upgrade walls without builder

As I told before, such feature is feasible but it needs some work. I thought few hours about this matter and I came up with new a solution: upgrading walls without a builder could be limited by time that is walls could be upgraded by forexample last 30% storage capacity just once a 72 hours. This on is more better and more practicable. I think instead of saying no its impossible,its not feasible etc that would be better you think about some solutions to improve such good suggestions and to improve the game. That's easy to go around threads and say no no not... planig,developing and improving is tough but valuble

No.. It's too convenient..

Quote:

Originally Posted by MrFailology

You've still not provided any sort of solution to the ridiculous lack of loot that will happen if this were to re-appear in game. Being able to upgrade walls whenever further encourages to dump your loot to prevent others from getting it, which means less loot for everyone. Right now people will only dump loot into walls whenever they have extra and are about to use a builder or when they are trying to max walls.

And to have a feature that you can always use and then lose because you're naturally progressing through the game is dumb and unfair. The only time this would ever happen is through game updates, which isn't apart of a mechanic's game design. Screwing over the higher level players to benefit the lower level ones has been done before and Clash took a beating for it.

Actually, he did provide a solution, though it might need slight tweaking...

The solution is that in order to upgrade wall pieces without a builder, you have to still have a certain amount in reserve when you're done spending your loot on walls. So you'd never be able to take the amount of loot in your storages below a certain level this way.

Now the OP suggested using a percentage, but I would change it to a hard #, probably 2-3.5m or so depending on the TH level...basically, whatever the cap for raidable loot is anyway. Using a hard floor instead of a percentage would eliminate any possibility of trying to game the system by not upgrading storages, and making that floor the same as the cap on raidable loot would mean that no loot is actually being removed from the raiding economy since you'd still have the same amount available to steal after purchasing walls.

There have been similar proposals for letting TH8 upgrade walls to level 8 using elixir, but either making it twice as much, or forcing them to hold a certain amount in reserve.

Neither of these are bad ideas, but I don't really see them being implemented because they add what is really an unnecessary layer of complexity to how the game is set up. That and Supercell may not like it since people won't be as tempted to spend gems to finish builds early if they max their storages and don't have a builder free.