Donating troops

it seems as if the SAME clan members are donating their troops while you have MORE non-donating clan members...... and I do not like the fact that you have to or may KICK those non donating clan members from the team

after making several requests for donations and you receive a few or no donations..... my idea would be to forcibly TaKe 1 trooper from each clan member to fill the remaining gap that exist in your clan castle

these Troopers would come from your top tier clan members on the first round and your middle tier clan members in the second round or request for troopers..... OR maybe just 1 trooper from each clan member for especially small clans ( it would be a random selection for the type of fighter or trooper selected to be taken )

What do you guys think about this suggestion and do you believe it's fair ??????