Encouraging donations, collect all, and heroes available for war when upgrading

Hi everyone! Here are my suggestions:

1. A lot of people, even senior members of clans, could be lazy or too stingy to donate troops to other clan members. Additionally, donating in clan wars also don't contribute to your donation score. While the term 'donate' means you don't expect anything in return, I think there's a good way to encourage more donations for both clan wars AND normal requests, and that's through small incentives. I think it's a good idea to reward donors with a little amount of gold for troops they donate, but only if the troops are high level enough, and the amount of gold reward also depends on what troops are donated.

For example, if one donates a level 6 (or higher) archer, he/she gets 1~5 gold in return. Level 5 and below don't get anything. Level 6/7 Giant will probably net you more, let's say 50~100 gold. Pekkas/dragons lvl 3 and above probably around 500 gold each? I don't know, I'm just throwing some numbers here, it's up to Supercell to decide on the suitable gold rewards. Hopefully it's not too much gold to the point it can be abused but also not too little for the elite troops, so that at least donors feel more encouraged to help their clan mates and at the same time feel slightly rewarded for their efforts and time spent training the troops.

2. When you tap on town hall, perhaps you guys can add a button to 'Collect All Resources'? That way we don't have to tap on all of the gold mines, elixir collectors and dark elixir drills one by one every single time. Some accidental wall upgrades or gem spending for speeding up etc. have occurred because of being too eager to tap on all these buildings quickly and so accidentally double/triple tapped on other stuff (that could be upgrading as well) that's in close proximity to these resource collecting buildings.

3. In clan wars, defense towers that are upgrading are still functional at their current levels. So why doesn't this feature apply for heroes as well? I humbly suggest that heroes be made available for deployment at their current levels in clan wars even when they are upgrading.

That's all folks, happy clashing!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by therockmmu

Hi everyone! Here are my suggestions:

1. A lot of people, even senior members of clans, could be lazy or too stingy to donate troops to other clan members. Additinally, donating in clan wars also don't contribute to your donation score. While the term 'donate' means you don't expect anything in return, I think there's a good way to encourage more donations, and that's through small incentives. I think it's a good idea to reward donors with a little amount of gold for troops they donate, but only if the troops are high level enough, and the amount of gold reward also depends on what troops are donated.
isn't that clan perks lvl 3? Maybe 4?

For example, if one donates a level 6 (or higher) archer, he/she gets 1~5 gold in return. Level 5 and below don't get anything. Level 6/7 Giant will probably net you more, let's say 50~100 gold. Pekkas/dragons lvl 3 and above probably around 500 gold each? I don't know, I'm just throwing some numbers here, it's up to Supercell to decide on the suitable gold rewards. Hopefully it's not too much gold to the point it can be abused but also not too little for the elite troops, so that at least donors feel more encouraged to help their clan mates and at the same time feel slightly rewarded for their efforts and time spent training the troops.

2. When you tap on town hall, perhaps you guys can add a button to 'Collect All Resources'? That way we don't have to tap on all of the gold mines, elixir collectors and dark elixir drills one by one every single time. Some accidental wall upgrades or gem spending for speeding up etc. have occurred because of being too eager to tap on all these buildings quickly and so accidentally double/triple tapped on other stuff (that could be upgrading as well) that's in close proximity to these resource collecting buildings
Very helpful and nice

3. In clan wars, defense towers that are upgrading are still functional at their current levels. So why doesn't this feature apply for heroes as well? I humbly suggest that heroes be made available for deployment at their current levels in clan wars even when they are upgrading
SC left a comment about this on a petition for that

That's all folks, happy clashing!

---

My replies in bold

The clan perks for donation troops refund, while my clan hasn't reached that level yet, I could only assume is elixir refund but only for a certain percentage. Do correct me if I'm wrong. Besides, that's only applicable for clan war donations. My suggestion for rewarding donors include both donations made in clan wars and for donating to normal requests outside of clan wars, and not with elixir refunds but with small amounts of gold. I know, it's kind of a long shot.

