Improvement for XP and Perks system

Printable View

April 2nd, 2015
Syph000

Improvement for XP and Perks system

Dear clasher and expecially dear supercell staff,

my clan mates and me are a little bit frustrated about the newly introduced XP system.
We are a war clan and to us the last update was the most exciting update since clan war has been introduced but we don't like how the XP are gained.
We won almost every war (now at 133 wars won) and 3-starred the half of the enemy bases on average.
Since now we gained the 99.8% of the XP available in our wars but still we are at level 3 while other clans are already level 4.

We would like that the XP are gained as the loot in war: if you loose the war you gain very few XP and for getting the most of them you have to win and possibly with very good results (maybe according to the total number of stars instead of the 1-starred villages).

As it is now, you gain more XP by having not extraordinary performances with 50 people than winning all the time with 35 people.
I think that by simply changing the system as it is for war loot you will reward the clans that really worth to be higher level.

I hope you will consider it and I will be glad if some of the stuff can reply just to know that you read this message.

Thank you very much in any case for all the efforts in making this game the best strategic and exciting game ever existed!! :thumbsup:

P.S. I will just add a poll to see how many people share my opinion (democracy rules! )
April 2nd, 2015
awesomness2016

How would this be an improvement?

The idea behind clan perks was to encourage more clans to participate in wars. Yes, it does give a decided advantage to larger clans, but I think the idea behind this is that they don't want to encourage clans with 50 people telling half the clan they can't war because they only want to bring their best attackers, which would definitely be a more frequent occurrence if XP was based more on winning wars than participating.

Seems to me like there's a much easier solution to this problem...as a level 3 clan with 133 war wins, it should not be that difficult for you to recruit enough solid attackers to fill up your clan, maintaining your win ratio, and leveling up faster.

Now if you really want to talk about improvements, I think there are other ways that Supercell could award XP. FOr example, total number of troops donated, or for reaching certain point/trophy thresholds (which would encourage lower level clans to trophy push...a thing I think is sorely needed).
April 2nd, 2015
Heresahint

Well how would that make the other ppl feel

If a clan with fifty ppl only had 25 of there troops attacking then the other ppl wouldn't get as much loot and might feel left out so they would end up just leaving the clan
April 2nd, 2015
EmeraldRange

Quote:

Originally Posted by awesomness2016

How would this be an improvement?

The idea behind clan perks was to encourage more clans to participate in wars. Yes, it does give a decided advantage to larger clans, but I think the idea behind this is that they don't want to encourage clans with 50 people telling half the clan they can't war because they only want to bring their best attackers, which would definitely be a more frequent occurrence if XP was based more on winning wars than participating.

Seems to me like there's a much easier solution to this problem...as a level 3 clan with 133 war wins, it should not be that difficult for you to recruit enough solid attackers to fill up your clan, maintaining your win ratio, and leveling up faster.

Now if you really want to talk about improvements, I think there are other ways that Supercell could award XP. FOr example, total number of troops donated, or for reaching certain point/trophy thresholds (which would encourage lower level clans to trophy push...a thing I think is sorely needed).

How did you read my mind. :thumbsup:
One of the reasons SC wasn't super enthusiastic about implementing Opting was that it would increase people not participating in the not-all-the-clan wars. It makes perfect sense that the reason (minor if not major) perks were added was to counteract that downside to the widely-requested Opting.

The perk system is really just a way to reward participation and clan loyalty, not to be a way to see how good the clan is (although that was inevitable).