Printable View
To prevent clan-hopping, it's best if players are subjected to a two-day cool down before being able to join another clan. This way they will think better about their choices of joining a clan instead of bouncing from clan to clan every couple of hours.
It's so annoying opening up the clan for anyone to join at X trophies because we constantly have people join and leave immediately, 1/2 the time it's people joining to leave a website link and then leaving immediately. But still, it makes the whole clan look horrible when people join and see a full wall of "joined, left, joined, left, joined, left" serioiusly. We can fill up our entire clan chat in a few hours just from people joining and immediately leaving without even considering the clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeannessp
I agree that this would be an awesome feature for clan leaders, however it is a part of the game to be able to join and leave clans at will. This can become tedious for clan leaders, but it's a part of the game. The people you really want in your clan, the loyal ones, will come and this cool down doesn't affect them. Thanks for your suggestion!
People have valid reasons to leave clans. Not all leave immediately but are just trying to find a home. How would you distinguish between them and the more annoying hopper ?
An enforced cool down before joining another clan would disadvantage them greatly and would not solve all hopper issues.
Nice thought but bad idea.
this would potentially kill donation clans
Sometimes people try to find the perfect clan that fits them, you can't expect everyone to be a hopper.
__________________________________________________ _______________________________________________
When tempted to fight fire with fire,
remember, the fire department always uses water.
😄😄😄😄
Good meaning, but wouldn't work. It would make it so people couldn't visit friends, and pretty much end all donation clans and recruiting on global...
How about a 8-12 hour cooldown for joining clans?
That gives a huge incentive for players that join in the morning to at least stick it out for 8 hours of the day before they quit in the evening (if they still want to quit). That would allow players to join up to two clans per day (unless staying up 24 hours, which would be 3 clans/day), and also severely decrease the chances of getting a clan hopper who joins and leaves within 5 seconds (not exaggerating).
Indeed, Req & Go clans which do a good deed for lower level players would cease to exist.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jomarx3me
It would also make it difficult to visit related clans, which is another reasonable reason to switch clans in a short space of time.
Hopping is annoying, but this idea restricts the above and other circumstances.
With the new opt-out in war just ignore the hopper. If someone new join you clan and leave what does it matters? They request and don't give. Just instate a rules where you have to donate first or better don't worry too much about the 5 donated archers you lost. If they join and request dragon/PK/Golem etc first without saying anything ... well you be the judge about if you should give it to them from the get go.:smirk:
Before it could be problematic if they leave in a war. Well give them a couple day probation period where the leader opt them out of war if they stay long enough and participate the leader can opt them in the next war.
If you think hoppers are bad player why do you want to keep them in your clan??? With the cool down you will have people leaving after 8/12/24 hours I don't see anything gained by that. I want to get rid of unreliable people from the get go.