Clan [Troop] Bank

Bank and get achievement easy u can donate too fast

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rogerrrrr

Bank and get achievement easy u can donate too fast

---

No you still have to have a rank and/or have the "new" rank go away to donate or withdraw

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rogerrrrr

Bank and get achievement easy u can donate too fast

---

You don't get anything towards your achievement without someone else pulling the troop out of the Bank. if your troop is not pulled out then you don't get a tally to your achievement.
I believe we also said something about Clan leaders being able to trash some troops because they are not good. Or maybe it was to allow them to have a have a max of __ troops at __ level.

Just thought of this, maybe there should be a time limit added as well. Your troop only lasts 48 hours in the bank. (could be 24 but I figured 48 to cover a full war prep/attack time) This would cut down on the clutter in the bank and keep people that are just looking for donation achievements from overloading the bank.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Coachamurton

You don't get anything towards your achievement without someone else pulling the troop out of the Bank. if your troop is not pulled out then you don't get a tally to your achievement.
I believe we also said something about Clan leaders being able to trash some troops because they are not good. Or maybe it was to allow them to have a have a max of __ troops at __ level.

Just thought of this, maybe there should be a time limit added as well. Your troop only lasts 48 hours in the bank. (could be 24 but I figured 48 to cover a full war prep/attack time) This would cut down on the clutter in the bank and keep people that are just looking for donation achievements from overloading the bank.

---

You know, that could work. Maybe 72 hours at most? What does the community think eh?

1: no time limits on donating. - yes to withdrawing... - Just like in the stock game...
If this is really going to work, you need to consider that in many clans - there are 2 or 3 people who provide 100% of all war troops... Those players - should be able to fill the bank - immediately - just like they can fill the war castles in a clan war or 40 troop requests in clan chat...

2: you should get experience for donating to the bank... you did donate after all - you get experience for donating every other place - in a Req and leave clan - in a war castle - everywhere... Standard game rules should apply - Across the board - for every comparable feature. Receiving experience only after the troop is used puts un due stress on the servers to remember every last person who donated every single item to know who to give exp to a day or a week later... not to mention the partial elixer refund... no... it has to be stock - standard - like the rest of the game.

3: - Elder to use the bank? NO... I dont know about your clan; but elder in mine - takes ten wars - multiple weeks... lots of work... - MONTHS of time for some players to earn their elder rank... We make players really work for Elder. - each of our seven clans has about 5 to 10 elders out of 45 members... If elder was a requirement to use the bank - it would be a useless perk.. because our elders all know how to go to a different clan and find max level troops and come back to attack... If you have members who MOOCH - kick them out... dont let them in ... interview better...

4: time limit to use the bank - 'new' has to go away -- NO no no... when you have multiple clans - where Elder is hard to earn - and you move members around -- they will always be new... for months they will remain 'new' -- every time they hop into the sister clan and return they are new again... -- BAD idea. If you have moochers - kick them out. dont punish everyone.


*About leachers... I run a low level clan - th 3 to 6 players all around... our high level players donate 100% of all war troops - every war - every castle - every attack - both attacks - my low level members all have horrible awful donation ratios cause I give them evreything... I dont WANT them using their weak little troops... i dont want them sharing weak troops... -- so in some cases - a player with a bad ratio-- is not a bad thing...

5:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kowalski711

The bank CAN'T I repeat CAN'T get full of troops, however there is a catch, a limit on troops. Clan leaders can change this limit of course. This limit includes all levels and not just one in particular
the default limit is....

These limits are to prevent only low level troop donations witch will pile up as high level troops are taken

To prevent crazy donation numbers, your donation amount (let's say 30) is split in half to a total of 15 and if you donated an odd number that decimal is rounded up. Once you join a clan you have to be in the clan long enough for the "new" rank to go away. At this point you CAN start donating, but you can't receive until given a rank.

---

I'm totally confused here -- if the bank CANT get full of troops - then why are there any limits at all? let people put 10 millon level 1 goblins in there if they want... -- no this sounds very odd...

In a 45x45 war - a clan will easily use 120 max loons.
They will use about 40 hogs
In a day worth of barching - they will easily use 500 archers - if not more like 2000 a day... If you really have an active clan of 40 some people who are going to play for 6 to 8 hours... they will tear through your bank. - you know every one of them will want the best troops...

This game is very simple and the makers keep it that way... To do this bank - this last topic here is the most important one... How to set each troop - how to limit each one... No easy way to do it...

This would require an entirely new way of donating ALL troops - gone would be the days of Chat filled troop requests... you would simply have to route ALL troop requests through the main clan bank. If this were done - then odd requests could stay there for ever... and not disappear in chat after 100 lines have been spoken.

The easiest solution - is to offer one new 'clan castle request' screen - that shows the entire available troop listing - and let you simply click the plus / minus button beside each troop that you want... Just like the War Camp screen -


There are three fair ways to figure the size.
1: I would recommend the following 'camp' limits to be calculated in a very FAIR and PROPER fashion.
-Add the combined size of all current clan members castles. If you have 40 members with 20 slot castles - thats 800 slots available in the clan bank. If you have 10 members with 10 slot castles -- thats 100 slots available in the bank.

