Clan History

I'm sure this has been requested before, but couldn't find it... We need to be able to view clan history stats. War logs seem to only be kept for a week... Not good enough. Why expire at all. I don't need to see all the replays, but let us see the stats from the war so we can tell who isn't using all their battles, who never gets any stars, who the best attacker/defender is, etc. Only being able to see this info for a week is not helpful enough. I realize that I could keep a spreadsheet of this stuff on my own, but honestly, it's a game, not work. We shouldn't have to manually track that ourselves.

Also, new leagues start on sunday nights (I think). Once a new league starts, we can no longer see how many troop donations each use had for that time period. Since donations get reset with every league period and running donation totals are not available to us, I must try to go in at the very end of the league and write down number of troop donations for each member. Then, do this for EVERY league session. A league history showing all this would be great so we can track these numbers without doing it manually. I am a clan leader, I don't want to be a clan secretary...

I like this idea. It's a good way to keep track of performance over time. Before SC implements this, you can use a separate spreadsheet for the data, though that will take a little work. Just a little.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by docmattman

I'm sure this has been requested before, but couldn't find it... We need to be able to view clan history stats. War logs seem to only be kept for a week... Not good enough. Why expire at all. I don't need to see all the replays, but let us see the stats from the war so we can tell who isn't using all their battles, who never gets any stars, who the best attacker/defender is, etc. Only being able to see this info for a week is not helpful enough. I realize that I could keep a spreadsheet of this stuff on my own, but honestly, it's a game, not work. We shouldn't have to manually track that ourselves.

Also, new leagues start on sunday nights (I think). Once a new league starts, we can no longer see how many troop donations each use had for that time period. Since donations get reset with every league period and running donation totals are not available to us, I must try to go in at the very end of the league and write down number of troop donations for each member. Then, do this for EVERY league session. A league history showing all this would be great so we can track these numbers without doing it manually. I am a clan leader, I don't want to be a clan secretary...

---

for the fist problem our clan does something called feeding time (other clans call it other names) where we kick everyone who doesnt use both attacks or obviously just goes for loot, that should be a solution to your first problem. And for your second problem you can look at the achievement friend in need in their profile (might be called something else, forgot) (btw its on the left side near the bottom) and it will show how many troops that person has donated

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Epthian

for the fist problem our clan does something called feeding time (other clans call it other names) where we kick everyone who doesnt use both attacks or obviously just goes for loot, that should be a solution to your first problem. And for your second problem you can look at the achievement friend in need in their profile (might be called something else, forgot) (btw its on the left side near the bottom) and it will show how many troops that person has donated

---

Yes, we kick new player who don't use both attacks as well. However, if we have a clan member who has been with us for a little while, will will give them a pass if they miss a war. So, it makes it tough to see if the user has battled in a few previous wars and what their performance has been. Also, I'll see someone attack someone too high level for them (not necessarily for loot, but out of false self-confidence). They think they can 3 star, but end up getting 1 or 0. I want to look back at previous wars and see if the user has done the same. If this type of behavior is a pattern, than that user should get booted. But the history just isn't there to look at.

I am aware of the Friend in Need achievement, however, I am more interested in how many troops they have donated while in our clan. Our clan has a requirement (we are relatively small and are recruiting) that all new members must donate 100 troops before we allow them to go to war with us. Before the update that let us choose our roster, we were getting burned by new members who would leave the clan in the middle of the wars without battling at all. We lost a few wars by less than 3 stars because of this reason. So after the update we require all new members to donate 100 troops before being included in wars. We haven't had a single problem with a clan member leaving in the middle of a war since then. However, if a new member joins, donates 50 troops, then the league resets, they donate another 50+ troops... We can't tell if they have donated 100 troops total or not. Also, after a certain amount of time (a week or 10 days maybe?), the user isn't indicated with "new". So we could have a member that isn't marked as new anymore and has less than 100 donations, but we don't know if he has been a good donator in previous leagues or not.

