Idea for when a player leaves after being locked into war...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ectar

Its a game, it's not a job, there is no leadership, there is a community that only stay around as long as they get what they asked for

---

Hmmm, so your clan has no leadership huh? That would explain having problems like is being complained about here. The way it works is you either do the job and enjoy the benefits, or not do the job and not have the benefits, in fact suffer the consequences of it not getting done.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sylveonzmushi

Suddenly, the maxed out th 10 takes his attack. GG
My suggestion is that he could control his troops like... its hard to explain but he makes his own troops based on the leavers troop level and army camp space.. only problem is the skill of THAT player which could probably could never be dealt with or solved.
Yeah ^ that was edit.

---

Thank you everyone. I'm responding to Sylve, because its clear he didn't read the entire post. The extra raid would need to go to a player below the person who left. otherwise yes, the #1 guy would cleanup 100% of the time, thus creating an unfair advantage.

Yes, of course its about clan management and not letting suspicious players into war.. As a policy, for our clan in particular: We do not let anyone with a "new" banner war with us.

Unfortunately sometimes a player just up and leaves. Sometimes a player will sad quit, after failing their first attack. I'm suggesting an idea that would allow a clan to utilize all allowed raids, even if a player leaves.

I do believe its a decent idea that deserves to have a good look.. Appreciate everyones thoughts.

Clash on!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kyleksq

Thank you everyone. I'm responding to Sylve, because its clear he didn't read the entire post. The extra raid would need to go to a player below the person who left. otherwise yes, the #1 guy would cleanup 100% of the time, thus creating an unfair advantage.

Yes, of course its about clan management and not letting suspicious players into war.. As a policy, for our clan in particular: We do not let anyone with a "new" banner war with us.

Unfortunately sometimes a player just up and leaves. Sometimes a player will sad quit, after failing their first attack. I'm suggesting an idea that would allow a clan to utilize all allowed raids, even if a player leaves.

I do believe its a decent idea that deserves to have a good look.. Appreciate everyones thoughts.

Clash on!

---

Well said I have to admit. Yeah I do have the strong feelings about management, and do believe that. But I don't see anything wrong with your idea. I agree its worth a look.

The one thing I think you should address is the question a few asked about if its the bottom guy. I think in that case the attacks do become lost, but if its the bottom guy that is so easy to cover I don't see there being any stress.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

The one thing I think you should address is the question a few asked about if its the bottom guy. I think in that case the attacks do become lost, but if its the bottom guy that is so easy to cover I don't see there being any stress.

---

Thank you RW, I forgot about that.. And I feel the same: if its the bottom guy, no extra raids can be awarded.

In the rare instance its actually the bottom guy who leaves- there are still 9-49 players who can easily pickup that target. ;)