Surviving Maxed Dragons From Battle Would Be OP

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xitra

Hmm, maybe I misread what Warren was trying to say? I also read what he said in this other post of his, and between the two posts, I wasn't quite sure if he was saying that we should be more open-minded about allowing troops to return, or if was just explaining why other people keep arguing for it...

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Json8r

Weve talked in other threads too, he meant people should be open minded to both sides, but i think he is against adding this

---

Sorry for the flip-flopply-ness of my one post, but yes I do keep an open mind to things.

Basicly, if you get troops back, as-is, no maintenance costs, troops come back healed, no changes to how defence is handled, and not do whatever Boom Beach does in it's system; then no, that would be totaly overpowered, and unbalance the game horribly. I could raid weak places with dragons or PEKKAs and have little fear of unit loss while bring in loads of loot.

The only way Supercell can even hope to add this in is if they do some drastic changes to the game. So many changes I'd think that some people may say it isn't "Clash of Clash" anymore.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheOneTheyCallSmasher

The rules actually say no bumping btw

And I still don't get the point of this thread. You have pointed out that the idea is under consideration, and even before it is added, you are starting a rebellion against it?

---

That bumping thing ik

Im not starting a rebellion in talking about it:smirk:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

Sorry for the flip-flopply-ness of my one post, but yes I do keep an open mind to things.

Basicly, if you get troops back, as-is, no maintenance costs, troops come back healed, no changes to how defence is handled, and not do whatever Boom Beach does in it's system; then no, that would be totaly overpowered, and unbalance the game horribly. I could raid weak places with dragons or PEKKAs and have little fear of unit loss while bring in loads of loot.

The only way Supercell can even hope to add this in is if they do some drastic changes to the game. So many changes I'd think that some people may say it isn't "Clash of Clash" anymore.

---

Like you said, boom is built around this. I play boom, so i can say that while this feature works there, it would ruin clash.

i never thought of that idea, i might go up to silver and find out if its good or not if it ever is implemented >:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JerrytheScary

i never thought of that idea, i might go up to silver and find out if its good or not if it ever is implemented >:)

---

Up???? Lol

I still wonder why this idea is not outright ruled out. As we know, even ruled out ideas could be added later, however very unlikely.

Given how biased the regular players are with the dogma of no returning troops, this topic is, as far as I can gather, is defaco ruled out, via public opinion from the momentum of established rules. (Basicly the idea of it has been this way from the start, and will always be this way, and changing will cause too many issues)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WarrenJames

I still wonder why this idea is not outright ruled out. As we know, even ruled out ideas could be added later, however very unlikely.

Given how biased the regular players are with the dogma of no returning troops, this topic is, as far as I can gather, is defaco ruled out, via public opinion from the momentum of established rules. (Basicly the idea of it has been this way from the start, and will always be this way, and changing will cause too many issues)

---

Forget ruled out, why is it being considered:cool:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Json8r

That bumping thing ik

Im not starting a rebellion in talking about it:smirk:

---

What I'm saying is that why complain about an idea SC haven't even added to the game yet??

Well Json8r, did you read the beautifully noticeable text above the considered ideas list? It says NOT to post threads about them, and to use the search bar. A bit of irony for a person who is telling fresh spawns to read the stickies don't you think?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by trooperc007

Well Json8r, did you read the beautifully noticeable text above the considered ideas list? It says NOT to post threads about them, and to use the search bar. A bit of irony for a person who is telling fresh spawns to read the stickies don't you think?

---

This is not a request for it to be added