War castle troops

As a Leader, I want to have specific troops in the war castles. I get people who want to help and put level4 troops in them. Unless the person is online to delete them, I can't fill them with what I want in there. Give the Leader the power to delete any clan castle troop.

Great idea and I support this fully! I had the same problem with this for the longest time. After about 3 weeks of blasting messages through inbox I finally got everyone on board. I had to implement a rule that only co-leaders were to fill CC troops. This helped, but being able to edit what troops and delete troops out would be great.

I don't need it to count towards my donation achievement. I just need to make sure my clan has the best chance to win! It's not quite as easy as saying you'll kick out whoever fills troops because there is no way of knowing who donated what, and I can't be on 24/7 unfortunately to make sure I fill as soon as the Prep time starts.

too much control to the leader. It becomes his war and not a team effort. Definitely do not give that to co-leaders. Co-leaders can sabotage the war and leave. Leaders can do that as well, but not as likely. I don't think it should happen.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by edomingox

too much control to the leader. It becomes his war and not a team effort. Definitely do not give that to co-leaders. Co-leaders can sabotage the war and leave. Leaders can do that as well, but not as likely. I don't think it should happen.

---

I support this idea. I don't have an issue with leaders having this power. If they abuse it (which is unlikely), tell them to stop (have a clan vote, if necessary). If he persists, then the people who don't like it can leave and form their own clan.

If you're in a clan with a leader who you think would sabotage a war and leave, then you shouldn't be in that clan! No reasonable leader would do that!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ShaneHed13

So you are telling me that you have low level people in your clan who continually donate bad troops to clan castles and you're solution is to give the leader/co-leader power to override what people have in their base? It sounds like what a leader is for is to make sure this doesn't happen in the first place. This shouldn't be a problem in a well run clan. Our clan knows that the top 5 players donate as soon as the war starts, and if there is any room at the end, other people can donate right before the war starts. You have the power now to leave people in your clan who donate poorly out of wars, or to tell people who you think are having poor troop decisions in their CC to change them. If they don't you can opt them out of wars as well. I think there is enough power with the leader/co at this point and if you are continuing to have problems, drop the opt/out hammer a couple of times and people will fall in line (people cannot donate to wars if they are not in them).

---

This from another thread on the same subject.

ShaneHed13 is correct. Allowing the leader to remove troops is just not a good idea.

Read the thread for the debate on this: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...+remove+troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ClashMoney

I support this idea. I don't have an issue with leaders having this power. If they abuse it (which is unlikely), tell them to stop (have a clan vote, if necessary). If he persists, then the people who don't like it can leave and form their own clan.

If you're in a clan with a leader who you think would sabotage a war and leave, then you shouldn't be in that clan! No reasonable leader would do that!

---

This is 100% accurate. If you're in a clan where the leader would sabotage a war, leave the Clan!

As a leader of my clan I spend over a million elixir every war donating troops trying to win. My war win bonus is 700k so I lose out on elixir every war. This doesn't matter to me though I'm more concerned with winning. So when some bozo low level in my clan donates level 2 giants into someones castle I should be able to remove it.

As our clans grow and people leave, we always recruit new players. Since they have not been with the clan very long they may not know. I have some players who want to help but don't realize they are doing more harm than good. I also spend over a million in elixer in troops, war cc's, war attack donation troops. It doesn't bother me because I want to win the war. This would be a major improvement in Clan Wars. This war is not the Leaders war, because every star counts, offensively and defensively. It is a collective team effort.

Yeah, this will help all clan leaders. :)

this will help most clans but if someone wants to sabotage there own clan I mean really come on if the leader did that they don't deserve to be leader a leader is someone who respects there clan and clan members listen and decides based upon that that's what I do and it works for my clan and yes I BACK THIS UP 100% it will help all leaders across clash great idea and thanks for posting it

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...c-troops/page3

posted the same thing a while ago, i think i got more negative responces tho