Printable View
When a person requests troops and you click donate, the box pops up with what you have available.
Now reverse that,
When a person requests troops a box pops up with the troop options, they choose what they are requesting.
Now only the troop/troops selected is what can be donated.
Personally I hate getting goblins.
Personally I hate getting five archers when I ask for loons or minions.
I kick people out who can't follow requests, because we don't have this feature.
I make people donate me dragons.....
You are doing the right thing sir!! And you have already solved your problem.Quote:
Originally Posted by RockyJoeHawkins
Guys that do stuff like that are just going to mess up other ways too. Its pretty clueless behavior so I think we are save assuming them to be general liabilities You are better off for having kicked them. You improved your clan with the subtraction.
Thank you,Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
That's great for a tough run clan, but the game can also be played by nice people who just want to have fun. I really don't like kicking nice new people who don't really get the competativeness of others.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
My compromise solution is that requests have to be honoured to the letter during the request period, but for old requests you may donate whatever. Except for war requests. Unfortunately, this is too hard for some, especially with inadequate provision to write out clan rules like this.
I still want a tab for internal rules, strategy, etc, like the description text, but a bit longer and private within the clan. That may help.
But more specificly for this problem, I wish I could place conditions on troops receiveable, a technical restriction that lasts for a certain time, maybe 20 minutes, maybe 1 hour. Some restriction is important. If someone asks for something that is not going to be provided, I don't want to see the request forced to hang there until scrolled off the bottom.
I also woruldn't mind choosing what fellow clan members can give to you. I often ask for hogs or dragons during war and get wizzards and archers (which are great, but are NOT dragons or hogs). As rwelshjr said though, if someone gives you wrong troops, you can just kick them.
Lower level players in my clan often ask for expensive stuff without good reason. I let them wait, then later give something else. Any technical restriction should allow for that.Quote:
Originally Posted by jzitovsky
Most players don't make it clear whether they are requesting a preference or a specific need. People requesting dragons or pekkas when they have prepared a bar her army annoy me. Some prompted options in requests could be good.
Yes, also addressable by firm clan management (kick people who can't follow instructions, but where go the instructions?)
Second this..on more than one occasion I have had to write out a clan wide mail message reminding people to not treat those who request specific troops as their trash can for unwanted troops. I have had tight war attack windows messed up because I needed a PEKKA for a GOWIPE and got a dragon...it is a stupid mess that can be fixed by highlighting which troops are acceptable when asking..and there could even be an 'any' option. Simple, awesome, and necessary fix. Great idea!
We have a member always donating barbs there should be a way to control what can be donated I had the same thing happen going to war instead of golem coming out its barbs and wbs now I just have to check what's in cc everytime. Were still hunting that member.
I would like this along with level requirement. It drives me up the wall when someone gives me a dragon when I want balloons or something. Dragons are cool but I don't always want them.
Level req would be for war donations really. When I ask for balloons I need at least level 5. Any other time I don't mind level since the lower guys want to contribute also.