
DeploymentTroops(Golems, Pekkas, Wizards, BK[KingLevel], AQ[QueenLevel],...,......,.......);
InitializeAttackScreen(VillageID);
}

How hard that must be??

Wow. That looks so easy. I wonder why people even charge money for this skill. It is obviously soo simple.

If SC doesn’t immediately give you a job, fly you around the world to meet the entire team and SHOW YOU HOW A FEW LINES OF CODE IN ISOLATION CAN STUFF UP THE WHOLE SYSTEM, then I guess you can always start your own games company. I look forward to your first product.
April 14th, 2015
vekool

SUPERCELL RESPONSE.

We thank you for providing such a simple to understand code. Here is what happens when we use it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AJabbar

var KingLevel = 17;
var QueenLevel = 20;

It works till here

Quote:

Originally Posted by AJabbar

ClanWarAttack()
{
DeploymentTroops(Golems, Pekkas, Wizards, BK[KingLevel], AQ[QueenLevel],...,......,.......);

We get the following error at this step

1) HeroNotFoundException has occurred. Do you want to debug this (Yes/No).

2) We click Yes.

3) Debugging requires (3456 Gems). How do you want to pay.
a) App Store
b) Play Store
c) Paypal
d) Bank Transfer
e) I cannot pay.

We select e) I cannot pay.

4) HeroNotFoundException has occured. No debugging allowed peasant.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AJabbar

InitializeAttackScreen(VillageID);
}

How hard that must be??

It's very hard to spend gems just to debug ^^.
April 14th, 2015
Jomarx3me

Quote:

Originally Posted by 40jumpstreet

First of all im a th 9 maxed out except walls and heroes I have a lvl 20 king and a lvl 19 queen I keep em both upgrading all the time the thing is most clans won't allow me to be in war since I don't have both my heroes.
Supercell say it's not possible for us to have heroes in war while upgrading due to some coding issue(which we all know is not true) so my idea here is supercell should start a subscription for like 5 dollars a month to allow people to use their heroes in war this wAy they keep earning money and we get to use em while upgrading without dishing out lots of money.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bstick7

or they could just allow it. they say coding issue, but personally i dont believe it is hard at all. it's almost like how if you upgrade a building it doesn't upgrade in war, and that was already like that when clan wars first came out.

:facepalm::facepalm::facepalm:

Quote:

Originally Posted by AJabbar

Remember the hero level at the start time of the war.. Make that level hero appear in your attack troops when you're attacking in Clan Wars regardless if it got upgraded during the war or still upgrading!

var KingLevel = 17;
var QueenLevel = 20;

ClanWarAttack()
{
DeploymentTroops(Golems, Pekkas, Wizards, BK[KingLevel], AQ[QueenLevel],...,......,.......);
InitializeAttackScreen(VillageID);
}

How hard that must be??

CoC's language is not a high-school project :straightface:

if you can decrypt the gs you'll see

SC has already released the statement about upgrading heroes in wars
if you don't want to believe it....

well, ignorance is bliss :smirk:
April 14th, 2015
sj74

SC has not ruled out letting heroes be available in wars. We have not even had a comment about the technical difficulty of doing it except from a community laison member (Anuschka) who freely admitted she was not a developer and didn't know how complex it was. See post here http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...24#post3858724

SC are aware that it would make lot's of people happy but as said previously it does make them money. So the long and the short of it is that it may happen some time we'll just have to wait and see. I for one believe that SC want to produce the best game they can, as they rightly believe that this will keep people playing and bring in the most revenue in the long term. So they may do it even if it harms revenue in a localised way (reduced hero regeneration anyone?).

..just wait and see.