How is this th9 base ??

http://imgur.com/Wl7JHso, a member in my clan just created this new war base design. How would u rate it on a scale from 1-10 on design only!!. Not in how well his defenses are upgraded. Just design wise

4/10

Only on the basis that there are no DGBs to kill hogs.

However, this would require an entire base makeover.

Tell him to redesign it from scratch with that in mind.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hesto25

4/10

Only on the basis that there are no DGBs to kill hogs.

However, this would require an entire base makeover.

Tell him to redesign it from scratch with that in mind.

---

He once had an anti-hog base. But as a clan, we have yet to encounter a problem with hogs in 50 war wins. They seemed to have died out post-update. I see no reason for him to creat an anti-hog for the small chance that we actually encounter a hogger

Queen is easy to kill, cc is easy to pull, and as mentioned above, no double bombs. If you haven't run into hoggers, as your clan gets higher, you will. Might as well protect the best you can against as many attack types as you can, right? It's a mediocre base at best. Vs any decent clan it would be 3* with not all that much thought.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Karmaslap

Queen is easy to kill, cc is easy to pull, and as mentioned above, no double bombs. If you haven't run into hoggers, as your clan gets higher, you will. Might as well protect the best you can against as many attack types as you can, right? It's a mediocre base at best. Vs any decent clan it would be 3* with not all that much thought.

---

I'd have to disagree, were a fairly high lvl clan, mostve in the lvl 80-95 range. & the higher we get up, stratigys Becom much more complex than a simple hog. & if u prepair a hog base you weaknen yourself to other atks. But the base did well in the war so far, defended itself against a lvl 3 drag raid, about 40%, one star. Keep in mind we do not face Max lvl clans yet guys.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ravenwood1

I'd have to disagree, were a fairly high lvl clan, mostve in the lvl 80-95 range. & the higher we get up, stratigys Becom much more complex than a simple hog. & if u prepair a hog base you weaknen yourself to other atks. But the base did well in the war so far, defended itself against a lvl 3 drag raid, about 40%, one star. Keep in mind we do not face Max lvl clans yet guys.

---

Honestly, defending against a dragon raid at th9 isn't an accomplishment. That's normal as a th9. But the base itself isn't bad IMO. I agree with the Queen being too easy to lure though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ravenwood1

I'd have to disagree, were a fairly high lvl clan, mostve in the lvl 80-95 range. & the higher we get up, stratigys Becom much more complex than a simple hog. & if u prepair a hog base you weaknen yourself to other atks. But the base did well in the war so far, defended itself against a lvl 3 drag raid, about 40%, one star. Keep in mind we do not face Max lvl clans yet guys.

---

Why ask for help, when every time someone puts there opinion you shut it down and say they're wrong.

It's a mediocre base that is really nothing special. It will get the job done, but I wouldn't settle on it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Neokilla

Why ask for help, when every time someone puts there opinion you shut it down and say they're wrong.

---

It's not really that, its the fact everyone always brings up hogs:/, if that's all we have to worry about, I'm not worried:/ & it's also discussion

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by charizzle

Honestly, defending against a dragon raid at th9 isn't an accomplishment. That's normal as a th9. But the base itself isn't bad IMO. I agree with the Queen being too easy to lure though.

---

Thank bud, this actually helps. I'll tell him to rethink queen position. Should he also relocate the king as well ??