I would guess that SC probably keeps records of all this stuff (it's most likely just small info in a database somewhere). It would just be nice if we could see it for ourselves somewhere.

It would also be also be incredibly useful if SC gave us an API to access our clan stats/history, so I could make a website for the clan and post all current and past info. But I'll settle for this information being accessible in-game for now...

It's not hard to keep track tbh. I manage to do it and you can always pull out paper or use notes in your phone. Seems like a personal prob.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich

It's not hard to keep track tbh. I manage to do it and you can always pull out paper or use notes in your phone. Seems like a personal prob.

---

You're absolutely right, it's not hard. However, it is work. The game would be more enjoyable if we didn't have homework to do along with it. I find your response to be particularly useless. This is a suggestion for a game improvement in the "ideas & feature requests" forum. While it may not be a top priority item for SC to work on, I think you would be hard-pressed to find someone who doesn't agree that this would be a game improvement. I have no doubt that SC has this data easily accessible to them. I'm merely saying that it would be nice to have it available to us as well instead of needing a "clan secretary" to write it all down and duplicate it for our own records.


This is obviously not an issue if you have a full clan loyal, ideal members. This idea would help out those of use who are looking to build strong clans with loyal members. Recruiting can be a big pain, this would help a lot with that process.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by docmattman

You're absolutely right, it's not hard. However, it is work. The game would be more enjoyable if we didn't have homework to do along with it. I find your response to be particularly useless. This is a suggestion for a game improvement in the "ideas & feature requests" forum. While it may not be a top priority item for SC to work on, I think you would be hard-pressed to find someone who doesn't agree that this would be a game improvement. I have no doubt that SC has this data easily accessible to them. I'm merely saying that it would be nice to have it available to us as well instead of needing a "clan secretary" to write it all down and duplicate it for our own records.


This is obviously not an issue if you have a full clan loyal, ideal members. This idea would help out those of use who are looking to build strong clans with loyal members. Recruiting can be a big pain, this would help a lot with that process.

---

My post wasn't pointless. It was feedback generated towards a commonly suggested item. There is no reason to implement a feature for players who are lazy. This is like adding a calculator to the game when there are apps out there that calculate your troop cost and players can do it by hand.


Like I said. You would know your more senior members. You take the names left after war and you didn't kick hem; put it in notes with a (1) to show they missed 1 war. And the next war will end. You'll say "oh he's a senior member; was he here last war?" you can then go back and check and see he wasn't. Issue solved and no one had to implement any kind of coding for this. The best solution since there is now a war opt in and out; is make them not war of they miss 1 or kick them. This a avoid issues in the future.

Again, your issue is solved by how I said above; if your idea got added; you'll still have to go look through. What I suggested is faster than your idea and has 0 coding.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich

My post wasn't pointless. It was feedback generated towards a commonly suggested item. There is no reason to implement a feature for players who are lazy.

---

If this is such a commonly suggested item, then why would there be no reason to implement it???



I'm not worried about "senior" members. It's the new members, and the members that are new but don't have the "new" status. I don't consider a user to be "senior" after being with the clan for a single war. What I suggested doesn't really require any coding anyway. SC already codes the war stats. I'm just asking that they keep it available and not take it away from us after a week. They already have it, why not leave it for us to see.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich

Again, your issue is solved by how I said above; if your idea got added; you'll still have to go look through. What I suggested is faster than your idea and has 0 coding.

---

So you think keeping your own stats and looking through them is faster than just looking at stats the SC has already generated??? Interesting...



None of what you just said helps me to keep a running total of all donations for clan members either. Donations get reset each season. Part of the clan stats would keep track of all that so we clan leaders can better manage our clan. It seems like you have a problem with data that is already collected being available for us to see. I understand that you "manage" to do it all yourself and I can too. However, I'd prefer an easier way, hence the suggestion...

It's odd to me that you're basically trying to argue that having more information about our clan available to us wouldn't be valuable.