Printable View
I doubt supercell will ever made this come true, because features like this will made side effect of people tend to gem less....hi roller player gems every problems they have...including gemming a requested troops instantly. So a bank of troops that made troops available without making players have to wait?...no thankyou.
I just posted the same idea, and someone told me it was suggested before ...
My idea is : http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post6866475
it's almost the same as suggested here, and for me it's a must.
Great Idea! I'm the leader of my clan and tired of spend many hours waiting from clan members to go online and ask troops for the war (it's annoying some members just can't wait somebody goes online, they attack without troops..)
I support this, but only for the wars!
SorryMyBadEnglish :p
I love it! Our clan has players in different time zones that attack when we are sleeping so this would be great to put troops in before we get off. I hope they implement this soon. 👍
Great idea - and would love to see it in the game , dont know how much super cell will be supportive of this (and comments above saying this will prevent use of gems to some extent)
Still few tweaks on the idea and should work :
- First - don't give members an option to take troops , let that be controlled by elders / co / leaders, who can donate troops from their own camps or use the bank to donate
- I know this also defeats the purpose of having a bank and people getting troops whenever they want , but someone has to control it to prevent leeches / hoppers
- plus gives a whole new meaning to elders now - which actually makes sense , they should have a better role to play in the clan (than just a tag and to invite members)
- Now think about supercell - why should they do it (if it prevents gemming?) and how do we justify the effort they have to spend to make this functionality available . For this I can only think one thing -
- To open a clan bank you will need to spend gems (not a lot but 1 gem for say 5 capacity), and the bank should be available for the entire season (one month) - close to the end you need to refill or the troops are lost
- which again brings up the question who will spend it ? that should be a combined effort from all clan mates who want to use that - and should be a choice on who wants to be a part of the bank (like membership - spend your CC capacity worth of gems to be a part of the bank - only those members would be able to donate to the bank or receive from them) -
- kinda similar to war opt in /out button
I honestly think it might be a lot of work for the development community to implement this change :p to have a bank (where to store these details / actual feasibility in the game) but seems to me that this will be like a dummy base in each clan with camps where people can see the donated troops - and clan members will work on improving the capacity of the troops (start with one camp - and keep building/upgrading them)
Hope it works and my comments help balance out players/supercell both :)
Alex
I liked the idea and I support it
I called it a donation pool
Questions and suggestions:
What if the bank is full of low level troops? Can the leader choose a minimum level for each troop? (Level 5 barbarians, level 2 dragons, etc.
The required donations for recieving troops seems too high.
hoppers should have a probation period where the can't withdraw from bank.
Do spells come into this?
In conclusion, this is a great idea, with me being an active donator myself. I would love too see this come into the game, so great suggestion!
I agree with you. In a clan like mine, people have different level of troops. If a troop bank is to be implemented for daily use and people can collect what they need only, low level troops may be neglected, and the bank may be filled with troops no one wanted...Quote:
Originally Posted by 3runinho
So, a clan war castle troops is more practical since we need only the best units in clan wars.
Love the idea. I made a thread thinking about this exact idea without even seeing this thread. With this concept, I think new clan membership ranks need to be implemented, as a certain rank can only draw from the bank. Every clan has one of two leachers who think they're entitled to drawing out a pekka to raid with at their leisure. That's fine for top end raiding clans, but the majority of us reserve those troops exclusively for war only.