Two ideas for solving Clan War missmatch

Printable View

April 1st, 2015
Quake

Two ideas for solving Clan War missmatch

There could be divisions of clan wars. A new table appears after you select how many players will play in clan wars.

We`re all frustrated about the clan wars, when you get ugly clans and there is no way you can beat them, so I’m suggesting this type of clan wars. Every clan would have a percentage of their clan wealth, how much they are progressed.
We would have Divisions similar to trophy league; just it would have some limitations to access them.

Example:

My clan has 78 wealth % (Wealth Calculation: Clan players base defense and offensive troops average)

And you have 9 divisions; you can enter two of them all the time. (There could be more, but SC have to decide this, I don’t know how many clans we have in this game, so I use an example as 9 Divisions)

Each one of them has limitations to every warring clan. There are no exceptions.

As you will see we have Divisions by wealth and used one idea for perfect matchup in clan wars http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...t=missmatching. The algorithm would have to match that particular league that you entered and the queue time.

I’ll explain now about the wealth that we can enter with.
Ok.. So all the clans can enter Divisions by their wealth +4-5%(This should also increase or decrease depending on how many clans we have in clash of clans) . I’ll show by math for better understanding.

So my clan has 78% of wealth so I can enter two Divisions:
3. General
4. Unbreakable.
Why?

My Clan 78% + 4% = 82% (3. General Division)
My Clan 78% - 5% = 73% (4. Unbreakable Division)
(I made +4-5% that it wont be a three Division pick: 75%+5% = 80% or 75% - 5% = 70%, You could still pick the fourth Division)
So.. Now we can get 18% stronger opponent on low chance. You can win after all.

What happens when you unlock new Division.

Rewards: I just put it optionally, it can be without them. It just looks nice :rolleyes:

Very simple ideas should solve a lot of problems. I add a Poll. Vote Yes or No.

Any questions? Suggestions? You’re welcome.

P.S. I also would like Shortened Preparation time for war by one hour, to keep wars at the same time. Give thoughts on this pls as well.
April 1st, 2015
CaptainSport

Clan mismatch isn't a big problem IMO. Do your best and you will win 90% of the time!
Yes my clan does get mismatched quite a lot.
April 1st, 2015
Qmegali7

If you are looking to solve mismatches, http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...mismatch-issue is probably one of the best answers. No, waiting for war isn't two hours, it is until the interval. This could also be a one hour interval thing. There are many possible ways of it working well--and if you don't care, you shouldn't care about this passing anyway.
April 1st, 2015
Quake

Quote:

Originally Posted by Qmegali7

If you are looking to solve mismatches, http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...mismatch-issue is probably one of the best answers. No, waiting for war isn't two hours, it is until the interval. This could also be a one hour interval thing. There are many possible ways of it working well--and if you don't care, you shouldn't care about this passing anyway.

I always wait 40-50 minutes till i get someone to war and we get always bigger opponent. So i would consider to wait for 2hours, to get a better matchup. Sometimes does happen when you get a clan in 15 minutes. There is no mismatches, but if it takes longer, that you know you will get :thumbsdown:

And you did not read it good. I've used that idea as well.