Printable View
if you leave during the war you should still be able to view the warpage and use your attacks, that way you could enter a war in one clan, leave join another clan, and then view the war page and the war you are in is still there, you cant war with the other clan till its finished anyway, and you would get the loot if you are in the clan or not so this should be a simple option and it helps clans that sometimes get hoppers, since its in their interest to attack since they are in the war anyway
Honestly, most of your ideas are awful and can be easily be exploited. For example, clan hop and constantly be attacking to get huge loot bonuses.
Yeah I disagree. It's encouraging clan hopping. If you want to be elsewhere then stay there. No need to add a feature cause you want to hop around.
i dont want to hop arround, they are already in the war and sometimes people leave, you cant make them stay and they are locked in war so it would discorage hopping as they cant get away from the war anyway, they cant join a new war untill the old one finished, it simply makes the game better as you wont have to worry about mass exodus at the start of war meaning your war is pretty much over before it begins wasting two whole days, some people want to war but thier clans dont wanna war, this has zero downsidesQuote:
Originally Posted by GanjaSandwich
clan hop = still in war, you are already in the war anyway, you could go back and fight, but why do that when you could just fight outside the war in another clan, you cant join multiple wars can you? but this way if you are in a war and you leave or get kicked, you are still in the war and still get to make your attacksQuote:
Originally Posted by FishFishFish
you cant exploit attacks in war, you could lose on purpose but who does that hurt? you thats it
you could snipe exposed th? well anyone could do that and they would get kicked, but they would still get the loot now, also they only get to do it once if you kick them they cant join the next war
fact is if you are selected for a war you should be able to compete in that war regardless of circumstances,
none of you can tell me a way this can be abused that isnt already a way it can be abused now, this just makes the game better and more fun
They added the solution to this. You don't wanna war you opt out. You wanna war then you can get 10 people in your clan to war and have someone start it. Half my clan doesn't war.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ectar
It doesnt discourage hopling. It'l breaks the system. I leave during war. I can still attack but this means I can go join another clan and just sandbag my attacks. IF they don't care enough to stay in te clan to war; you really think they'll care enough to attack? Nope. And they're already locked in a war. Only thing you're suggesting is being able to participate while not in a clan. That makes no sense. You don't start war solo for one.
major flaw:
I join a clan. I'm still listed as being in war and since I can attack my war menu shows my war. Well what if I already did all my attacks? I can't look at the clan I'm in war. All it shows is my old clan. So me looking at my new clans war would be impossible. And I would still get a bonus even though I wasn't there in the clan during war.
Sounds great
Join a clan for war loot. Leave after it starts. Never return.
maybe you dont wanna be in that clan, maybe they dont want you in there, either way if you are in a war its not fair on someone for you to not be fighting in that war, you dont get the next war, but this war you can attack and get loot bonus, clan can still win war, you cant do anything else war related untill its over and why should you lose out on loot and why should the clan lose out on the attacks you might make?
It hurts the clan when they sand bag attacks. Unused attack is the same as a 0%. And I just listed how it could get abused so:smirk:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ectar
BAM YOU JUST MADE THE POINTQuote:
Originally Posted by Ectar
You should lose out on loot because you bailed on your clan during war. You're weren't there to give donations.Quote:
why should you lose out on loot
Just get a loyal clan like damn it's not that hard