As for the heroes being made available for clan wars even when upgrading, I searched the stickys for a mention of this but couldn't find it. Maybe I didn't search hard enough but if you could or if you remember, pls do enlighten me on SC's reply regarding this issue.

Thanks a lot!

As a lvl 3 clan we get a pretty good refund. It is not up to you to decide whether someone should donate or not. If they don't donate, SC gives us the wonderful option of giving them the boot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mrkw

As a lvl 3 clan we get a pretty good refund. It is not up to you to decide whether someone should donate or not. If they don't donate, SC gives us the wonderful option of giving them the boot.

---

That refund is only for troops donated in clan wars, right? How about donations made to normal requests? And no, I'm not saying that it should be up to me to decide whether someone should donate or not. It's totally their right if they don't wanna donate, I'm just suggesting that hey, if you do donate, here's a little incentive for ya. And not just anyone who donates gets the incentive. Only those that donate high level troops get it. This is essentially just a way to encourage high level players to help out lower leveled clan mates.

Also, booting someone out just because they don't donate may seem kinda harsh. Perhaps we wanna keep them coz they consistently deliver good results in clan wars, right?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by therockmmu

That refund is only for troops donated in clan wars, right? How about donations made to normal requests? And no, I'm not saying that it should be up to me to decide whether someone should donate or not. It's totally their right if they don't wanna donate, I'm just suggesting that hey, if you do donate, here's a little incentive for ya. And not just anyone who donates gets the incentive. Only those that donate high level troops get it. This is essentially just a way to encourage high level players to help out lower leveled clan mates.

Also, booting someone out just because they don't donate may seem kinda harsh. Perhaps we wanna keep them coz they consistently deliver good results in clan wars, right?

---

The refund is applicable to all donations made. I don't see why you would only want to encourage high level players to donate, everyone should get the same rewards which they do. You receive more for lvl6 archers then lvl4 since they cost more to start with.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by therockmmu

That refund is only for troops donated in clan wars, right? How about donations made to normal requests? And no, I'm not saying that it should be up to me to decide whether someone should donate or not. It's totally their right if they don't wanna donate, I'm just suggesting that hey, if you do donate, here's a little incentive for ya. And not just anyone who donates gets the incentive. Only those that donate high level troops get it. This is essentially just a way to encourage high level players to help out lower leveled clan mates.

Also, booting someone out just because they don't donate may seem kinda harsh. Perhaps we wanna keep them coz they consistently deliver good results in clan wars, right?

---

If someone doesn't donate. They most likely are only there to help themselves and not the clan. What is the point of being in a clan?

I believe it is for all donations.

We just got it but no active requests to test. It says simply, "Donation Refund" nothing about war or anything.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by webbie

The refund is applicable to all donations made. I don't see why you would only want to encourage high level players to donate, everyone should get the same rewards which they do. You receive more for lvl6 archers then lvl4 since they cost more to start with.

---

Oh, I see. If it's applicable to all donations, then it's all good :) I can scrap this gold incentive idea since that's actually rewarding enough already.

As to why I would only want to encourage high level players to donate, well first of all it will no doubt help the lower guys farm and level up faster. And secondly, it's just that there were some cases where low level guys spam donate level 1~3 barbs/archers/giants even to TH8/9/10 guys (which are pretty much useless to them) just to boost their own troops donated score. I just don't feel that they should be given anymore rewards than that. It may not have happened to your clan before but I've seen quite a few cases in the number of clans that I was part of in the recent past. Sure we can just boot these players out of the clan. Hence why I thought only a certain high level of troops get rewarded so the lower leveled guys don't abuse this feature and the only guys who can donate high level troops are guys in TH8 and above.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuperBone

If someone doesn't donate. They most likely are only there to help themselves and not the clan. What is the point of being in a clan?

---

Haha! That's true, but see, some of us are old fellas who could be too busy at work and family and stuff. Some barely have the time to play or diligently check for donation requests and then train the troops requested and then donate them when ready. It's just too much for them. But they can still help the clan by kicking some serious butt in clan wars. :)