Clan [Troop] Bank

Clash of Clans is all about association. The idea is great but not needed. Remember that Clash of Clans has been a phenomenon because it's simple but versatile. Too much additions such as these will make the game obsolete.

Remember, the keyword for games like this is "activity". Players must play. So if we have a bank, I don't have to stay "ON" and wait for online players, simply because we have a bank.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by moki149

it would be good if they had an option similar to the im in/out for war that decided whethter you could take donate to the troop bank. Only leaders, co-leaders and maybe elders could change this option on players profiles. Other than that i would love to see this in the game.

---

It would still have to be earned - and more open to hoppers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by aveydee

Clash of Clans is all about association. The idea is great but not needed. Remember that Clash of Clans has been a phenomenon because it's simple but versatile. Too much additions such as these will make the game obsolete.

Remember, the keyword for games like this is "activity". Players must play. So if we have a bank, I don't have to stay "ON" and wait for online players, simply because we have a bank.

---

Yes i agree. Clash is great in that way, but every so often you'll find that 1 mil raid, and say "♥♥♥♥!!! I need CC troops!!!" and nobody is online!!! And lets be honest, id be so mad to see that 1 mil raid wasted. This idea will help you, me, and your clan mates always be restocked on troops.

Troops you withdraw from the clan bank should go to your clan castle. Doing this should count as requesting troops. There should also be a ratio, for example: You can withdraw one troop for every troop you donate. This would apply to troop housing space, not quantity.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Orion328

Troops you withdraw from the clan bank should go to your clan castle. Doing this should count as requesting troops. There should also be a ratio, for example: You can withdraw one troop for every troop you donate. This would apply to troop housing space, not quantity.

---

They do go to the CC. Thought I mentioned that. Oops. As for ratio its changeable by the leader. For instance 1:1 2:1 etc

This is a good idea but I don't think this should be implemented as it can RUIN THE PLEASURE OF "REAL TIME" GAMING

the fun of the game is that it is played on Real Time events .

Donation banks can take away the pleasure and excitement when we need our friends to be online for us ..

I dislike the idea. Mainly because since most clans are active, donations get filled when you're offline, or usually someone will tell you they're cooking a troop. To be fair, it feels like an idea for people too impatient to wait for troops. So I say no.

These two ideas would work together nicely.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ositions-Roles

This needs to be implemented instantly. Next update I expect to see this. The clan bank is the best thing I have ever seen in my life. It makes perfect sense. Especially if you are in a small clan during war. This way everyone donates to the bank before wear and now you have troops for war. I really love this idea, and I am furious that anyone could dislike this idea.

Also, there are many times when I make an army to donate to people who are still attacking in war because already used my attacks but then I can't empty the army to attack normally because I have to wait to give everyone troops. This is an instant solution.

SUPERCELL THIS IS THE BEST IDEA

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 789firespawn

I dislike the idea. Mainly because since most clans are active, donations get filled when you're offline, or usually someone will tell you they're cooking a troop. To be fair, it feels like an idea for people too impatient to wait for troops. So I say no.

---

Sorry firespawn but you must be in a 20+ member clan but there are COUNTLESS clans that have less then 20 people and the clan chat is not active every second or every hour of the day. Maybe you should be a bit more open minded. Some people like to donate to get their friend in need achievement up but everyones clan castle is full. This bank would be incredible because then I can donate non-stop.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by viniGodFather

This is a good idea but I don't think this should be implemented as it can RUIN THE PLEASURE OF "REAL TIME" GAMING

the fun of the game is that it is played on Real Time events .

Donation banks can take away the pleasure and excitement when we need our friends to be online for us ..

---

Great for you! You enjoy realtime. But don't reject this idea and be selfish. Just close the clan bank and don't use it in your clan. Not everyone likes realtime gaming and some people don't like to spend all day on clash of clans waiting for troops and would rather just go on and take troops to attack in war with.