Printable View
It would be nice to punish players leaving clan during war without doing 2 attacks. Missing 2 Attacks: reduce all ressources by 80% 1 missing attack: reduce all resources by 50 %. If there are no resources available then downlevel some some buldings or reduce some gems. It must be super pain to leave war !
Does this happens if they are kicked too?Quote:
Originally Posted by cx978
This game caters to so much noobness. I feel it sometimes protects idiots a lot. But then again, you can't fault them for it. They made a game everyone can play and should be willing to play.
I personally hate this idea.... I will leave an example of a way it can affect people poorly.
Jimmy is in a clan of 10 people who war constantly. They only want to do 10 player wars with only trusted members like Jimmy. One day a emergency happens in Jimmy's family, and he is unable to attack. Jimmy had 6mil saved up for a big upgrade. What happens because he doesn't attack? He is left with 1.2 million, making jimmy very angry
Also, down leveling is completely idiotic. Say some one is almost maxed, and misses out on his war attacks. His expensive buildings will suddenly disappear and he will have to farm the resources again. What if a level 4 Xbow is downgraded? There goes 8mil, making this unfortunate persons day a living hell.
Just in case they leave. Not when they got kicked. Not when they simply will not attack.
Still, a bad idea, such as the massive amounts of resources that can be lost.
Ok, so they troll the clan causing it problems so the leader kicks them. That would worse than if they simply left.Quote:
Originally Posted by cx978
So I take it a step further. The leader say, "I will not kick you no matter what you do. Unless you do your attacks you are stuck eating that penalty.." So the guy now is really mad so he trolls a little longer to make extra trouble, Fills all the cc with gobs as much as he can, then as soon as battle starts he drops one barb each on 2 attacks, and leaves without the penalty.
Do you think thats a problem with your idea that guys can just handle it that way? Would it not be better if the guy simply left? I am not saying its good, but is it not the lesser of two evils?
Yes this a big problem which have to be solved.
May be some light logic where an attack with less than 50% or more of the players army camp, troop spell and Clan castle capacity counts as zero attempt. Execption should be connection lost. This is easy to calculate and detect a player who does not realy attack.
I do not see any reason why there should not be a penalty if a player only trolls the clan.
Let US be clear that this behavior is very bad and makes all players angry. except KaiTheBeast0.
@KaiTheBeast0
This is only a sugesstion from me for discussion. You do not give any arguments. If you fear your resources then think twice before you join a clan war!
Yes indeed there should be warnings. In fact it someone leave CW. Maybe on CW enter. With do not show again option.Quote:
Originally Posted by jesseh
Please don't name and shame on the forum.Quote:
Originally Posted by cx978
I think your error why your ideas on this have problems is because they are all about what should happen AFTER you get screwed over. And now you are even starting to talk about have them try writing spaghetti code that still will not work. (writing routines that could analyze an attack and separate not trying from just not being very good at it would be very hard to do at all and no matter what anyone came up with guys would figure out how to trick the routine)
IMHO you should shift your focus to how not to get screwed over in the first place so then you are not worrying about what should happen after.