Printable View
I'm with welsh on this one. Too much to be learned by our young/growing members when they can see the bases we are discussing and the tactics we plan to use against them. Had a spy join once. Booted him in the first 30 seconds. Had a few more apply. Simply rejected their request. Make sure your co-leaders are feel empowered to do the same and the problem doesn't exist.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Why important? can you explain more?
War is an event, and if someone is not in that event, it's normal to not see bases... not joining but seeing base is not fair...
that's your choice I think. Clan means for us is not only making war. Making war different job than being in clan. Someone comes, someone goes. Many people stays. We are dynamic clan , we want to recruit and want to make war in same timeQuote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
well as far as i know 99% of people have the same base for both war and farming/rush (normal base) so you're idea doesn't make much sense, and to be frank if you're getting spied to much during clan wars it's because stupidity hasn't got any cure (just lock your clan and it'll be alright mate)
In a casual/farming clan (primarily what mine is) that also wars this is completely untrue. Effective base layouts for farming and wars are very different. Using the same makes you either easy to farm or easy to get war stars from.Quote:
Originally Posted by napileon
Folks up in master leagues may have similar bases but the objectives of PvE and wars are different enough that they should still have at least subtle differences. The otherwise useless storages placed as bait so their high HP will make attackers stop longer to be attacked for instance.
Seems like I'm one of the view that thinks this is a good idea!
War is war, and spying is just a part of WAR. Every WAR game out there incorporates some form of spying, some even going as far as to make a specific unit called "spies". In clash spying is actually preventable so no need to take away this potential strategy.Quote:
Originally Posted by SirUltimate
Um why can't you still recruit? Are you just accepting any join request? Or are you actually recruiting by talking to people from global?? If you're doing the second part you should have very minimal potential of having spies join. If youre just accepting any and all requests, well thats your fault for not taking the proper preventive measures.
This idea, as well as any other anti spy idea is :thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown:
I think, you should just check if the member who is requesting to join is a member of the other clan to prevent spying.
BTW, spying is a part of any war. Be it CoC or any other real war.
Judging how "spy" is in the COC dictionary I do not think they are too concerned.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ans-Dictionary
Clash of Clans Dictionary Sticky
X-Mas Tree- Christmas tree
Season- the cycle of two weeks where at the end of one donation counts, leagues and top clan leader boards are reset.
Comp- short term for Army Composition
Spy- a person who joins a enemy's clan in order to obtain trap and tesla locations
Design Virgin- a person who has not posted or showcased any base designs
Flying Solo/Loner- a player who prefers to be clanless
You can just close your clan then spys cant join all together...
fairly certain thats not official, maybe to keep the spying aspect, "NEW MEMBERS" see it as enemy base type, but ranked members see it as normal i.e. an elder or co-leader.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheRealchrism
then you that enjoy "spying" and donating goblins randomly to people.. can still do so if they EARN a rank within the war parameter