☞【New Clan War XP Syste】☜

Our clan is not strong, but our war record for the past few month is about 30-1. Almost every clan we face have same/better troops then us, but NOT ONE CLAN attack properly, they either attack with ♥♥♥♥ty troops for 1 star, or attack with good troops with ♥♥♥♥ty strategy. Where is the fun in this???

Admit it, the current system sucks, and would take over a year to reach level 10 if you clan is awesome and works really hard.

---

- Win Clan War: +50XP (no change, it's good)

- Defeat an enemy: +5XP (consistent for every victory, even for those who got aced already)
- If enemy is X TH level above/below you, you gain/lose X amount of XP on top of the 5XP.

- Get Star: +1XP for every new star gained. (larger war = more star = more XP)

- Successful Defense: +5XP (consistent for every successful defense, even if previous defenses weren't successful)
- If enemy is X TH level above/below you, you gain/lose X amount of XP based on the 5XP.

- Get 1/3 and 2/3 of total star: old system, no change

- Get all stars (perfect war): Double them amount of XP you get from 2/3 total star achievement.



Nothing OP, harder you work, more you get, plus losing side will actually lose more than the 50XP. Also #1 TH9 attacking #40 TH6 will no longer give the same amount of XP as a TH4 attack TH6.

I don't like it.

This system rewards "farm clans" and people who hit above the level where they can 3 star.

I also don't like successful defense, because that is independent on the other clan.

I think this can only work if the following features were removed:

Defeat an enemy that has not already been starred: current system - XPfor attacking already starred bases would mean that farm clans which snipe #1 and #2 would get boatloads of XP that they don't deserve.

Get star: +1 XP. sure. The XP per level would have to be rebalanced.

The perfect war idea is interesting but it is dependent on a lot of factors (what clan you are matched up against, how well/poorly their bases are designed), so I think that the bonus should be decreased and the threshold would be 9/10 total XP?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by X7386

I don't like it.

This system rewards "farm clans" and people who hit above the level where they can 3 star.

I also don't like successful defense, because that is independent on the other clan.

I think this can only work if the following features were removed:

Defeat an enemy that has not already been starred: current system - XPfor attacking already starred bases would mean that farm clans which snipe #1 and #2 would get boatloads of XP that they don't deserve.

Get star: +1 XP. sure. The XP per level would have to be rebalanced.

The perfect war idea is interesting but it is dependent on a lot of factors (what clan you are matched up against, how well/poorly their bases are designed), so I think that the bonus should be decreased and the threshold would be 9/10 total XP?

---

Farm clans is not a big problem, a few extra XP is fine, the system should increase the speed winning/losing side gain XP.

Again, if enemy clan sucks, they gain nothing and you gain more, which pushes people to build better bases and attack properly.

The point of this system is so people will try harder to win wars, just so you know our clan have won the past 20 wars and every clan we faced have the attacking power to wipe us all out, but they do lousy attacks with lousy army, and their base design just sucks. It was not fun for us at all, and I'm sure it's not fun for you either.

Its honestly fine the way it is. Why do you care if other people only 1 star. You're still getting 50 more xp than them in the end.