2: Have X number of spaces for every member who joins; regardless of their town hall level.

3: Have X number of spaces based upon Clan perk level. -- perk 1 is 10 slots per player -- perk2 is 20 slots per player - etc.

4: Have X number of spaces based upon clan perk level - and DONT base it on the membership levels - just make it a generic size for everyone.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by blombardo

1: no time limits on donating. - yes to withdrawing... - Just like in the stock game...
If this is really going to work, you need to consider that in many clans - there are 2 or 3 people who provide 100% of all war troops... Those players - should be able to fill the bank - immediately - just like they can fill the war castles in a clan war or 40 troop requests in clan chat...
I agree, I thought I had put that in for withdrawing :confused:
I'll change that :)

2: you should get experience for donating to the bank... you did donate after all - you get experience for donating every other place - in a Req and leave clan - in a war castle - everywhere... Standard game rules should apply - Across the board - for every comparable feature. Receiving experience only after the troop is used puts un due stress on the servers to remember every last person who donated every single item to know who to give exp to a day or a week later... not to mention the partial elixer refund... no... it has to be stock - standard - like the rest of the game.
You do get XP, but only after your troop has been taken (Says somewhere in the last few paragraphs)
3: - Elder to use the bank? NO... I dont know about your clan; but elder in mine - takes ten wars - multiple weeks... lots of work... - MONTHS of time for some players to earn their elder rank... We make players really work for Elder. - each of our seven clans has about 5 to 10 elders out of 45 members... If elder was a requirement to use the bank - it would be a useless perk.. because our elders all know how to go to a different clan and find max level troops and come back to attack... If you have members who MOOCH - kick them out... dont let them in ... interview better...
That's the point, it's a feature that can REALLY help, but needs to be earned none the less.

4: time limit to use the bank - 'new' has to go away -- NO no no... when you have multiple clans - where Elder is hard to earn - and you move members around -- they will always be new... for months they will remain 'new' -- every time they hop into the sister clan and return they are new again... -- BAD idea. If you have moochers - kick them out. dont punish everyone.
That's there to prevent someone joining, getting free elder, taking troops, and leaving. It's one of those things that, if the forums community doesn't like it, easily can be removed.

*About leachers... I run a low level clan - th 3 to 6 players all around... our high level players donate 100% of all war troops - every war - every castle - every attack - both attacks - my low level members all have horrible awful donation ratios cause I give them evreything... I dont WANT them using their weak little troops... i dont want them sharing weak troops... -- so in some cases - a player with a bad ratio-- is not a bad thing...

5:


I'm totally confused here -- if the bank CANT get full of troops - then why are there any limits at all? let people put 10 millon level 1 goblins in there if they want... -- no this sounds very odd...

Long story short, I made some edits to add a limit, looks like I forgot to remove that part :3
Thanks for catching that - it's been fixed :)

In a 45x45 war - a clan will easily use 120 max loons.
They will use about 40 hogs
In a day worth of barching - they will easily use 500 archers - if not more like 2000 a day... If you really have an active clan of 40 some people who are going to play for 6 to 8 hours... they will tear through your bank. - you know every one of them will want the best troops...

This game is very simple and the makers keep it that way... To do this bank - this last topic here is the most important one... How to set each troop - how to limit each one... No easy way to do it...

This would require an entirely new way of donating ALL troops - gone would be the days of Chat filled troop requests... you would simply have to route ALL troop requests through the main clan bank. If this were done - then odd requests could stay there for ever... and not disappear in chat after 100 lines have been spoken.

The easiest solution - is to offer one new 'clan castle request' screen - that shows the entire available troop listing - and let you simply click the plus / minus button beside each troop that you want... Just like the War Camp screen -

Exactly, in my 2nd post there is a photo showing a little box, that you click on and a new interface shows up.

There are three fair ways to figure the size.
1: I would recommend the following 'camp' limits to be calculated in a very FAIR and PROPER fashion.
-Add the combined size of all current clan members castles. If you have 40 members with 20 slot castles - thats 800 slots available in the clan bank. If you have 10 members with 10 slot castles -- thats 100 slots available in the bank.

2: Have X number of spaces for every member who joins; regardless of their town hall level.

3: Have X number of spaces based upon Clan perk level. -- perk 1 is 10 slots per player -- perk2 is 20 slots per player - etc.

4: Have X number of spaces based upon clan perk level - and DONT base it on the membership levels - just make it a generic size for everyone.

---

Replies in bold

Great idea :-) but would this count towards the 'friend in need' achievement?

I like it, would be awesome to have during wars. And I agree that it's irksome at times, having to wait for hours for your cc to fill because everyone else is busy or asleep. The purpose of the current "Live" donation system isn't keeping people online, after all.

Maybe lower the amount of hounds and golems you could keep in bank. Could get a bit overpowered

Didn't read all the way. Understand the theory. Totally agree for the times you want to clash when you clan mates aren't online. I am in a clan that is from my hometown so everyone is on at the same time but also offline at the same time. I know that the clan I am in isn't the only one like that. Lots of players play with their friends so I know I am not the only one