Strategy Hut

A new mid-late game building which allows you to run a simulation of a village attack
The units you have avaliable are the ones you will be able to use, but you can use them without spending the ones you've made
You can simulate an attack on your base or on another players base

I like the idea of simulating an attack on your own base

Why a new building? If the Town Hall is so important, and there is hardly any function, other than trap reset and target, just make it as part of the Town Hall Upgrade.

Heck, while at it, add in things to help teach people how to use troop combos. Single player had so much potential to do just that, give people a lession on how to play, but fell short of that, since with no unit limit, you can Barcher many mid stage bases as a TH8 with some effort for a total victory. :rolleyes:

There's a huge problem with attack simulation: I could just copy my enemy's base and see how my attack works

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MNvikingsfan1

There's a huge problem with attack simulation: I could just copy my enemy's base and see how my attack works

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Read Before Posting sticky thread

Major Additions:
* Dueling/challenge/simulator/sparring battle area

---

Yes, that is the very first thing listed on the sticky thread as a possible addition.
Let's just admit it. That's what people want, a way to plan and see how things work. Instead of letting just game modders use thier sandbox cracked programs, even things out a bit and give everyone access to roughly the samething.

Makes logical sense, since it is such a common impulse to do.

Instead of have it run as a full battle, could be a stylized miniature battle that runs in 'turns', pausing every so often so you can look at how things would likely go.at each stage. Would have it's own graphics, with minitures, and the landscape is either a map, or a wooden table.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

Yes, that is the very first thing listed on the sticky thread as a possible addition.
Let's just admit it. That's what people want, a way to plan and see how things work. Instead of letting just game modders use thier sandbox cracked programs, even things out a bit and give everyone access to roughly the samething.

Makes logical sense, since it is such a common impulse to do.

Instead of have it run as a full battle, could be a stylized miniature battle that runs in 'turns', pausing every so often so you can look at how things would likely go.at each stage. Would have it's own graphics, with minitures, and the landscape is either a map, or a wooden table.

---

That is exactly what i had in mind: A tabletop simulation with a pause option to see how its all going.

I intended to make this tool a bit more self focused, so you could see your own base weaknesses. To leave it a bit less over powered, when you are running the simulation on a enemy base, there are no traps, so in the simulation you could have won, but in the actual battle, your troops would be devastated by a large bomb, or a tesla.

I was just about to make a thread about this. I think its a great idea to have a simulation to test troops and practice with army compositions. I know it would save me a lot of loot. But the simulation part is simple, just put 2 possible selections. Your base and a random computer generated base at the town hall level of your choice. Then it wouldn't be attacking another player as far as you would know. And even if you used your base to recreate an enemy's base, its not like you could recreate their clan castle troops or their trap placement. If you somehow managed to memorize all the traps and were able to place those properly too, you shouldn't need any more practice on this base. Sorry if I restated something from above, didn't actually read all of it.

It would be fun indeed. Here are the two arguments against it...

1. it would get used as a mini game of sorts. - I actually don't have a way to say it won't. But think this is a small thing, I believe in my heart most would use it for strategy planning. Or for within clan competition and smack talk, which I see more as being a fun thing than a bad thing. (I would want to post the replay of taking down the leaders base)
2. Guys would copy a war opponent and practice on it - Probably true, guys would. So make the it unavailable during war and that settles that problem.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MNvikingsfan1

There's a huge problem with attack simulation: I could just copy my enemy's base and see how my attack works

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

Guys would copy a war opponent and practice on it - Probably true, guys would. So make the it unavailable during war and that settles that problem.

---

Exactly...

I would like the idea of an attack simulation building, but why not do something called TESTING OUT YOUR BASE/ATTACK STRATEGY?