Clan [Troop] Bank

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

September 28th, 2015
MaGnOoN

fantastic

It is a very good idea .k hope from the Developers to do it .this one and tne night mode then the game will be fantastic😍👍
October 3rd, 2015
Kowalski711

Quote:

Originally Posted by VideoGameStar

I haven't read all the 300 replies and sorry if I make a pointless bump, but I saw that the troop storage limit and believe that is dangerous, because people can store those troop amount and retrieve as they like from others. Example, the box is full and you're the only player online, you will end up taking away every troop from the box, of every type!

And, this would make CoC a bit too easy, because you'll have any troop within your reach, so I believe it is better to make a total troop limit instead, like...

Clan Lv.1 30 troop limit
Clan Lv.2 45 troop limit
Clan Lv.3 60 troop limit
Clan Lv.4 80 troop limit
Clan Lv.5 100 troop limit
Clan Lv.6 125 troop limit
Clan Lv.7 150 troop limit
Clan Lv.8 175 troop limit
Clan Lv.9 200 troop limit
Clan Lv.10 250 troop limit

This is to avoid players having a wide variety of OP troops for your CC. 15 dragons in a bank would be chaos, do you even know the housing space they would all have? 300. And with everything else added you would have infinite troops! So, this is what I had in mind when you posted this idea and saw the troop limits. The troop limit is = to the housing space. Example: Clan Lv.5 has 100 housing space in their bank, they can add for example, up to 5 dragons, or 3 golems, or 4 PEKKAS. That means that their bank would be limited, so they don't have an nearly infinite variety of troops.

I may be new here, but I'm good at game balancing and trust me, it is better to keep things like this as I've pointed out. Don't you think?

With a strong case like that, i will add it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperJosh

I support this idea one hundred percent

Thanks!

Quote:

Originally Posted by BarchTheDeco

Bro this is so good idea! Yay Yay!

Thanks!

Quote:

Originally Posted by LayoXavier

Its good I like it

:)

Quote:

Originally Posted by janezfinal

i like this idea - however it still pending on SC - we never know if this suggestion will be in or out . based on SC decision since this thread is months ago.

Patience is a virtue.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaGnOoN

It is a very good idea .k hope from the Developers to do it .this one and tne night mode then the game will be fantastic😍👍

Glad you like it!
October 3rd, 2015
JasemAli

I love it

this is the first thing I like to have in the next update ;);)
October 4th, 2015
Kowalski711

Quote:

Originally Posted by JasemAli

this is the first thing I like to have in the next update ;);)

Thanks, and glad you like it!
October 9th, 2015
shorisharvuut

Great initiative! We absolutely want it! although it might create dispute.
October 11th, 2015
HummmDinger

I thought this was "my new great feature request" so I send in game feed back. support replied "no, would get abused" I asked how and was directed to the forums. .. found this in the sticky, and you have addressed all the abuse issues. great job. implement asap! :)
October 12th, 2015
Coastal

Great idea.

I have thought about this for a while. I didn't know this site existed until recently, so thought I would add my thoughts. Here was my plan for a troop bank before I read that my idea wasn't unique:

Participation is optional to clan members.
Only members who bank troops can withdraw troops.
Donations/withdrawals based on your current cc level.
You can only withdraw what you donate.
Withdrawal troops don't level up like regular donations.

Why I thought of this:
We have a level 7 clan with a wide range of time zones. Usually when I hop on clash for some raiding, I have been hit and my cc is depleted. I will raid for a while to build up loot for upgrades. When I need to get off, I request defensive troops for my cc. Many times, there may not be other mates on to fill request. Therefore, I keep playing until i get the troops. Second option, is to just stop and assume I will get robbed before I return to play again.

My plan doesn't benefit hoppers or lower level mates. They get taken care of enough already. It also prevents would be abusers of the system.

I have been a TH9 for 3 days and I get raked when I am offline. My CC capacity is 25. I would gladly deposit those troops before I started raiding so that I had insurance when I was ready to stop. There are times that I could raid, but don't for fear of having no CC defense. If I do one raid and pull 500k gold and elixer combined, it is going to get taken back the first time I get raided without cc troops. I end up just riding the shield provided from previous fleecing until I know there are active mates online.

Why Supercell should adopt this:
It is a need that I have almost every time I play.
It's simple enough to be a positive addition to the game without affecting other aspects of the game.
It doesn't diminish Supercell's ability to gain revenue via gem sales.
There really is no way to abuse this system that I have thought of.

Just my thoughts. Your idea is much more thorough than mine. Thanks for posting as any troop bank would be better than nothing. My thought is that the simpler it is, the more likely it is to be considered.
October 12th, 2015
AsadKhan

Nice idea.. This idea will help me in wars....👍
October 12th, 2015
ClashOn4Life

I like the idea, but I think the troop holding space should be increased a little bit for lower lvl clans and that new members should wait x time before being able to prevent hoppers coming in and stealing your troops.
October 12th, 2015
thecoolkyle

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

Photos provided by Hairich

http://i61.tinypic.com/ngdjjr.jpg

http://i59.tinypic.com/xc2aeb.jpg

I got got these photos from a different thread, so replace the words "Troop/Donation Box" Clan [Troop] Bank.
Thanks!

OMG that's me in the picture!!!!!!! Hahahaha

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page